Thermodynamic Characterization of the Folding Equilibrium of the Human Nedd4-WW4 Domain: At the Frontiers of Cooperative Folding

WW domains are the smallest naturally independent beta-sheet protein structures available to date and constitute attractive model systems for investigating the determinants of beta-sheet folding and stability. Nonetheless, their small size and low cooperativity pose a difficult challenge for a quantitative analysis of the folding equilibrium. We describe here a comprehensive thermodynamic characterization of the conformational equilibrium of the fourth WW domain from the human ubiquitin ligase Nedd4 (hNedd4-WW4) using a combination of calorimetric and spectroscopic techniques with several denaturing agents (temperature, pH, and chemical denaturants). Our results reveal that even though the experimental data can be described in terms of a two-state equilibrium, spectral data together with anomalous values for some thermodynamic parameters (a strikingly low temperature of maximum stability, a higher than expected native-state heat capacity, and a small specific enthalpy of unfolding) Could be indicative of more complex types of equilibria, such as one-state downhill folding or alternative native conformations. Moreover, double-perturbation experiments reveal some features that, in spite of the apparent linear correlation between the thermodynamic parameters, seem to be indicative of a complex conformational equilibrium in the presence of urea. In summary, the data presented here point toward the existence of a low-energy barrier between the different macrostates of hNedd4-WW4, placing It at the frontier of Cooperative folding.