Carers' reflections on nursing home and NHS long-stay care for elderly patients

The aim of this study was to compare the perceptions of carers of elderly long-stay care patients who are now in nursing homes in three health districts in a former Regional Health Authority and in remaining long-stay geriatric National Health Service (NHS) wards. One hundred and ninety-eight nursing home carers (78%) and 128 NHS carers (83%) were interviewed by telephone, using a semi-structured questionnaire and open questions. The impact of caring at home was shown to be greater on NHS than on nursing home carers. Most were satisfied with the care, staff and atmosphere of the nursing home or hospital. Nursing homes were perceived to offer better 'hotel' facilities and a more pleasant environment. They were seen as better at respecting patients' privacy. The NHS was regarded as superior in offering clinical and rehabilitative services. Most participants thought the institution was the right place for their relative, although in general, it was thought to be better to care for elderly people at home. 'Care in the community' was supported, but carers were realistic about alternatives when informal care ceased to be a reasonable option. There was little 'choice' between public and private sector care. For many patients, entry into the institution followed directly from an acute hospital admission. The only choice was between care in a long-stay facility or remaining at home, with the patient becoming increasingly dependent and the carer becoming - increasingly unable to cope. The formal aspect of community care should be to be organized rationally and accepted as a valid response to the needs of some dependent elderly patients and their carers.