Factoid forensics: Have "more than 40" Australian families abandoned their homes because of wind farm noise?

被引:6
作者
Chapman, Simon [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Sydney, Sch Publ Hlth, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
关键词
Abandoned homes; noise; wind farms;
D O I
10.4103/1463-1741.137043
中图分类号
R36 [病理学]; R76 [耳鼻咽喉科学];
学科分类号
100104 ; 100213 ;
摘要
Anti-wind farm activists repeatedly claim that families said to be adversely affected by noise from wind turbines "abandon" their homes. In Australia, a claim of " more than 40 families" has been made by a prominent anti-wind farm activist. Six sources (parliamentary submissions, media reports, an anti-wind farm website, wind industry sources, correspondence with known anti-wind farm activists and with three politicians opposed to wind farms) were used to find evidence of home "abandonments." Claims about 12 Australian households permanently (n = 10) or periodically (n = 2) leaving their homes were found. However, no house appears to have been permanently "abandoned" without sale, as the expression implies. These 12 cases need contextualizing against considerations that several of those involved were either dedicated activists against wind farms from times sometimes pre-dating their construction, were engaged in protracted negotiations for home purchase with wind companies, had pre-existing health problems, grievances with the wind company over employment or had left the area for unrelated reasons of employment elsewhere. The statement that "more than 40" houses have been "abandoned" because of wind turbines in Australia is a factoid promoted by wind farm opponents for dramatic, rhetorical impact. Other considerations are often involved in abandonment unrelated to the claims made about wind farm noise.
引用
收藏
页码:208 / 212
页数:5
相关论文
共 23 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], 2005, STAR, P3
[2]  
Back C, 2012, WIND TURBINES UNTOLD
[3]  
Chapman S., 2014, SYMPTOMS DIS ABERRAN
[4]   The Pattern of Complaints about Australian Wind Farms Does Not Match the Establishment and Distribution of Turbines: Support for the Psychogenic, 'Communicated Disease' Hypothesis [J].
Chapman, Simon ;
St George, Alexis ;
Waller, Karen ;
Cakic, Vince .
PLOS ONE, 2013, 8 (10)
[5]   How the factoid of wind turbines causing "vibroacoustic disease' came to be "irrefutably demonstrated' [J].
Chapman, Simon ;
St George, Alexis .
AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2013, 37 (03) :244-249
[6]   The Power of Positive and Negative Expectations to Influence Reported Symptoms and Mood During Exposure to Wind Farm Sound [J].
Crichton, Fiona ;
Dodd, George ;
Schmid, Gian ;
Gamble, Greg ;
Cundy, Tim ;
Petrie, Keith J. .
HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY, 2014, 33 (12) :1588-1592
[7]   Can Expectations Produce Symptoms From Infrasound Associated With Wind Turbines? [J].
Crichton, Fiona ;
Dodd, George ;
Schmid, Gian ;
Gamble, Greg ;
Petrie, Keith J. .
HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY, 2014, 33 (04) :360-364
[8]  
Danby R, 2013, SAG OP 2013
[9]  
Heller B, 2011, PROPERTY VALUES AFFE
[10]  
Hoen B., 2013, A Spatial Hedonic Analysis of the Effects of Wind Energy Facilities on Surrounding Property Values in the United States