The Mismatch Problem: Why Mele's Approach to the Puzzle of Synchronic Self-control Does Not Succeed

Most of us have had the experience of resisting our currently strongest desire, for example, resisting the desire to eat another cookie when eating another cookie is what we most want to do. The puzzle of synchronic self-control, however, says that this is impossible: an agent cannot ever resist her currently strongest desire. The paper argues that one prominent solution to this puzzle - the solution offered by Al Mele - faces a serious 'mismatch problem', which ultimately undermines its plausibility. It is furthermore argued that this problem can be avoided if we adopt a 'divided mind' solution instead.