Quantitative evaluation of nonrepetitive phase-encoding orders for first-pass, 3D contrast-enhanced MR angiography

In this work, a detailed quantitative comparison was made of many alternative phase-encoding strategies for first-pass 3D MR angiography where each phase encode is only sampled once during the transient passage of contrast agent. A series of standard sequential and centric phase-encoding orders including elliptical centric were tested, as well as a new order called elliptical sequential. The characteristics of the different phase-encoding orders were tested using a computer simulation followed by experimental verification using a variable flip angle scheme. The characteristics to be considered included: arterial intensity, arterial-to-venous contrast, degree of artifact, and the blurring of the point-spread function. By making use of a wide range of start times and a rapidly varying contrast curve, the quantitative results clearly indicate the widely varying merits of each phase-encoding order. In general, when an optimal start time is used techniques that sample the low k-space views most compactly will produce the best results; however, the same methods are more problematic when the bolus arrival time deviates substantially from that expected. (C) 2001 Wiley-Liss, Inc.