Comment on "Stochastic analysis of recurrence plots with applications to the detection of deterministic signals" by Rohde et al. [Physica D 237 (2008) 619-629]

被引：13
作者：
Marwan, Norbert [1 ,2 ]
Kurths, Juergen [3 ]
机构：
[1] Potsdam Inst Climate Impact Res, Dept Transdisciplinary Concepts & Methods, D-14412 Potsdam, Germany
[2] Univ Potsdam, Interdisciplinary Ctr Dynam Complex Syst, D-14415 Potsdam, Germany
[3] Humboldt Univ, Dept Phys, D-12489 Berlin, Germany
来源：
PHYSICA D-NONLINEAR PHENOMENA | 2009年 / 238卷 / 16期
关键词：
Recurrence plot; Stochastic processes; Detection; Data analysis; QUANTIFICATION ANALYSIS; SERIES;
D O I：
10.1016/j.physd.2009.04.018
中图分类号：
O29 [应用数学];
学科分类号：
070104 ;
摘要：
In the recent article "Stochastic analysis of recurrence plots with applications to the detection of deterministic signals" (Physica D 237 (2008) 619-629), Rohde et al. stated that the performance of RQA in order to detect deterministic signals would be below traditional and well-known detectors. However, we have concerns about such a general statement. Based on our own studies we cannot confirm their conclusions. Our findings suggest that the measures of complexity provided by RQA are useful detectors outperforming well-known traditional detectors, in particular for the detection of signals of complex systems, with phase differences or signals modified due to the measurement process. Nevertheless, we also clearly assert that an uncritical application of RQA may lead to wrong conclusions. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码：1711 / 1715
页数：5
相关论文
共 19 条
[11]   Recurrence analysis of strange nonchaotic dynamics [J].
Ngamga, E. J. ;
Nandi, A. ;
Ramaswamy, R. ;
Romano, M. C. ;
Thiel, M. ;
Kurths, J. .
PHYSICAL REVIEW E, 2007, 75 (03)
[12]   Stochastic analysis of recurrence plots with applications to the detection of deterministic signals [J].
Rohde, Gustavo K. ;
Nichols, Jonathan M. ;
Dissinger, Bryan M. ;
Bucholtz, Frank .
PHYSICA D-NONLINEAR PHENOMENA, 2008, 237 (05) :619-629
[13]   Multivariate recurrence plots [J].
Romano, MC ;
Thiel, M ;
Kurths, J ;
von Bloh, W .
PHYSICS LETTERS A, 2004, 330 (3-4) :214-223
[14]   DYNAMIC-PROGRAMMING ALGORITHM OPTIMIZATION FOR SPOKEN WORD RECOGNITION [J].
SAKOE, H ;
CHIBA, S .
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ACOUSTICS SPEECH AND SIGNAL PROCESSING, 1978, 26 (01) :43-49
[15]   Selection of recurrence threshold for signal detection [J].
Schinkel, S. ;
Dimigen, O. ;
Marwan, N. .
EUROPEAN PHYSICAL JOURNAL-SPECIAL TOPICS, 2008, 164 (1) :45-53
[16]   Recurrence quantification analysis of the logistic equation with transients [J].
Trulla, LL ;
Giuliani, A ;
Zbilut, JP ;
Webber, CL .
PHYSICS LETTERS A, 1996, 223 (04) :255-260
[17]   The Wiener-Khinchin theorem and recurrence quantification [J].
Zbilut, Joseph P. ;
Marwan, Norbert .
PHYSICS LETTERS A, 2008, 372 (44) :6622-6626
[18]   Detecting deterministic signals in exceptionally noisy environments using cross-recurrence quantification [J].
Zbilut, JP ;
Giuliani, A ;
Webber, CL .
PHYSICS LETTERS A, 1998, 246 (1-2) :122-128
[19]   Recurrence quantification analysis as an empirical test to distinguish relatively short deterministic versus random number series [J].
Zbilut, JP ;
Giuliani, A ;
Webber, CL .
PHYSICS LETTERS A, 2000, 267 (2-3) :174-178
12