Practical knowledge of unsuccessful actions

被引:0
|
作者
Kietzmann, Christian [1 ]
机构
[1] FAU Erlangen Nurnberg, Inst Philosophie, Bismarckstr 1, D-91054 Erlangen, Germany
来源
ALLGEMEINE ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PHILOSOPHIE | 2020年 / 45卷 / 03期
关键词
GEM Anscombe; practical knowledge; intentional action; intention; form and matter;
D O I
10.12857/AZP.910450320-4
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
Anscombe introduced the concept of "practical knowledge" into contemporary action theory. According to Anscombe, in cases where someone's action fails to be performed successfully, the error lies in what he or she is doing and not in what he or she is thinking, wherefore his thought is not mistaken, and thus still knowledge. But Anscombe also seems to believe that knowledge is factive, i.e. to know that p implies that p. Both claims are, however, in tension with each other, because my practical mistake prevents that my knowledge corresponds to a fact. This paper seeks to address the problem this tension poses for our understanding ofpractical knowledge. In 1, I describe the problem. In 2, I review Anscombe's own response to the problem, and point out a difficulty for it. In 3, I discuss three other attempts to deal with the problem, and argue that they are flawed. Finally, in 4 I sketch my own solution.
引用
收藏
页码:339 / 362
页数:24
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Practical Knowledge and the Structural Challenge
    Campbell, Lucy
    MIND, 2024, 133 (532) : 1028 - 1056
  • [22] Practical knowledge: starting from EM guide by GEM Anscombe
    Kertscher, Jens
    ALLGEMEINE ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PHILOSOPHIE, 2020, 45 (03): : 295 - 316
  • [23] Practical knowledge for academic psychiatrists
    Edenharder, K
    ACADEMIC PSYCHIATRY, 2006, 30 (03) : 238 - 238
  • [24] Pratibha, intuition, and practical knowledge
    Das, Nilanjan
    BRITISH JOURNAL FOR THE HISTORY OF PHILOSOPHY, 2023, 31 (04) : 630 - 656
  • [25] Worker- student: education, knowledge, practical knowledge and work
    da Silva Filho, Raimundo Barbosa
    de Lima Araujo, Ronaldo Marcos
    Raiol da Costa, Ana Maria
    EDUCACAO POR ESCRITO, 2020, 11 (02):
  • [26] Problematizing the Practicum to Integrate Practical Knowledge
    Melville, Wayne
    Campbell, Todd
    Fazio, Xavier
    Stefanile, Antonio
    Tkaczyk, Nicholas
    RESEARCH IN SCIENCE EDUCATION, 2014, 44 (05) : 751 - 775
  • [27] Problematizing the Practicum to Integrate Practical Knowledge
    Wayne Melville
    Todd Campbell
    Xavier Fazio
    Antonio Stefanile
    Nicholas Tkaczyk
    Research in Science Education, 2014, 44 : 751 - 775
  • [28] Scaffolded practical knowledge: a problem for intellectualism
    Nottelmann, Nikolaj
    Thorsson, Kari
    PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES, 2021, 178 (02) : 577 - 595
  • [29] Accessing practical knowledge: how? why?
    Black, AL
    Halliwell, G
    TEACHING AND TEACHER EDUCATION, 2000, 16 (01) : 103 - 115
  • [30] Scaffolded practical knowledge: a problem for intellectualism
    Nikolaj Nottelmann
    Kári Thorsson
    Philosophical Studies, 2021, 178 : 577 - 595