Return migrants play an increasingly important role in agricultural production in China and other developing countries. However, the effect of rural-urban migration experience on farmers' arable land use remains unclear. This study aims to fill this gap using data from a survey of 2293 farmers consisting of 586 return migrants and 1707 non-migrants in China. We employ the treatment effects model to account for the self-selectivity of rural-urban migration experience arising from observable and unobservable factors. The results show that after accounting for the self-selectivity bias, the rural-urban migration experience significantly increases farmers' arable land use by 22%. Meanwhile, the positive effect of rural-urban migration experience on arable land use differs by farmers' age group and region. While rural-urban migration experience increases arable land use for farmers aged below 65 years old by 29%, it shows no significant effect on arable land use for farmers aged 65 years old and above. In addition, there is a positive relationship between rural-urban migration experience and arable land use in Shaanxi, Shandong, and Zhejiang. However, there is no significant effect of rural-urban migration experience on arable land use. On such a basis, we discuss several important implications for policies related to arable land use in China.