Analysis of Fracture Characteristic and Medial Collateral Ligament Injury Relationships in Terrible Triad Elbow Injuries

Purpose The objectives of this study were to identify the relationship between fracture characteristics and medial collateral ligament (MCL) injuries in terrible triad injuries of the elbow. Methods Between 2010 and 2018, 60 patients who underwent surgery for terrible triad elbow injuries were retrospectively reviewed. Using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) assessments, patients were stratified into those who had intact or low-grade partial MCL tears (low-grade MRI-MCL group) and those who had high-grade partial or full-thickness MCL tears (high-grade MRI-MCL group). We also analyzed patients according to whether they underwent MCL repair surgery. Fractures of the radial head were assessed according to Mason's classification system and measurements of fracture fragment arc on axial cuts. Fractures of the coronoid processes were assessed according to the system of Regan and Morrey and measurements of coronoid process volumes. Results Patients in the high-grade MRI-MCL group (28 patients) had a more comminuted and higher fragment arc of radial head fractures than those in the low-grade MRI-MCL group (32 patients) (143 degrees +/- 45 degrees vs 119 degrees +/- 31 degrees). However, the volume of coronoid fracture fragments was smaller in the highgrade MRI-MCL than in the low-grade MRI-MCL group (359 +/- 325 mm(3) vs 722 +/- 448 mm(3)). The MCL repair group (22 patients) also had a more comminuted and higher fragment arc in radial head fractures (153 degrees +/- 44 degrees vs 117 degrees +/- 31 degrees) and a smaller coronoid process fracture volume (236 +/- 224 mm(3) vs 735 +/- 419 mm(3)) than the non-MCL repair group (38 patients). Conclusions Our results demonstrated that high-grade MCL injuries are associated with comminuted and larger-sized radial head fractures, as well as smaller-sized coronoid process fractures in terrible triad injuries. In making a decision regarding surgical treatment, these fracture characteristics could help to predict the severity for MCL injury in terrible triad injuries. Copyright (C) 2021 by the American Society for Surgery of the Hand. All rights reserved. Type of study/level of evidence Prognostic IV.