Responses to severe weather warnings and affective decision-making

被引:15
作者
Weyrich, Philippe [1 ]
Scolobig, Anna [2 ]
Walther, Florian [3 ]
Patt, Anthony [1 ]
机构
[1] Swiss Fed Inst Technol, Dept Environm Syst Sci, Climate Policy Grp, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland
[2] Univ Geneva, Environm Governance & Terr Dev Inst, CH-1205 Geneva, Switzerland
[3] GVB Serv AG, Wetter Alarm, CH-3063 Ittigen, Switzerland
关键词
IMPACT-BASED WARNINGS; RISK;
D O I
10.5194/nhess-20-2811-2020
中图分类号
P [天文学、地球科学];
学科分类号
07 ;
摘要
When public agencies provide information provision to help people make better decisions, they often face the choice between economy and completeness. For weather services warning people of high-impact weather events, this choice is between offering standard warnings (SWs) only of the weather event itself, such as wind-speed, or also describing the likely impacts (so-called impact-based warnings, IBWs). Previous studies have shown IBWs to lead to a greater behavioral response. These studies, however, have relied on surveys describing hypothetical weather events; given that participants did not feel threatened, they may have been more likely to process the warning slowly and analytically, which could bias the results towards finding a greater response to the IBWs. In this study, we conducted a field experiment involving actual and potentially threatening weather events for which there was variance with respect to the time interval between the warning and the forecasted event and for which we randomly assigned participants to receive SWs or IBWs. We observe that shorter time intervals led to a greater behavioral response, suggesting that fear of an imminent threat is an important factor motivating behavior. We observe that IBWs did not lead to greater rates of behavioral change than SWs, suggesting that when fear is a driving factor, the additional information in IBWs may be of little importance. We note that our findings are highly contextualized, but we call into question the prevailing belief that IBWs are necessarily more helpful than SWs.
引用
收藏
页码:2811 / 2821
页数:11
相关论文
共 29 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], 1990, COMMUNICATION EMERGE
[2]   Communicating Increased Risk: An Empirical Investigation of the National Weather Service's Impact-Based Warnings [J].
Casteel, Mark A. .
WEATHER CLIMATE AND SOCIETY, 2016, 8 (03) :219-232
[3]  
Finucane ML, 2000, J BEHAV DECIS MAKING, V13, P1, DOI 10.1002/(SICI)1099-0771(200001/03)13:1<1::AID-BDM333>3.0.CO
[4]  
2-S
[5]  
FSO, 2017, STAND WOHNB AB 15 NA
[6]  
FSO, 2017, BEV SCHWEIZ
[7]   Citizens' adaptive or avoiding behavioral response to an emergency message on their mobile phone [J].
Gutteling, Jan M. ;
Terpstra, Teun ;
Kerstholt, Jose H. .
JOURNAL OF RISK RESEARCH, 2018, 21 (12) :1579-1591
[8]  
Harrison J., 2014, 8 S POL SOC RES ATL
[9]   A Preliminary Look at the Social Perspective of Warn-on-Forecast: Preferred Tornado Warning Lead Time and the General Public's Perceptions of Weather Risks [J].
Hoekstra, S. ;
Klockow, K. ;
Riley, R. ;
Brotzge, J. ;
Brooks, H. ;
Erickson, S. .
WEATHER CLIMATE AND SOCIETY, 2011, 3 (02) :128-140
[10]  
Kahneman D, 2013, Thinking,_fast_and_slow, V1st