Bilayer Formation vs Molecular Exchange in Organic Heterostructures: Strong Impact of Subtle Changes in Molecular Structure

Organic heterostructures are a central part of a manifold of (opto)electronic devices and serve a variety of functions. Particularly, molecular monolayers on metal electrodes are of paramount importance for device performance as they allow tuning energy levels in a versatile way. However, this can be hampered by molecular exchange, i.e., by interlayer diffusion of molecules toward the metal surface. We show that the organic-metal interaction strength is the decisive factor for the arrangement in bilayers, which is the most fundamental version of organic-organic heterostructures. The subtle differences in molecular structure of 6,13-pentacenequinone (P2O) and 5,7,12,14-pentacenetetrone (P4O) lead to antithetic adsorption behavior on Ag(111): physisorption of P2O but chemisorption of P4O. This allows providing general indicators for organic-metal coupling based on shifts in photoelectron spectroscopy data and to show that the coupling strength of copper-phthalocyanine (CuPc) with Ag(111) is in between that of P2O and P4O. We find that, indeed, CuPc forms a bilayer when deposited on a monolayer P4O/Ag(111) but molecular exchange takes place with P2O, as shown by a combination of scanning tunneling microscopy and X-ray standing wave experiments.