Randomized controlled trials and real-world data: differences and similarities to untangle literature data

被引:102
作者
Monti, Sara [1 ]
Grosso, Vittorio [1 ]
Todoerti, Monica [1 ]
Caporali, Roberto [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Pavia, Dept Rheumatol, IRCCS Policlin S Matteo Fdn, I-27100 Pavia, Italy
关键词
randomized controlled trial; real-world data; study design; rheumatoid arthritis; biologic drugs; RHEUMATOID-ARTHRITIS; CLINICAL-TRIALS; EXTERNAL VALIDITY; INFLIXIMAB; BIOLOGICS; THERAPY; AGENT; RISK;
D O I
10.1093/rheumatology/key109
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) represent the gold-standard of medical evidence to assess the efficacy and safety of therapeutic interventions. However, the need to minimize bias and ensure the correct design to explore the study aims often affects the generalizability of results. As a consequence, the evidence derived from the most rigorous research strategy available is not always representative of the real-world settings for which this evidence is ultimately intended. Observational studies, in contrast, although affected by a number of potential confounders, can more effectively capture treatment characteristics and safety issues that had not been identified by previous RCTs, owing to the short duration of follow-up or highly selective inclusion criteria. The aim of this review is to provide a comparative summary of the main advantages and pitfalls of RCTs and real-world data, emphasizing the need for a constant integration of all available levels of evidence to provide the best care for patients.
引用
收藏
页码:54 / 58
页数:5
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Using Real-World Data to Extrapolate Evidence From Randomized Controlled Trials
    Wang, Shirley, V
    Schneeweiss, Sebastian
    Gagne, Joshua J.
    Evers, Thomas
    Gerlinger, Christoph
    Desai, Rishi
    Najafzadeh, Mehdi
    CLINICAL PHARMACOLOGY & THERAPEUTICS, 2019, 105 (05) : 1156 - 1163
  • [2] Combining randomized controlled trials and real world data
    Friede, Tim
    Roever, Christian
    Mathes, Tim
    PRAVENTION UND GESUNDHEITSFORDERUNG, 2023,
  • [3] Assessing the use of observational methods and real-world data to emulate ongoing randomized controlled trials
    Wallach, Joshua D.
    Deng, Yihong
    Polley, Eric C.
    Dhruva, Sanket S.
    Herrin, Jeph
    Quinto, Kenneth
    Gandotra, Charu
    Crown, William
    Noseworthy, Peter
    Yao, Xiaoxi
    Jeffery, Molly Moore
    Lyon, Timothy D.
    Ross, Joseph S.
    McCoy, Rozalina G.
    CLINICAL TRIALS, 2023, 20 (06) : 689 - 698
  • [4] Replication of Randomized, Controlled Trials Using Real-World Data: What Could Go Wrong?
    Thompson, David
    VALUE IN HEALTH, 2021, 24 (01) : 112 - 115
  • [5] Real-World Data and Randomised Controlled Trials: The Salford Lung Study
    Leather, David A.
    Jones, Rupert
    Woodcock, Ashley
    Vestbo, Jorgen
    Jacques, Loretta
    Thomas, Mike
    ADVANCES IN THERAPY, 2020, 37 (03) : 977 - 997
  • [6] Randomized Controlled Trials Versus Real-World Data in the COVID-19 Era: A False Narrative
    Lyman, Gary H.
    Kuderer, Nicole M.
    CANCER INVESTIGATION, 2020, 38 (10) : 537 - 542
  • [7] When can real-world data generate real-world evidence?
    Rahman, Motiur
    Dal Pan, Gerald
    Stein, Peter
    Levenson, Mark
    Kraus, Stefanie
    Chakravarty, Aloka
    Rivera, Donna R.
    Forshee, Richard
    Concato, John
    PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY AND DRUG SAFETY, 2024, 33 (01)
  • [8] Emulations of oncology trials using real-world data: a systematic literature review
    Rider, Jennifer R.
    Wasserman, Asher
    Slipski, Lukas
    Carrigan, Gillis
    Harvey, Raymond
    Jiao, Xiaolong
    Mcroy, Lynn
    Pace, Nelson D.
    Becnel, Lauren
    Bruno, Amanda
    Eckert, Joy C.
    Hodgkins, Priscilla
    Jain, Purva
    Merola, David
    Ovbiosa, Osayi E.
    Natanzon, Yanina
    Pinheiro, Simone
    Quinn, Jameson
    Rodriguez-Watson, Carla
    Campbell, Ulka
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2025,
  • [9] Making Compassionate Use More Useful: Using real-world data, real-world evidence and digital twins to supplement or supplant randomized controlled trials
    Greenbaum, Dov
    PACIFIC SYMPOSIUM ON BICOMPUTING 2021, 2021, : 38 - 49
  • [10] Comparison between patients included in randomized controlled trials of ischemic heart disease and real-world data. A nationwide study
    Laursen, Peter Norkjaer
    Holmvang, Lene
    Lonborg, Jacob
    Kober, Lars
    Hofsten, Dan E.
    Helqvist, Steffen
    Clemmensen, Peter
    Kelbaek, Henning
    Jorgensen, Erik
    Lassen, Jens Flensted
    Pedersen, Frants
    Hoi-Hansen, Thomas
    Therkelsen, Christian Juhl
    Tilsted, Hans-Henrik
    Jensen, Lisette Okkels
    Nepper-Christensen, Lars
    Sadjadieh, Golnaz
    Engstrom, Thomas
    AMERICAN HEART JOURNAL, 2018, 204 : 128 - 138