Anticipating risks, governance needs, and public perceptions of de-extinction

被引:11
|
作者
Valdez, Rene X. [1 ,5 ]
Kuzma, Jennifer [2 ,3 ]
Cummings, Christopher L. [4 ]
Peterson, M. Nils [1 ]
机构
[1] North Carolina State Univ, Fisheries Wildlife & Conservat Biol Program, Box 7646, Raleigh, NC 27695 USA
[2] North Carolina State Univ, Sch Publ & Int Affairs, Raleigh, NC USA
[3] North Carolina State Univ, Genet Engn & Soc Ctr, Raleigh, NC USA
[4] Nanyang Technol Univ, Wee Kim Wee Sch Commun & Informat, Singapore, Singapore
[5] Virginia Dept Game & Inland Fisheries, 7870 Villa Pk Dr,POB 90778, Henrico, VA 23228 USA
关键词
De-extinction; governance; environmental risk; moral risk; technological pessimism; PLANT-PATHOGENS; CONSERVATION; PERSPECTIVES; TECHNOLOGY; FRAMEWORK; FUTURES; ETHICS; ISSUES; FOOD;
D O I
10.1080/23299460.2019.1591145
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Advances in biotechnology may allow for de-extinction. Potential impacts of de-extinct species remain uncertain; they may improve ecosystem function, or hinder conservation efforts and damage socio-ecological systems. To better anticipate de-extinction's outcomes, ethical dilemmas, and governance needs, we surveyed experts from multiple disciplinary backgrounds. We applied a mixed-method approach to our analysis, integrating quantitative responses of perceived outcomes with qualitative responses, to clarify and provide context. Overall, respondents indicated de-extinction was more likely to induce hazards, not benefits. Reasons for this viewpoint included a moral hazard' argument, suggesting conservation policies could be undermined if society perceives that species need less protection because they can be revived later. Pessimistic views of de-extinction were linked to concerns about unclear development paths. Experts believed the public might be skeptical about de-extinction. Our results suggest future de-extinction efforts may benefit from collaborative efforts to clarify hazards and explore salient concerns among the engaged public.
引用
收藏
页码:211 / 231
页数:21
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] A mammoth undertaking: harnessing insight from functional ecology to shape de-extinction priority setting
    McCauley, Douglas J.
    Hardesty-Moore, Molly
    Halpern, Benjamin S.
    Young, Hillary S.
    FUNCTIONAL ECOLOGY, 2017, 31 (05) : 1003 - 1011
  • [32] Won’t Somebody Please Think of the Mammoths? De-extinction and Animal Welfare
    Heather Browning
    Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 2018, 31 : 785 - 803
  • [33] Assessing Student Conceptions of Protein Synthesis with a Case Study in CRISPR and De-extinction
    Rutkowske, Kadee G.
    Willis, Jacob N.
    Bierema, Andrea M-K
    AMERICAN BIOLOGY TEACHER, 2022, 84 (07) : 415 - 421
  • [34] Pathways to de-extinction: how close can we get to resurrection of an extinct species?
    Shapiro, Beth
    FUNCTIONAL ECOLOGY, 2017, 31 (05) : 996 - 1002
  • [35] Re-creation tourism: de-extinction and its implications for nature-based recreation
    Whittle, Patrick M.
    Stewart, Emma J.
    Fisher, David
    CURRENT ISSUES IN TOURISM, 2015, 18 (10) : 908 - 912
  • [36] Public Perceptions of Collaborative Governance in Transportation Policy
    Cain, Bruce E.
    Gerber, Elisabeth R.
    Hui, Iris
    POLITICAL RESEARCH QUARTERLY, 2021, 74 (04) : 899 - 912
  • [37] Perceptions of the Governance of the Technological Risks of Food Innovations for Addressing Food Security
    Kunyanga, Catherine Nkirote
    Byskov, Morten Fibieger
    Hyams, Keith
    Mburu, Samuel
    Werikhe, Grace
    Onyango, Cecilia Moraa
    SUSTAINABILITY, 2023, 15 (15)
  • [38] Public Perceptions and Informational Needs Regarding Surgical Residents
    Quach, William T.
    Hennessy, Cassandra
    Lindsell, Christopher J.
    Langerman, Alexander
    JOURNAL OF SURGICAL EDUCATION, 2024, 81 (01) : 37 - 47
  • [39] Stakeholder perceptions of public good provision from agriculture and implications for governance mechanism design
    Roberts, Michaela
    Byg, Anja
    Faccioli, Michela
    Novo, Paula
    Kyle, Carol
    JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT, 2021, 64 (02) : 289 - 307
  • [40] Public Perceptions About Smart Cities: Governance and Quality-of-Life in Hong Kong
    Hartley, Kris
    SOCIAL INDICATORS RESEARCH, 2023, 166 (03) : 731 - 753