Measuring Perceived Mistreatment: Potential Problems in Asking About "Discrimination"

Many studies have used survey data on perceived everyday mistreatment to assess the extent and health impact of racial discrimination and of discrimination based on weight, sexual orientation, and other reasons. Some surveys use the word discrimination in the initial question put to respondents, while other surveys do not use this word. This research note argues that including discrimination in the initial question may depress reports of perceived mistreatment, particularly among whites. It tests this possibility with data from the 1995-1996 National Survey of Midlife Development in the United States, which used discrimination in the initial question, and the 2001-2003 National Survey of American Life, which did not use this word. Findings suggest that using discrimination in the initial question considerably depresses whites' reports of everyday mistreatment.