Peirce on the justification of abduction

被引:7
作者
Bellucci, Francesco [1 ]
Pietarinen, Ahti-Veikko [2 ,3 ]
机构
[1] Univ Bologna, Bologna, Italy
[2] Tallinn Univ Technol, Tallinn, Estonia
[3] Res Univ Higher Sch Econ, Moscow, Russia
来源
STUDIES IN HISTORY AND PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE | 2020年 / 84卷
关键词
Peirce; Abduction; Hypothetic-deductive method; Induction; Logic; Classification of arguments; Scientific inquiry;
D O I
10.1016/j.shpsa.2020.04.003
中图分类号
N09 [自然科学史]; B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ; 010108 ; 060207 ; 060305 ; 0712 ;
摘要
What sort of justification can be claimed for abduction? In this paper we reconstruct Peirce's answer to this question. We show that in his early works on the logic of science Peirce provided an abductive justification of abduction, and that in his mature writings the early solution is enriched by a reference to the place abduction has in a typical scientific inquiry. Since abduction is the first stage of inquiry by which a hypothesis is suggested and which then has to be subjected to inductive testing, the fundamental abduction (ur-abduction) that justifies abduction has also to be subjected to a verification by means of a fundamental induction (ur-induction), namely that the abduction that abduction is valid is verified by an appeal to the history of science.
引用
收藏
页码:12 / 19
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Towards a theory of abduction based on conditionals
    Pfister, Rolf
    SYNTHESE, 2022, 200 (03)
  • [32] MEANING AND ABDUCTION AS PROCESSSTRUCTURE: A DIAGRAM OF REASONING
    Semetsky, Inna
    COSMOS AND HISTORY-THE JOURNAL OF NATURAL AND SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY, 2009, 5 (02): : 191 - 209
  • [33] Guessing and Abduction
    Tschaepe, Mark
    TRANSACTIONS OF THE CHARLES S PEIRCE SOCIETY, 2014, 50 (01): : 115 - 138
  • [34] Strategies in Abduction: Generating and Selecting Diagnostic Hypotheses
    Stanley, Donald E.
    Nyrup, Rune
    JOURNAL OF MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY, 2020, 45 (02): : 159 - 178
  • [35] Modalities of Abduction: a Philosophy of Science-Based Investigation of Abduction
    Jeppe Olsen
    Alexander Gjerding
    Human Arenas, 2019, 2 : 129 - 152
  • [36] On practical abduction
    Hilpinen, Risto
    THEORIA-A SWEDISH JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 2007, 73 : 207 - 220
  • [37] Peirce on educational beliefs
    Strand T.
    Studies in Philosophy and Education, 2005, 24 (3-4) : 255 - 276
  • [38] Analysis and decomposition in Peirce
    Bellucci, Francesco
    SYNTHESE, 2021, 198 (01) : 687 - 706
  • [39] Peirce and the art of reasoning
    Anderson D.
    Studies in Philosophy and Education, 2005, 24 (3-4) : 277 - 289
  • [40] Peirce, Pedigree, Probability
    Stewart, Rush T.
    Sterkenburg, Tom F.
    TRANSACTIONS OF THE CHARLES S PEIRCE SOCIETY, 2022, 58 (02): : 138 - 166