Current evidence for spinal X-ray use in the chiropractic profession: a narrative review

被引:47
作者
Jenkins, Hazel J. [1 ]
Downie, Aron S. [1 ]
Moore, Craig S. [2 ]
French, Simon D. [1 ,3 ]
机构
[1] Macquarie Univ, Dept Chiropract, Fac Sci & Engn, Sydney, NSW, Australia
[2] Univ Technol Sydney, Fac Hlth, Sydney, NSW, Australia
[3] Queens Univ, Sch Rehabil Therapy, Kingston, ON, Canada
关键词
Chiropractic; Spinal X-rays; Clinical guidelines; Appropriate use of imaging; Low back pain; Back pain; Neck pain; Imaging indications; LOW-BACK-PAIN; PRIMARY-CARE; LUMBAR SPINE; RADIOGRAPH UTILIZATION; PRACTICE GUIDELINES; RADIATION-EXPOSURE; PROGNOSTIC-FACTORS; APPROPRIATE USE; CLINICAL-COURSE; RED FLAGS;
D O I
10.1186/s12998-018-0217-8
中图分类号
R49 [康复医学];
学科分类号
100215 ;
摘要
The use of routine spinal X-rays within chiropractic has a contentious history. Elements of the profession advocate for the need for routine spinal X-rays to improve patient management, whereas other chiropractors advocate using spinal X-rays only when endorsed by current imaging guidelines. This review aims to summarise the current evidence for the use of spinal X-ray in chiropractic practice, with consideration of the related risks and benefits. Current evidence supports the use of spinal X-rays only in the diagnosis of trauma and spondyloarthropathy, and in the assessment of progressive spinal structural deformities such as adolescent idiopathic scoliosis. MRI is indicated to diagnose serious pathology such as cancer or infection, and to assess the need for surgical management in radiculopathy and spinal stenosis. Strong evidence demonstrates risks of imaging such as excessive radiation exposure, overdiagnosis, subsequent low-value investigation and treatment procedures, and increased costs. In most cases the potential benefits from routine imaging, including spinal X-rays, do not outweigh the potential harms. The use of spinal X-rays should not be routinely performed in chiropractic practice, and should be guided by clinical guidelines and clinician judgement.
引用
收藏
页数:11
相关论文
共 130 条
[61]  
Harrison D, 2009, PRACTICING CHIROPRAC
[62]   Further reliability analysis of the Harrison radiographic line-drawing methods: Crossed ICCS for lateral posterior tangents and modified Risser-Ferguson method on AP views [J].
Harrison, DE ;
Holland, B ;
Harrison, DD ;
Janik, TJ .
JOURNAL OF MANIPULATIVE AND PHYSIOLOGICAL THERAPEUTICS, 2002, 25 (02) :93-98
[63]   Cobb method or Harrison posterior tangent method [J].
Harrison, DE ;
Harrison, DD ;
Cailliet, R ;
Troyanovich, SJ ;
Janik, TJ ;
Holland, B .
SPINE, 2000, 25 (16) :2072-2078
[64]   Prevalence of and Screening for Serious Spinal Pathology in Patients Presenting to Primary Care Settings With Acute Low Back Pain [J].
Henschke, Nicholas ;
Maher, Christopher G. ;
Refshauge, Kathryn M. ;
Herbert, Robert D. ;
Cumming, Robert G. ;
Bleasel, Jane ;
York, John ;
Das, Anurina ;
McAuley, James H. .
ARTHRITIS AND RHEUMATISM, 2009, 60 (10) :3072-3080
[65]  
Horne JP, 2014, AM FAM PHYSICIAN, V89, P193
[66]   A systematic review of the global prevalence of low back pain [J].
Hoy, Damian ;
Bain, Christopher ;
Williams, Gail ;
March, Lyn ;
Brooks, Peter ;
Blyth, Fiona ;
Woolf, Anthony ;
Vos, Theo ;
Buchbinder, Rachelle .
ARTHRITIS AND RHEUMATISM, 2012, 64 (06) :2028-2037
[67]   Associaion of Early Imaging for Back Pain With Clinical Outcomes in Older Adults [J].
Jarvik, Jeffrey G. ;
Gold, Laura S. ;
Comstock, Bryan A. ;
Heagerty, Patrick J. ;
Rundell, Sean D. ;
Turner, Judith A. ;
Avins, Andrew L. ;
Bauer, Zoya ;
Bresnahan, Brian W. ;
Friedly, Janna L. ;
James, Kathryn ;
Kessler, Larry ;
Nedeljkovic, Srdjan S. ;
Nerenz, David R. ;
Shi, Xu ;
Sullivan, Sean D. ;
Chan, Leighton ;
Schwalb, Jason M. ;
Deyo, Richard A. .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2015, 313 (11) :1143-1153
[68]  
Jenkins H., 2010, Chiro J. Australia, V40, P69
[69]   Understanding patient beliefs regarding the use of imaging in the management of low back pain [J].
Jenkins, H. J. ;
Hancock, M. J. ;
Maher, C. G. ;
French, S. D. ;
Magnussen, J. S. .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PAIN, 2016, 20 (04) :573-580
[70]   Imaging for low back pain: is clinical use consistent with guidelines? A systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Jenkins, Hazel J. ;
Downie, Aron S. ;
Maher, Chris G. ;
Moloney, Niamh A. ;
Magnussen, John S. ;
Hancock, Mark J. .
SPINE JOURNAL, 2018, 18 (12) :2266-2277