Predicting Ebola Severity: A Clinical Prioritization Score for Ebola Virus Disease

被引:30
作者
Hartley, Mary-Anne [1 ,2 ]
Young, Alyssa [1 ]
Tran, Anh-Minh [1 ]
Okoni-Williams, Harry Henry [1 ]
Suma, Mohamed [1 ]
Mancuso, Brooke [1 ]
Al-Dikhari, Ahmed [1 ]
Faouzi, Mohamed [3 ]
机构
[1] GOAL Global, Dublin, Ireland
[2] Univ Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland
[3] Inst Social & Prevent Med, Lausanne, Switzerland
关键词
HEMORRHAGIC-FEVER; CASE-MANAGEMENT; SIERRA-LEONE; VIRAL LOAD; OUTBREAK; MORTALITY; INFECTION; DIAGNOSIS; SELECTION; IMMUNITY;
D O I
10.1371/journal.pntd.0005265
中图分类号
R51 [传染病];
学科分类号
100401 ;
摘要
Background Despite the notoriety of Ebola virus disease (EVD) as one of the world's most deadly infections, EVD has a wide range of outcomes, where asymptomatic infection may be almost as common as fatality. With increasingly sensitive EVD diagnosis, there is a need for more accurate prognostic tools that objectively stratify clinical severity to better allocate limited resources and identify those most in need of intensive treatment. Methods/Principal Findings This retrospective cohort study analyses the clinical characteristics of 158 EVD(+) patients at the GOAL-Mathaska Ebola Treatment Centre, Sierra Leone. The prognostic potential of each characteristic was assessed and incorporated into a statistically weighted disease score. The mortality rate among EVD(+) patients was 60.8% and highest in those aged <5 or >25 years (p<0.05). Death was significantly associated with malaria co-infection (OR = 2.5, p = 0.01). However, this observation was abrogated after adjustment to Ebola viral load (p = 0.1), potentially indicating a pathologic synergy between the infections. Similarly, referral-time interacted with viral load, and adjustment revealed referral-time as a significant determinant of mortality, thus quantifying the benefits of early reporting as a 12% mortality risk reduction per day (p = 0.012). Disorientation was the strongest unadjusted predictor of death (OR = 13.1, p = 0.014) followed by hiccups, diarrhoea, conjunctivitis, dyspnoea and myalgia. Including these characteristics in multivariate prognostic scores, we obtained a 91% and 97% ability to discriminate death at or after triage respectively (area under ROC curve). Conclusions/Significance This study proposes highly predictive and easy-to-use prognostic tools, which stratify the risk of EVD mortality at or after EVD triage.
引用
收藏
页数:20
相关论文
共 42 条
[1]   Ebola Virus Disease among Male and Female Persons in West Africa [J].
Agua-Agum, Junerlyn ;
Ariyarajah, Archchun ;
Blake, Isobel M. ;
Cori, Anne ;
Donnelly, Christl A. ;
Dorigatti, Ilaria ;
Dye, Christopher ;
Eck-Manns, Tim ;
Ferguson, Neil M. ;
Fraser, Christophe ;
Garske, Tini ;
Hinsley, Wes ;
Jombart, Thibaut ;
Mills, Harriet L. ;
Nedjati-Gilani, Gemma ;
Newton, Emily ;
Nouvellet, Pierre ;
Perkins, Devin ;
Riley, Steven ;
Schumacher, Dirk ;
Shah, Anita ;
Thomas, Lisa J. ;
Van Kerkhove, Maria D. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2016, 374 (01) :96-98
[2]  
[Anonymous], 2016, Ebola Situation Report
[3]   Ebola Virus Disease in West Africa - The First 9 Months of the Epidemic and Forward Projections [J].
Aylward, Bruce ;
Barboza, Philippe ;
Bawo, Luke ;
Bertherat, Eric ;
Bilivogui, Pepe ;
Blake, Isobel ;
Brennan, Rick ;
Briand, Sylvie ;
Chakauya, Jethro Magwati ;
Chitala, Kennedy ;
Conteh, Roland M. ;
Cori, Anne ;
Croisier, Alice ;
Dangou, Jean-Marie ;
Diallo, Boubacar ;
Donnelly, Christl A. ;
Dye, Christopher ;
Eckmanns, Tim ;
Ferguson, Neil M. ;
Formenty, Pierre ;
Fuhrer, Caroline ;
Fukuda, Keiji ;
Garske, Tini ;
Gasasira, Alex ;
Gbanyan, Stephen ;
Graaff, Peter ;
Heleze, Emmanuel ;
Jambai, Amara ;
Jombart, Thibaut ;
Kasolo, Francis ;
Kadiobo, Albert Mbule ;
Keita, Sakoba ;
Kertesz, Daniel ;
Kone, Moussa ;
Lane, Chris ;
Markoff, Jered ;
Massaquoi, Moses ;
Mills, Harriet ;
Mulba, John Mike ;
Musa, Emmanuel ;
Myhre, Joel ;
Nasidi, Abdusalam ;
Nilles, Eric ;
Nouvellet, Pierre ;
Nshimirimana, Deo ;
Nuttall, Isabelle ;
Nyenswah, Tolbert ;
Olu, Olushayo ;
Pendergast, Scott ;
Perea, William .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2014, 371 (16) :1481-1495
[4]   Clinical Presentation of Patients with Ebola Virus Disease in Conakry, Guinea [J].
Bah, Elhadj Ibrahima ;
Lamah, Marie-Claire ;
Fletcher, Tom ;
Jacob, Shevin T. ;
Brett-Major, David M. ;
Sall, Amadou Alpha ;
Shindo, Nahoko ;
Fischer, William A., II ;
Lamontagne, Francois ;
Saliou, Sow Mamadou ;
Bausch, Daniel G. ;
Moumie, Barry ;
Jagatic, Tim ;
Sprecher, Armand ;
Lawler, James V. ;
Mayet, Thierry ;
Jacquerioz, Frederique A. ;
Baggi, Maria F. Mendez ;
Vallenas, Constanza ;
Clement, Christophe ;
Mardel, Simon ;
Faye, Ousmane ;
Faye, Oumar ;
Soropogui, Bare ;
Magassouba, Nfaly ;
Koivogui, Lamine ;
Pinto, Ruxandra ;
Fowler, Robert A. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2015, 372 (01) :40-47
[5]   Ebola outbreak in Conakry, Guinea: Epidemiological, clinical, and outcome features [J].
Barry, M. ;
Traore, F. A. ;
Sako, F. B. ;
Kparny, D. O. ;
Bah, E. I. ;
Poncin, M. ;
Keita, S. ;
Cisse, M. ;
Toure, A. .
MEDECINE ET MALADIES INFECTIEUSES, 2014, 44 (11-12) :491-494
[6]   Clinical Predictors of Mortality in Patients With Ebola Virus Disease [J].
Barry, Moumie ;
Toure, Abdoulaye ;
Traore, Fode Amara ;
Sako, Fode-Bangaly ;
Sylla, Djibril ;
Kpamy, Dimai Ouo ;
Bah, Elhadj Ibrahima ;
Bangoura, M'Mah ;
Poncin, Marc ;
Keita, Sakoba ;
Tounkara, Thierno Mamadou ;
Cisse, Mohamed ;
Vanhems, Philippe .
CLINICAL INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2015, 60 (12) :1821-1824
[7]   High Prevalence of Both Humoral and Cellular Immunity to Zaire ebolavirus among Rural Populations in Gabon [J].
Becquart, Pierre ;
Wauquier, Nadia ;
Mahlakoiv, Tanel ;
Nkoghe, Dieudonne ;
Padilla, Cindy ;
Souris, Marc ;
Ollomo, Benjamin ;
Gonzalez, Jean-Paul ;
De Lamballerie, Xavier ;
Kazanji, Mirdad ;
Leroy, Eric M. .
PLOS ONE, 2010, 5 (02)
[8]   Ebola control: effect of asymptomatic infection and acquired immunity [J].
Bellan, Steve E. ;
Pulliam, Juliet R. C. ;
Dushoff, Jonathan ;
Meyers, Lauren Ancel .
LANCET, 2014, 384 (9953) :1499-1500
[9]   Priorities in Ebola research-a view from the field [J].
Boyles, Tom .
LANCET, 2015, 385 (9962) :23-23
[10]   Correlates of Immunity to Filovirus Infection [J].
Bradfute, Steven B. ;
Bavari, Sina .
VIRUSES-BASEL, 2011, 3 (07) :982-1000