Comparison of quality of life following total ankle arthroplasty and ankle arthrodesis: Retrospective study of 54 cases

被引:52
作者
Dalat, F. [1 ]
Trouillet, F. [2 ]
Fessy, M. H. [1 ,3 ]
Bourdin, M. [3 ]
Besse, J. -L. [1 ,3 ]
机构
[1] Hosp Civils Lyon, Ctr Hosp Lyon Sud, Serv Chirurg Orthoped Traumatol & Med Sport, F-69495 Pierre Benite, France
[2] Hosp Civils Lyon, Hop Renee Sabran, Serv Chirurg Orthoped, F-83400 Hyeres, France
[3] Univ Lyon 1, IFSTTAR, LBMC UMR T 9406, Lab Biomecan & Mecan Chocs, F-69675 Bron, France
关键词
Total ankle arthroplasty; Ankle arthrodesis; Quality of life; Functional results; PERIPROSTHETIC OSTEOLYTIC LESIONS; FOOT FUNCTION INDEX; REPLACEMENT; VALIDITY; SPORTS; OUTCOMES; FUSION; RATES;
D O I
10.1016/j.otsr.2014.07.018
中图分类号
R826.8 [整形外科学]; R782.2 [口腔颌面部整形外科学]; R726.2 [小儿整形外科学]; R62 [整形外科学(修复外科学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Introduction: The benefit of ankle arthroplasty compared to arthrodesis continues to be debated, but the quality of life after these two interventions has rarely been assessed. We conducted a case-control study to compare quality of life and functional and athletic ability. Hypothesis: Functional results, athletic ability, and quality of life after total ankle arthroplasty (TAA) are better than after ankle arthrodesis. Material and methods: Two continuous series of 59 TAAs and 46 arthrodeses (operated on between 1997 and 2009) were evaluated retrospectively using a questionnaire including the functional items of the AOFAS score, the Foot Function Index (FFI) score, the Foot Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM), and the SF-36. Results: Eighty-three responses (79% of the overall series) were matched in two groups: 32 TAAs [age at the intervention, 51.4 years (range, 21-63 years); follow-up, 52.2 months (range, 30-146 months); age at revision, 55.8 years (range, 26-67 years); BMI, 27.7 (range, 21.7-36.7)] and 22 arthrodeses [age at intervention, 50.1 years (range, 24-72 years); follow-up 57.9 months (range, 12-147 months); age at revision 54.9 years (range, 31-75 years); BMI, 26.8 (range, 17.6-37)] (NS on all items between the two groups). The pain results were better after TAA, but with no statistically significant difference: AOFAS pain, (/40) 28.1 +/- 8.2 vs. 24.5 +/- 9.6; FFI pain, 16.6 +/- 18.8 vs. 24.3 +/- 21.5. The overall FFI score (/100) was better (P = 0.048) after TAA (16.2 +/- 16.5 vs. 24.8 +/- 18.2). The overall mean athletic level compared to the state prior to the injury was relatively low in both groups, but significantly (p = 0.007) higher in the TAA group: FAAM sports score (/100), 49.5 +/- 24.4 vs. 29.8 +/- 26.2. The quality-of-life scores, SF-36 physical health, mental health, and general health were not significantly different after TAA and arthrodesis: mental health score, 63.1 +/- 14.7 vs. 57.8 +/- 21.5; physical health score, 61.3 +/- 17.8 vs. 53.7 +/- 23.9, overall score, 63.2 +/- 16.4 vs. 55.9 +/- 23.5. Discussion: Very few publications describe activities and quality of life after TAA and arthrodesis. Despite weaknesses, this comparative study demonstrates a tendency toward better functional results after TAA than after ankle arthrodesis, without the difference between the two groups being very significant. On the other hand, there was no difference in terms of quality of life. After the doubts raised by publications on severe periprosthetic osteolysis at the intermediate term with certain TAA models, these results encourage pursuit of implantation and development of TAA. (C) 2014 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:761 / 766
页数:6
相关论文
共 29 条
[1]   Total ankle arthroplasty in France [J].
Besse, J. -L. ;
Colombier, J. -A. ;
Asencio, J. ;
Bonnin, M. ;
Gaudot, F. ;
Jarde, O. ;
Judet, T. ;
Maestro, M. ;
Lemrijse, T. ;
Leonardi, C. ;
Toullec, E. .
ORTHOPAEDICS & TRAUMATOLOGY-SURGERY & RESEARCH, 2010, 96 (03) :291-303
[2]   Clinical Evaluation and Radiographic Assessment of Bone Lysis of the AES Total Ankle Replacement [J].
Besse, Jean-Luc ;
Brito, Nuno ;
Lienhart, Christophe .
FOOT & ANKLE INTERNATIONAL, 2009, 30 (10) :964-975
[3]   Ankle Function and Sports Activity After Total Ankle Arthroplasty [J].
Bonnin, Michel P. ;
Laurent, Jean-Raphael ;
Casillas, Mark .
FOOT & ANKLE INTERNATIONAL, 2009, 30 (10) :933-944
[4]   THE FOOT FUNCTION INDEX - A MEASURE OF FOOT PAIN AND DISABILITY [J].
BUDIMANMAK, E ;
CONRAD, KJ ;
ROACH, KE .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 1991, 44 (06) :561-570
[5]   Arthrodesis after failed total ankle replacement [J].
Culpan, P. ;
Le Strat, V. ;
Piriou, P. ;
Judet, T. .
JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY-BRITISH VOLUME, 2007, 89B (09) :1178-1183
[6]   Histologic study of periprosthetic osteolytic lesions after AES total ankle replacement. A 22 case series [J].
Dalat, F. ;
Barnoud, R. ;
Fessy, M. -H. ;
Besse, J. -L. .
ORTHOPAEDICS & TRAUMATOLOGY-SURGERY & RESEARCH, 2013, 99 (06) :S285-S295
[7]   Comparative Study of the Quality of Life Between Arthrodesis and Total Arthroplasty Substitution of the Ankle [J].
Esparragoza, Luis ;
Vidal, Carlos ;
Vaquero, Javier .
JOURNAL OF FOOT & ANKLE SURGERY, 2011, 50 (04) :383-387
[8]   Intermediate and long-term outcomes of total ankle arthroplasty and ankle arthrodesis - A systematic review of the literature [J].
Haddad, S. L. ;
Coetzee, J. C. ;
Estok, R. ;
Fahrbach, K. ;
Banel, D. ;
Nalysnyk, L. .
JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY-AMERICAN VOLUME, 2007, 89A (09) :1899-1905
[9]   CLINICAL RATING SYSTEMS FOR THE ANKLE-HINDFOOT, MIDFOOT, HALLUX, AND LESSER TOES [J].
KITAOKA, HB ;
ALEXANDER, IJ ;
ADELAAR, RS ;
NUNLEY, JA ;
MYERSON, MS ;
SANDERS, M .
FOOT & ANKLE INTERNATIONAL, 1994, 15 (07) :349-353
[10]   Severe periprosthetic osteolytic lesions after the Ankle Evolutive System total ankle replacement [J].
Koivu, H. ;
Kohonen, I. ;
Sipola, E. ;
Alanen, K. ;
Vahlberg, T. ;
Tiusanen, H. .
JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY-BRITISH VOLUME, 2009, 91B (07) :907-914