Transcranial direct current stimulation for balance rehabilitation in neurological disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis

被引:20
作者
Beretta, Victor Spiandor [1 ]
Santos, Paulo Cezar Rocha [2 ]
Orcioli-Silva, Diego [1 ,3 ]
Zampier, Vinicius Cavassano [1 ]
Vitorio, Rodrigo [1 ,4 ]
Gobbi, Lilian Teresa Bucken [1 ]
机构
[1] Sao Paulo State Univ, UNESP, Inst Biosci, Grad Program Movement Sci,Posture & Gait Studies, Rio Claro, Brazil
[2] Weizmann Inst Sci, Dept Comp Sci & Appl Math, Rehovot, Israel
[3] Univ Estadual Campinas, UNICAMP, Sch Appl Sci FCA, Lab Appl Sport Physiol LAFAE, Limeira, Brazil
[4] Northumbria Univ, Dept Sport Exercise & Rehabil, Newcastle Upon Tyne, Tyne & Wear, England
基金
巴西圣保罗研究基金会;
关键词
Brain stimulation; Postural balance; Parkinson?s disease; Stroke; Ageing; TDCS; NONINVASIVE BRAIN-STIMULATION; OF-THE-ART; PARKINSONS-DISEASE; MOTOR CORTEX; POSTURAL STABILITY; CHRONIC STROKE; DOUBLE-BLIND; FUNCTIONAL MOBILITY; SINGLE SESSION; PEDRO SCALE;
D O I
10.1016/j.arr.2022.101736
中图分类号
Q2 [细胞生物学];
学科分类号
071009 ; 090102 ;
摘要
Postural instability is common in neurological diseases. Although transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) seems to be a promising complementary therapy, emerging evidence indicates mixed results and protocols' characteristics. We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis on PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus, and Web of Science to synthesize key findings of the effectiveness of single and multiple sessions of tDCS alone and combined with other interventions on balance in adults with neurological disorders. Thirty-seven studies were included in the systematic review and 33 in the meta-analysis. The reviewed studies did not personalize the stimulation protocol to individual needs/characteristics. A random-effects meta-analysis indicated that tDCS alone (SMD = -0.44; 95%CI =-0.69/-0.19; p < 0.001) and combined with another intervention (SMD =-0.31; 95%CI = -0.51/-0.11; p = 0.002) improved balance in adults with neurological disorders (small to moderate effect sizes). Balance improvements were evidenced regardless of the number of sessions and targeted area. In sum-mary, tDCS is a promising therapy for balance rehabilitation in adults with neurological disorders. However, further clinical trials should identify factors that influence responsiveness to tDCS for a more tailored approach, which may optimize the clinical use of tDCS.
引用
收藏
页数:22
相关论文
共 130 条
[1]   Machine learning and individual variability in electric field characteristics predict tDCS treatment response [J].
Albizu, Alejandro ;
Fang, Ruogu ;
Indahlastari, Aprinda ;
O'Shea, Andrew ;
Stolte, Skylar E. ;
See, Kyle B. ;
Boutzoukas, Emanuel M. ;
Kraft, Jessica N. ;
Nissim, Nicole R. ;
Woods, Adam J. .
BRAIN STIMULATION, 2020, 13 (06) :1753-1764
[2]   Effects of anodal tDCS on motor and cognitive function in a patient with multiple system atrophy [J].
Alexoudi, Athanasia ;
Patrikelis, Panayiotis ;
Fasilis, Theodoros ;
Deftereos, Spyros ;
Sakas, Damianos ;
Gatzonis, Stylianos .
DISABILITY AND REHABILITATION, 2020, 42 (06) :887-891
[3]  
Anastasi AA, 2017, STROKE RES TREAT, V2017, DOI 10.1155/2017/8276136
[4]   Effects of different montages of transcranial direct current stimulation on the risk of falls and lower limb function after stroke [J].
Andrade, Suellen Marinho ;
de Almeida Ferreira, Jose Jamacy ;
Rufino, Thatiana Silva ;
Medeiros, Germana ;
Brito, Jader Duarte ;
da Silva, Michele Alexandre ;
Moreira, Raquel de Negreiros .
NEUROLOGICAL RESEARCH, 2017, 39 (12) :1037-1043
[5]   Sinusoidal Transcranial Direct Current Versus Galvanic Vestibular Stimulation for Treatment of Lateropulsion Poststroke [J].
Babyar, Suzanne ;
Santos, Taiza ;
Will-Lemos, Tenysson ;
Mazin, Suleimy ;
Edwards, Dylan ;
Reding, Michael .
JOURNAL OF STROKE & CEREBROVASCULAR DISEASES, 2018, 27 (12) :3621-3625
[6]   Center of Pressure Speed Changes with tDCS Versus GVS in Patients with Lateropulsion after Stroke [J].
Babyar, Suzanne ;
Santos-Pontelli, Taiza ;
Will-Lemos, Tenysson ;
Mazin, Suleimy ;
Bikson, Marom ;
Truong, Dennis Q. ;
Edwards, Dylan ;
Reding, Michael .
BRAIN STIMULATION, 2016, 9 (05) :796-798
[7]   The effect of transcranial direct current stimulation on balance in healthy young and older adults: A systematic review of the literature [J].
Baharlouei, Hamzeh ;
Saba, Maryam A. ;
Yazdi, Mohammad Jafar Shaterzadeh ;
Jaberzadeh, Shapour .
NEUROPHYSIOLOGIE CLINIQUE-CLINICAL NEUROPHYSIOLOGY, 2020, 50 (02) :119-131
[8]   Transcranial direct current stimulation in the treatment of cerebellar ataxia: A two-phase, double-blind, auto-matched, pilot study [J].
Barretto, Thiago Lima ;
Bandeira, Igor Dorea ;
Jagersbacher, Joao Gabriel ;
Barretto, Bianca Lima ;
Souza de Oliveira e Torres, Angelo Frederico ;
Pena, Norberto ;
Vivas Miranda, Jose Garcia ;
Lucena, Rita .
CLINICAL NEUROLOGY AND NEUROSURGERY, 2019, 182 :123-129
[9]   Transcranial direct current stimulation for the treatment of Parkinson's disease [J].
Benninger, David H. ;
Lomarev, Mikhail ;
Lopez, Grisel ;
Wassermann, Eric M. ;
Li, Xiaobai ;
Considine, Elaine ;
Hallett, Mark .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2010, 81 (10) :1105-1111
[10]   Cerebellar transcranial direct current stimulation in patients with ataxia: A double-blind, randomized, sham-controlled study [J].
Benussi, Alberto ;
Koch, Giacomo ;
Cotelli, Maria ;
Padovani, Alessandro ;
Borroni, Barbara .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2015, 30 (12) :1701-1705