Sentience With or Without Consciousness

被引:0
作者
Nani, Andrea [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Volpara, Gabriele [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Faggio, Andrea
机构
[1] Univ Turin, Dept Psychol, Turin, Italy
[2] Koelliker Hosp, GCS fMRI, Turin, Italy
[3] Univ Turin, Dept Psychol, Focus Lab, Turin, Italy
关键词
plants; animals; adaptiveness; sensitivity; sentience; consciousness; cognition; DOGS CANIS-FAMILIARIS; SELF-RECOGNITION; PLANT NEUROBIOLOGY; COMMUNICATION; CONNECTIVITY; ENVIRONMENTS; CHIMPANZEES; PLASTICITY; CHALLENGE; SIGNALS;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
The study of plant signalling and behaviour, whose aim is to address the physiological basis for adaptive behaviour in plants, is a growing and thought-provoking field of research. In this review we discuss relevant studies that fry to interpret in a neurocognitive fashion cases in which plants seem to behave similarly to animals. By comparing observations and experiments about plants and animals, we propose a framework composed of three axes in which interactions of living organisms with the world can be represented. The first axis refers to adaptiveness, the second to sensitivity, and the third to sentience. This model allows us to interpret the behaviours of living organisms along a continuum capable of giving a smooth transition from simple to complex responses. In light of this, plants show an excellent adaptiveness, a variable level of sensitivity, and a good degree of sentience (restricted to the immediate perception that some-thing is happening to themselves). Only the organisms with a high degree of sentience can have the basis for developing consciousness. However, even though it is necessary for consciousness, sentience is not sufficient, as it must be associated with a complex functional organization of structures that can support a recursive and synchronized processing of information. So far, plants have been found to completely lack this type of organization. Plants appear to be, therefore, sentient but not conscious.
引用
收藏
页码:60 / 79
页数:20
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] A critical review of plant sentience: moving beyond traditional approaches
    Hansen, Mads Jorgensen
    BIOLOGY & PHILOSOPHY, 2024, 39 (04)
  • [22] Animal sentience
    Browning, Heather
    Birch, Jonathan
    PHILOSOPHY COMPASS, 2022, 17 (05)
  • [23] Animal welfare with and without consciousness
    Dawkins, M. S.
    JOURNAL OF ZOOLOGY, 2017, 301 (01) : 1 - 10
  • [24] Solipsistic sentience
    Taylor, Jordan C. V.
    MIND & LANGUAGE, 2022, 37 (04) : 734 - 750
  • [25] A Case for Thinking Without Consciousness
    Dijksterhuis, Ap
    Strick, Madelijn
    PERSPECTIVES ON PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 2016, 11 (01) : 117 - 132
  • [26] Emotional sentience and the nature of phenomenal experience
    Kauffman, Katherine Peil
    PROGRESS IN BIOPHYSICS & MOLECULAR BIOLOGY, 2015, 119 (03) : 545 - 562
  • [27] What is Sentience? From Definitions to Metaphors
    Airoldi, Giorgio
    GLOBAL PHILOSOPHY, 2025, 35 (01):
  • [28] Searching for sentience
    Thelot, Ruby
    AI & SOCIETY, 2024, 39 (06) : 3043 - 3045
  • [29] Plant Sentience, Semantics, and the Emergentist Dilemma
    Brown, Deborah
    Key, Brian
    JOURNAL OF CONSCIOUSNESS STUDIES, 2021, 28 (1-2) : 155 - 183
  • [30] The problem of sentience
    Candiotto, Laura
    PHENOMENOLOGY AND THE COGNITIVE SCIENCES, 2025, 24 (01) : 191 - 211