Diagnostic error in the Emergency Department: follow up of patients with minor trauma in the outpatient clinic

被引:32
作者
Moonen, Pieter-Jan [1 ,3 ]
Mercelina, Luc [2 ]
Boer, Willem [1 ]
Fret, Tom [1 ]
机构
[1] Ziekenhuis Oost Limburg Genk, Dept Anesthesiol Crit & Emergency Med & Pain Ther, Schiepsebos 11, B-3600 Genk, Belgium
[2] Ziekenhuis Oost Limburg Genk, Dept Gen Surg, Schiepsebos 11, B-3600 Genk, Belgium
[3] Ieperstr 43, B-2300 Turnhout, Belgium
来源
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF TRAUMA RESUSCITATION & EMERGENCY MEDICINE | 2017年 / 25卷
关键词
Diagnostic error; Primary missed diagnosis; Minor trauma; Emergency department; Malpractice; Fracture; MALPRACTICE CLAIMS; ADVERSE EVENTS; DECISION RULES; INJURIES; ANKLE; RADIOGRAPHS; FRACTURES; CARE;
D O I
10.1186/s13049-017-0361-5
中图分类号
R4 [临床医学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100602 ;
摘要
Background: The Emergency Department (ED) is prone to diagnostic error. Most frequent diagnostic errors involved " minor" trauma. Our goal was to determine how frequently a missed diagnosis was detected during follow up and to determine the frequency and causes of primary missed diagnosis and diagnostic error. Methods: A retrospective single centre study review, during 6 months including all patients presenting to the outpatient clinic after ED admission with a minor trauma. We defined primary missed diagnosis versus diagnostic error. Demographic data were collected in Excel file and analyzed using.2 and unpaired T-test. Results: Inclusion of 56 patients leading to 57 missed diagnoses representing 1.39% of all minor trauma patients presenting to the ED. History and physical examination notes were incomplete or inadequate in respectively 17/56 and 20/56. Most frequently missed diagnoses were ankle (13/57), wrist (8/57) and foot (7/57) fractures. Causes for diagnostic error could be categorized into two main groups: failure to perform adequate history taking and/or physical examination and failure to order or correctly interpret technical investigation. In 6 cases (0.14%) diagnostic error was confirmed. All other cases were defined as primary missed diagnosis. Discussion: Emergency physicians have to remain vigilant to prevent and avoid primary missed diagnosis (PMD) and diagnostic error (DE), certainly in case of minor trauma patients, representing a large proportion of ED patients. We observed a prevalence of 1.39% of missed diagnoses within a six month study period. This is comparable to previous studies (1%). However in our study both primary missed diagnoses and DE were included. Using this definition we saw that only one case could be attributed to negligence and DE had a prevalence of 0.14% (6 cases). X-rays remain the mainstay investigation for minor trauma patients, however in certain selected cases (pelvic and spinal trauma) we advise early CT-scan. Follow up in an outpatient clinic or other forms of planned follow up have to be provided and help to reduce PMD and DE. Conclusion: Both primary missed diagnosis and diagnostic error have relatively low prevalence but have a serious impact on patients, hospitals and medical services. Planned follow up after adequate explanation can help to prevent diagnostic error and detect primary missed diagnosis, thereby reducing time to final diagnosis and risks for medico legal litigation. Reassessment of diagnostic error on a timely basis can be used as a key performance indicator in a quality assessment program.
引用
收藏
页数:7
相关论文
共 21 条
  • [1] Bartlett E E, 1998, J Healthc Risk Manag, V18, P62
  • [2] What is the effect of reporting all emergency department radiographs?
    Benger, JR
    Lyburn, ID
    [J]. EMERGENCY MEDICINE JOURNAL, 2003, 20 (01) : 40 - 43
  • [3] Do emergency physicians and radiologists reliably interpret pelvic radiographs obtained as part of a trauma series?
    Bent, Clare
    Chicklore, Sugama
    Newton, Alastair
    Habig, Karel
    Harris, Tim
    [J]. EMERGENCY MEDICINE JOURNAL, 2013, 30 (02) : 106 - 111
  • [4] A framework for classifying factors that contribute to error in the emergency department
    Cosby, KS
    [J]. ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2003, 42 (06) : 815 - 823
  • [5] Reducing missed orthopedic injuries in the ER
    Cross, Catherine
    [J]. CANADIAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION JOURNAL, 2014, 186 (01) : E18 - E18
  • [6] A description of emergency department-related malpractice claims in the Netherlands: closed claims study 1993-2001
    Elshove-Bolk, Jolande
    Simons, Maarten
    Cremers, Jan
    van Vugt, Arie
    Burg, Michael
    [J]. EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2004, 11 (05) : 247 - 250
  • [7] Errors in a busy emergency department
    Fordyce, J
    Blank, FSJ
    Pekow, P
    Smithline, HA
    Ritter, G
    Gehlbach, S
    Benjamin, E
    Henneman, PL
    [J]. ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2003, 42 (03) : 324 - 333
  • [8] Orthopedic pitfalls in the ED: tibial plafond fractures
    Germann, CA
    Perron, AD
    Sweeney, TW
    Miller, MD
    Brady, WJ
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2005, 23 (03) : 357 - 362
  • [9] Greenberg R, 2000, Eur J Emerg Med, V7, P113
  • [10] Diagnostic errors in an accident and emergency department
    Guly, HR
    [J]. EMERGENCY MEDICINE JOURNAL, 2001, 18 (04) : 263 - 269