Microemulsion Formation and Detergency with Oily Soil: V. Effects of Water Hardness and Builder

In this study, the impact of water hardness and builder on the phase diagrams of motor oil microemulsions and the detergency of oil removal from a polyester/cotton blend was investigated. Water hardness and builder were found to have insignificant effects on the microemulsion phase diagram with motor oil. A mixed surfactant system of two parts C14-15(PO)(3)SO4Na, and 98 parts C12-14H25-29O(EO)(5)H of the total actives at 4% salinity was used to study the effect of water hardness and builders sodium tripolyphosphate (STPP) or ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) on detergency at 30 A degrees C at a total active concentration of 0.3%. This formulation is in the Winsor Type III microemulsion regime. The microemulsion-based formulation resulted in better detergency than a leading commercial liquid laundry detergent at all concentrations up to 0.5% actives. The microemulsion-based formulation showed a plateau in detergency at > 80% oil removal above 0.1% actives. The total oil removal decreased with increasing water hardness while the interfacial tension increased. When hard water was used in laundering, the total oil removal improved with increasing concentrations of STPP or EDTA up to stoichiometric levels, with STPP being slightly more effective than EDTA on a molar basis. Even high builder concentration could not improve hard water detergency to that of soft water. A significant fraction of oil removal occurred in the rinse steps vs. the wash step. Increasing water hardness reduced this fractional oil removal in the rinse steps, but it was still over half of total oil removal at 1,000 ppm water hardness.