On the interpretation of microbial clusters in periodontal disease

被引:3
作者
Cohen, ME
机构
[1] Naval Dental Research Institute, Building 1-H, Great Lakes, IL 60088-5259
关键词
periodontal diseases; oral microbiology; biostatistics; cluster analysis;
D O I
10.1111/j.1600-0765.1997.tb01381.x
中图分类号
R78 [口腔科学];
学科分类号
1003 ;
摘要
Cluster analysis is sometimes used in periodontal research to describe patterns of microbial identifications observed among cases (subjects or sites). These patterns are assumed to define subsets of cases that are meaningful, in the sense of defining periodontal subgroups that have reliable differences in some aspect of their disease. However, cluster analysis is an exploratory, first-stage technique that does not incorporate the machinery that allows one to evaluate the statistical significance and reliability of the patterns observed. Problems inherent in drawing inferences from cluster analysis are discussed and, as one methodological example of how the statistical significance of clustering might be determined, a randomization-based test for binary scaled microbial identifications is described. The introduction of cluster analysis to the study of periodontal microbiology was important and innovative, but future work needs to incorporate validation by either statistical means or independent replication. The present rarity of such confirmatory methods in the literature suggests caution in accepting specific cluster-based hypotheses about patient-microbial patterns.
引用
收藏
页码:47 / 53
页数:7
相关论文
共 11 条
[1]  
Dillon W.R., 1984, MULTIVARIATE ANAL ME
[2]   PATTERNS OF ANTIBODY-RESPONSE IN SUBJECTS WITH PERIODONTITIS [J].
HAFFAJEE, AD ;
SOCRANSKY, SS ;
TAUBMAN, MA ;
SIOSON, J ;
SMITH, DJ .
ORAL MICROBIOLOGY AND IMMUNOLOGY, 1995, 10 (03) :129-137
[3]   CLINICAL AND MICROBIOLOGICAL PATTERNS OF ADULTS WITH PERIODONTITIS [J].
KORNMAN, KS ;
NEWMAN, MG ;
ALVARADO, R ;
FLEMMIG, TF ;
NACHNANI, S ;
TUMBUSCH, J .
JOURNAL OF PERIODONTOLOGY, 1991, 62 (10) :634-642
[4]  
Manly BFJ, 1991, RANDOMIZATION MONTE
[5]  
Romesburg C. H., 1984, Cluster Analysis for Researchers
[6]   PERIODONTAL STATUS AND SELECTED CULTIVABLE ANAEROBIC MICROFLORA OF INSULIN-DEPENDENT JUVENILE DIABETICS [J].
SBORDONE, L ;
RAMAGLIA, L ;
BARONE, A ;
CIAGLIA, RN ;
TENORE, A ;
IACONO, VJ .
JOURNAL OF PERIODONTOLOGY, 1995, 66 (06) :452-461
[7]   RELATIONSHIP OF SUBGINGIVAL MICROBIAL COMPLEXES TO CLINICAL-FEATURES AT THE SAMPLED SITES [J].
SOCRANSKY, SS ;
HAFFAJEE, AD ;
DZINK, JL .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PERIODONTOLOGY, 1988, 15 (07) :440-444
[8]   AN APPROACH TO THE DEFINITION OF PERIODONTAL-DISEASE SYNDROMES BY CLUSTER-ANALYSIS [J].
SOCRANSKY, SS ;
TANNER, ACR ;
GOODSON, JM ;
HAFFAJEE, AD ;
WALKER, CB ;
EBERSOLE, JL ;
SORNBERGER, GC .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PERIODONTOLOGY, 1982, 9 (06) :460-471
[9]  
STRAUSS RE, 1982, ECOLOGY, V63, P634
[10]   CLUSTERING OF TRANSECT PHYTOPLANKTON COLLECTIONS WITH A QUICK RANDOMIZATION ALGORITHM [J].
VASSILIOU, A ;
IGNATIADES, L ;
KARYDIS, M .
JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL MARINE BIOLOGY AND ECOLOGY, 1989, 130 (02) :135-145