Contrasting seasonal patterns of fine root production for blue oaks (Quercus douglasii) and annual grasses in California oak woodland

In a blue oak woodland in NE California, we used root ingrowth cores to study seasonal patterns of fine root (< 2 mm diameter) production (FRP) for annual grasses and blue oaks (Quercus douglasii Hook and Arn.). At each of three sites (River, Upland and Hilltop) there were three studies: a short-term seasonal study, a long-term cumulative study and a core nutrient enrichment study. In the short-term study, ingrowth cores were installed and harvested in 3-month intervals. Grass and oak FRP dominated in different seasons. Grass FRP was greater in fall (Oct-Dec, 26.0 g m(-)2 month(-)1(gmm)) and winter (Jan-Mar, 18.1 gmm), lower in spring (Apr-Jun, 2.9 gmm) and negligible in summer (July-Sep). In contrast, oak FRP was greater in spring (6.1 gmm) with lower, but significant summer growth (2.9 gmm). Grass FRP declined steadily with soil depth (0-40 cm) in all seasons. Oak FRP changed little with soil depth, except in the summer, when production was greatest at lower soil depths. In the long-term study, ingrowth cores were installed and harvested after 3, 6, 9 and 12 months. Oak annual FRP was greater in the long-term study than in the short-term study at the River and Upland sites. Thus production in the short-term study may be an underestimate, due to disturbance effects. Nutrient enrichment of cores with N-P-K increased grass FRP, but surprisingly, decreased oak FRP, suggesting that annual grasses may have competitive advantages in nutrient enriched soil.