Quantitative integration of single-subject studies: Methods and misinterpretations

被引:7
作者
Kollins, SH [1 ]
Newland, MC
Critchfreld, TS
机构
[1] Western Michigan Univ, Dept Psychol, Kalamazoo, MI 49008 USA
[2] Auburn Univ, Auburn, AL 36849 USA
[3] Illinois State Univ, Normal, IL 61761 USA
来源
BEHAVIOR ANALYST | 1999年 / 22卷 / 02期
关键词
D O I
10.1007/BF03391992
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
Derenne and Baron (1999) criticized a quantitative literature review by Kollins, Newland, and Critchfield (1997) and raised several important issues with respect to the integration of single-subject data. In their criticism they argued that the quantitative integration of data across experiments conducted by Kollins et al. is a meta-analysis and, as such, is inappropriate. We reply that Kollins et al. offered behavior analysts a technique for integrating quantitative information in a way that draws from the strengths of behavior analysis. Although the quantitative technique is true to the original spirit of meta-analysis, it bears little resemblance to meta-analyses as currently conducted or defined and offers behavior analysts a potentially useful tool for comparing data from multiple sources. We also argue that other criticisms raised by Derenne and Baron were inaccurate or irrelevant to the original article. Our response highlights two main points: (a) There are meaningful quantitative techniques for examining single-subject data across studies without compromising the integrity of behavior analysis; and (b) the healthiest way to refute or question findings in any viable held of scientific inquiry is through empirical investigation.
引用
收藏
页码:149 / 157
页数:9
相关论文
共 42 条
[1]   CALCULATING EFFECT SIZES FOR METAANALYSIS - THE CASE OF THE SINGLE-CASE [J].
ALLISON, DB ;
GORMAN, BS .
BEHAVIOUR RESEARCH AND THERAPY, 1993, 31 (06) :621-631
[2]  
[Anonymous], 1990, The future of meta-analysis
[3]  
[Anonymous], 1988, MATCHING LAW
[4]  
BARON A, 1983, PSYCHOL REC, V33, P495
[5]  
Baron A, 1982, Behav Anal, V5, P143
[6]   THE EXPERIMENTAL-ANALYSIS OF HUMAN-BEHAVIOR - INDISPENSABLE, ANCILLARY, OR IRRELEVANT [J].
BARON, A ;
PERONE, M ;
GALIZIO, M .
BEHAVIOR ANALYST, 1991, 14 (02) :145-155
[7]   ANALYZING THE REINFORCEMENT PROCESS AT THE HUMAN LEVEL - CAN APPLICATION AND BEHAVIORISTIC INTERPRETATION REPLACE LABORATORY RESEARCH [J].
BARON, A ;
PERONE, M ;
GALIZIO, M .
BEHAVIOR ANALYST, 1991, 14 (02) :95-105
[9]   2 TYPES OF DEVIATION FROM MATCHING LAW - BIAS AND UNDERMATCHING [J].
BAUM, WM .
JOURNAL OF THE EXPERIMENTAL ANALYSIS OF BEHAVIOR, 1974, 22 (01) :231-242
[10]   ON THE DIFFICULTY OF STUDYING BASIC BEHAVIORAL PROCESSES IN HUMANS [J].
BRANCH, MN .
BEHAVIOR ANALYST, 1991, 14 (02) :107-110