Performance Comparison of a Two-Level and Three-Level Inverter Permanent Magnet Synchronous Machine Drives for HEV Application

This paper investigates the performance of a two level and a three level inverter drives for a permanent magnet synchronous machine (PMSM) under different swicthing frequencies. The experiments were conducted via a real time based system called Opal-RT. The inverters were operated at 1 kHz and 5 kHz switching frequencies. The torque was varied between 2 N.m and 4 N.m at a constant speed of 800 rpm. However the torque ripples and the copper losses between the two inverter drives were similar and the copper losses were independant of the swicthing frequency. At 5 kHz inverter switching frequency the two level inverter performed better at 4 N.m with a total current harmonic distortion of 2.55% and a torque ripple of 10%. However overall the three level inverter had low voltage and current harmonic distortion which translates to lower iron losses. Swicthing at 5 kHz frequency showed to have lower overall harmonic distortion than at 1 kHz for both inverters. The greater the capcitor voltage error the more the torque ripples even though the machine registered lower current total harmonic distortion for the three level inverter.