Clinical impact of panel-based error-corrected next generation sequencing versus flow cytometry to detect measurable residual disease (MRD) in acute myeloid leukemia (AML)

被引:73
作者
Patkar, Nikhil [1 ,2 ]
Kakirde, Chinmayee [1 ]
Shaikh, Anam Fatima [1 ]
Salve, Rakhi [1 ]
Bhanshe, Prasanna [1 ]
Chatterjee, Gaurav [1 ,2 ]
Rajpal, Sweta [1 ,2 ]
Joshi, Swapnali [1 ]
Chaudhary, Shruti [1 ]
Kodgule, Rohan [1 ]
Ghoghale, Sitaram [1 ]
Deshpande, Nilesh [1 ]
Shetty, Dhanalaxmi [3 ]
Khizer, Syed Hasan [3 ,4 ]
Jain, Hasmukh [3 ,4 ]
Bagal, Bhausaheb [2 ,4 ]
Menon, Hari [5 ]
Khattry, Navin [3 ,5 ]
Sengar, Manju [2 ,4 ]
Tembhare, Prashant [1 ,2 ]
Subramanian, Papagudi [1 ,2 ]
Gujral, Sumeet [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] ACTREC, Tata Mem Ctr, Haematopathol Lab, Navi Mumbai, India
[2] Homi Bhabha Natl Inst HBNI, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
[3] ACTREC, Tata Mem Ctr, Dept Cytogenet, Navi Mumbai, India
[4] Tata Mem Hosp, Adult Haematolymphoid Dis Management Grp, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
[5] CyteCare Canc Hosp, Haematooncol, Bangalore, Karnataka, India
基金
英国惠康基金;
关键词
RISK; TRANSPLANTATION; MUTATIONS; ASSAY;
D O I
10.1038/s41375-021-01131-6
中图分类号
R73 [肿瘤学];
学科分类号
100214 ;
摘要
We accrued 201 patients of adult AML treated with conventional therapy, in morphological remission, and evaluated MRD using sensitive error-corrected next generation sequencing (NGS-MRD) and multiparameter flow cytometry (FCM-MRD) at the end of induction (PI) and consolidation (PC). Nearly 71% of patients were PI NGS-MRD+ and 40.9% PC NGS-MRD+ (median VAF 0.76%). NGS-MRD+ patients had a significantly higher cumulative incidence of relapse (p = 0.003), inferior overall survival (p = 0.001) and relapse free survival (p < 0.001) as compared to NGS-MRD- patients. NGS-MRD was predictive of inferior outcome in intermediate cytogenetic risk and demonstrated potential in favorable cytogenetic risk AML. PI NGS-MRD- patients had a significantly improved survival as compared to patients who became NGS-MRD- subsequently indicating that kinetics of NGS-MRD clearance was of paramount importance. NGS-MRD identified over 80% of cases identified by flow cytometry at PI time point whereas FCM identified 49.3% identified by NGS. Only a fraction of cases were NGS-MRD- but FCM-MRD+. NGS-MRD provided additional information of the risk of relapse when compared to FCM-MRD. We demonstrate a widely applicable, scalable NGS-MRD approach that is clinically informative and synergistic to FCM-MRD in AML treated with conventional therapies. Maximum clinical utility may be leveraged by combining FCM and NGS-MRD modalities.
引用
收藏
页码:1392 / 1404
页数:13
相关论文
共 44 条
[1]   getITD for FLT3-ITD-based MRD monitoring in AML [J].
Blaette, Tamara J. ;
Schmalbrock, Laura K. ;
Skambraks, Sabrina ;
Lux, Susanne ;
Cocciardi, Sibylle ;
Dolnik, Anna ;
Doehner, Hartmut ;
Doehner, Konstanze ;
Bullinger, Lars .
LEUKEMIA, 2019, 33 (10) :2535-2539
[2]   Cytogenetic and molecular diagnostic characterization combined to postconsolidation minimal residual disease assessment by flow cytometry improves risk stratification in adult acute myeloid leukemia [J].
Buccisano, Francesco ;
Maurillo, Luca ;
Spagnoli, Alessandra ;
Del Principe, Maria Ilaria ;
Fraboni, Daniela ;
Panetta, Paola ;
Ottone, Tiziana ;
Consalvo, Maria Irno ;
Lavorgna, Serena ;
Bulian, Pietro ;
Ammatuna, Emanuele ;
Angelini, Daniela F. ;
Diamantini, Adamo ;
Campagna, Selenia ;
Ottaviani, Licia ;
Sarlo, Chiara ;
Gattei, Valter ;
Del Poeta, Giovanni ;
Arcese, William ;
Amadori, Sergio ;
Lo Coco, Francesco ;
Venditti, Adriano .
BLOOD, 2010, 116 (13) :2295-2303
[3]   The Use and Interpretation of Competing Risks Regression Models [J].
Dignam, James J. ;
Zhang, Qiang ;
Kocherginsky, Masha .
CLINICAL CANCER RESEARCH, 2012, 18 (08) :2301-2308
[4]   Targeted RNA-sequencing for the quantification of measurable residual disease in acute myeloid leukemia [J].
Dillon, Laura W. ;
Hayati, Sheida ;
Roloff, Gregory W. ;
Tunc, Ilker ;
Pirooznia, Mehdi ;
Mitrofanova, Antonina ;
Hourigan, Christopher S. .
HAEMATOLOGICA, 2019, 104 (02) :297-304
[5]   Molecular MRD status and outcome after transplantation in NPM1-mutated AML [J].
Dillon, Richard ;
Hills, Robert ;
Freeman, Sylvie ;
Potter, Nicola ;
Jovanovic, Jelena ;
Ivey, Adam ;
Kanda, Anju Shankar ;
Runglall, Manohursingh ;
Foot, Nicola ;
Valganon, Mikel ;
Khwaja, Asim ;
Cavenagh, Jamie ;
Smith, Matthew ;
Ommen, Hans Beier ;
Overgaard, Ulrik Malthe ;
Dennis, Mike ;
Knapper, Steven ;
Kaur, Harpreet ;
Taussig, David ;
Mehta, Priyanka ;
Raj, Kavita ;
Novitzky-Basso, Igor ;
Nikolousis, Emmanouil ;
Danby, Robert ;
Krishnamurthy, Pramila ;
Hill, Kate ;
Finnegan, Damian ;
Alimam, Samah ;
Hurst, Erin ;
Johnson, Peter ;
Khan, Anjum ;
Salim, Rahuman ;
Craddock, Charles ;
Spearing, Ruth ;
Gilkes, Amanda ;
Gale, Rosemary ;
Burnett, Alan ;
Russell, Nigel H. ;
Grimwade, David .
BLOOD, 2020, 135 (09) :680-688
[6]   Diagnosis and management of AML in adults: 2017 ELN recommendations from an international expert panel [J].
Doehner, Hartmut ;
Estey, Elihu ;
Grimwade, David ;
Amadori, Sergio ;
Appelbaum, Frederick R. ;
Buechner, Thomas ;
Dombret, Herve ;
Ebert, Benjamin L. ;
Fenaux, Pierre ;
Larson, Richard A. ;
Levine, Ross L. ;
Lo-Coco, Francesco ;
Naoe, Tomoki ;
Niederwieser, Dietger ;
Ossenkoppele, Gert J. ;
Sanz, Miguel ;
Sierra, Jorge ;
Tallman, Martin S. ;
Tien, Hwei-Fang ;
Wei, Andrew H. ;
Lowenberg, Bob ;
Bloomfield, Clara D. .
BLOOD, 2017, 129 (04) :424-447
[7]   Mutation Clearance after Transplantation for Myelodysplastic Syndrome [J].
Duncavage, E. J. ;
Jacoby, M. A. ;
Chang, G. S. ;
Miller, C. A. ;
Edwin, N. ;
Shao, J. ;
Elliott, K. ;
Robinson, J. ;
Abel, H. ;
Fulton, R. S. ;
Fronick, C. C. ;
O'Laughlin, M. ;
Heath, S. E. ;
Brendel, K. ;
Saba, R. ;
Wartman, L. D. ;
Christopher, M. J. ;
Pusic, I. ;
Welch, J. S. ;
Uy, G. L. ;
Link, D. C. ;
DiPersio, J. F. ;
Westervelt, P. ;
Ley, T. J. ;
Trinkaus, K. ;
Graubert, T. A. ;
Walter, M. J. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2018, 379 (11) :1028-1041
[8]   Acute myeloid leukaemia [J].
Estey, Elihu ;
Doehner, Hartmut .
LANCET, 2006, 368 (9550) :1894-1907
[9]   Prognostic Relevance of Treatment Response Measured by Flow Cytometric Residual Disease Detection in Older Patients With Acute Myeloid Leukemia [J].
Freeman, Sylvie D. ;
Virgo, Paul ;
Couzens, Steve ;
Grimwade, David ;
Russell, Nigel ;
Hills, Robert K. ;
Burnett, Alan K. .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 2013, 31 (32) :4123-+
[10]   Standardization and quality control studies of 'real-time' quantitative reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction of fusion gene transcripts for residual disease detection in leukemia -: A Europe Against Cancer Program [J].
Gabert, J ;
Beillard, E ;
van der Velden, VHJ ;
Bi, W ;
Grimwade, D ;
Pallisgaard, N ;
Barbany, G ;
Cazzaniga, G ;
Cayuela, JM ;
Cavé, H ;
Pane, F ;
Aerts, JLE ;
De Micheli, D ;
Thirion, X ;
Pradel, V ;
González, M ;
Viehmann, S ;
Malec, M ;
Saglio, G ;
van Dongen, JJM .
LEUKEMIA, 2003, 17 (12) :2318-2357