Analytical sensitivity and clinical sensitivity of the three rapid antigen detection kits for detection of SARS-CoV-2 virus

被引:83
作者
Mak, Gannon C. K. [1 ]
Lau, Stephen S. Y. [1 ]
Wong, Kitty K. Y. [1 ]
Chow, Nancy L. S. [1 ]
Lau, C. S. [1 ]
Lam, Edman T. K. [1 ]
Chan, Rickjason C. W. [1 ]
Tsang, Dominic N. C. [1 ]
机构
[1] Ctr Hlth Protect, All Microbiol Div, Publ Hlth Lab Serv Branch, Dept Hlth, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
关键词
2019 novel coronavirus; SARS-CoV-2; COVID-19; Rapid antigen detection; RT-PCR;
D O I
10.1016/j.jcv.2020.104684
中图分类号
Q93 [微生物学];
学科分类号
071005 ; 100705 ;
摘要
Background: Numerous rapid antigen detection (RAD) kits for diagnosing COVID-19 patients are available in the market recently. Objective: To compare analytical sensitivity and clinical sensitivity for the three commercially available RAD kits. Study Design: Analytical sensitivity for the detection of SARS-CoV-2 virus was determined by limit of detection (LOD) using RT-PCR as a reference method. Clinical sensitivity was evaluated by using respiratory specimens collected from confirmed COVID-19 patients. Results: The LOD results showed that the three RAD kits varied from 102-105 fold less sensitive than RT-PCR. Clinical sensitivity of RAD kits ranged from 22.9 %-71.4 % for detecting specimens from COVID-19 patients. Conclusions: Although RAD kits were less sensitive than RT-PCR, understanding the clinical characteristics of different RAD kits can guide us to obtain suitable specimens for testing. The likelihood of positive results for RAD kits will be higher.
引用
收藏
页数:5
相关论文
共 20 条
[1]   Implementation of rapid SARS-CoV-2 antigenic testing in a laboratory without access to molecular methods: Experiences of a general hospital [J].
Blairon, Laurent ;
Wilmet, Alain ;
Beukinga, Ingrid ;
Tre-Hardy, Marie .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL VIROLOGY, 2020, 129
[2]   Predicting Infectious Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 From Diagnostic Samples [J].
Bullard, Jared ;
Dust, Kerry ;
Funk, Duane ;
Strong, James E. ;
Alexander, David ;
Garnett, Lauren ;
Boodman, Carl ;
Bello, Alexander ;
Hedley, Adam ;
Schiffman, Zachary ;
Doan, Kaylie ;
Bastien, Nathalie ;
Li, Yan ;
Van Caeseele, Paul G. ;
Poliquin, Guillaume .
CLINICAL INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2020, 71 (10) :2663-2666
[3]  
Centre for Health Protection, 2020, Latest situation of cases of COVID-19
[4]   Urgent need of rapid tests for SARS CoV-2 antigen detection: Evaluation of the SD-Biosensor antigen test for SARS-CoV-2 [J].
Cerutti, Francesco ;
Burdino, Elisa ;
Milia, Maria Grazia ;
Allice, Tiziano ;
Gregori, Gabriella ;
Bruzzone, Bianca ;
Ghisetti, Valeria .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL VIROLOGY, 2020, 132
[5]   Comparative analytical sensitivities of six rapid influenza A antigen detection test kits for detection of influenza A subtypes H1N1H3N2 and H5N1 [J].
Chan, K. H. ;
Lam, S. Y. ;
Puthavathana, P. ;
Nguyen, T. D. ;
Long, H. T. ;
Pang, C. M. ;
Chan, K. M. ;
Cheung, C. Y. ;
Seto, W. H. ;
Peiris, J. S. M. .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL VIROLOGY, 2007, 38 (02) :169-171
[6]  
Dhama K, 2020, CLIN MICROBIOL REV, V33, DOI [10.1128/CMR.00028-20, 10.1038/s41432-020-0088-4]
[7]   Multisystem Inflammatory Syndrome in US Children and Adolescents [J].
Feldstein, Leora R. ;
Rose, Erica B. ;
Horwitz, Steven M. ;
Collins, Jennifer P. ;
Newhams, Margaret M. ;
Son, Mary Beth F. ;
Newburger, Jane W. ;
Kleinman, Lawrence C. ;
Heidemann, Sabrina M. ;
Martin, Amarilis A. ;
Singh, Aalok R. ;
Li, Simon ;
Tarquinio, Keiko M. ;
Jaggi, Preeti ;
Oster, Matthew E. ;
Zackai, Sheemon P. ;
Gillen, Jennifer ;
Ratner, Adam J. ;
Walsh, Rowan F. ;
Fitzgerald, Julie C. ;
Keenaghan, Michael A. ;
Alharash, Hussam ;
Doymaz, Sule ;
Clouser, Katharine N. ;
Giuliano, John S. ;
Gupta, Anjali ;
Parker, Robert M. ;
Maddux, Aline B. ;
Havalad, Vinod ;
Ramsingh, Stacy ;
Bukulmez, Hulya ;
Bradford, Tamara T. ;
Smith, Lincoln S. ;
Tenforde, Mark W. ;
Carroll, Christopher L. ;
Riggs, Becky J. ;
Gertz, Shira J. ;
Daube, Ariel ;
Lansell, Amanda ;
Coronado Munoz, Alvaro ;
Hobbs, Charlotte V. ;
Marohn, Kimberly L. ;
Halasa, Natasha B. ;
Patel, Manish M. ;
Randolph, Adrienne G. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2020, 383 (04) :334-346
[8]  
Khairat SM., 2020, INT J MICROBIOLOGY B, V5, P131
[9]   Evaluation of a Rapid Diagnostic Assay for Detection of SARS-CoV-2 Antigen in Nasopharyngeal Swabs [J].
Lambert-Niclot, Sidonie ;
Cuffel, Alexis ;
Pape, Samuel Le ;
Vauloup-Fellous, Christelle ;
Morand-Joubert, Laurence ;
Roque-Afonso, Anne-Marie ;
Goff, Jerome Le ;
Delaugerre, Constance .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY, 2020, 58 (08)
[10]   Evaluation of rapid antigen test for detection of SARS-CoV-2 virus [J].
Mak, Gannon C. K. ;
Cheng, Peter K. C. ;
Lau, Stephen S. Y. ;
Wong, Kitty K. Y. ;
Lau, C. S. ;
Lam, Edman T. K. ;
Chan, Rickjason C. W. ;
Tsang, Dominic N. C. .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL VIROLOGY, 2020, 129