A Comparison of Fixed-Parameter Active-Power-Oscillation Damping Solutions for Virtual Synchronous Generators

In order to emulate the frequency support characteristics of conventional synchronous generators (SGs), control algorithms based on the virtual synchronous generator (VSG) have been extensively applied to grid-tied converters. However, in the case that a large inertia is used in VSGs, active power oscillations can be introduced in the transients, due to the lack of enough damping effects. To avoid this phenomena, various solutions with additional damping terms have been proposed. This paper analyzes and compares six relevant fixed-parameter active-power-oscillation damping solutions in detail, where responses under set point and phase angle changes, the parameter sensitivity, and capabilities of limiting the rate of change of frequency (RoCoF) and attenuating power ripples are included. The results show the advantages and drawbacks of each solution, leading to the conclusion that extra damping terms may significantly degrade the inertial response of VSGs and have high dependency on the parameter estimation accuracy.