Developing a core outcome domain set to assessing effectiveness of interdisciplinary multimodal pain therapy: the VAPAIN consensus statement on core outcome domains

被引:78
|
作者
Kaiser, Ulrike [1 ]
Kopkow, Christian [2 ]
Deckert, Stefanie [3 ]
Neustadt, Katrin [1 ]
Jacobi, Lena [3 ]
Cameron, Paul [4 ]
De Angelis, Valerio
Apfelbacher, Christian [5 ]
Arnold, Bernhard [6 ]
Birch, Judy [7 ]
Bjarnegard, Anna [8 ]
Christiansen, Sandra [9 ]
Williams, Amanda C. de C. [10 ]
Gossrau, Gudrun [1 ]
Heinks, Andrea [11 ]
Hueppe, Michael [12 ]
Kiers, Henri [13 ]
Kleinert, Ursula [14 ]
Martelletti, Paolo [15 ]
McCracken, Lance [16 ]
de Meij, Nelleke [17 ]
Nagel, Bernd [18 ]
Nijs, Jo [19 ]
Norda, Heike [20 ]
Singh, Jasvinder A. [21 ]
Spengler, Ellen
Terwee, Caroline B. [22 ]
Tugwell, Peter [23 ]
Vlaeyen, Johan W. S. [24 ]
Wandrey, Heike
Neugebauer, Edmund [25 ]
Sabatowski, Rainer [1 ]
Schmitt, Jochen [3 ]
机构
[1] Tech Univ Dresden, Univ Hosp Carl Gustav Carus, Comprehens Pain Ctr, Fetscherstr 74, D-01307 Dresden, Germany
[2] Univ Appl Sci, Dept Appl Hlth Sci, Bochum, Germany
[3] Tech Univ Dresden, Hosp & Med Fac Carl Gustav Carus, Ctr Evidence Based Healthcare, Dresden, Germany
[4] Queen Margaret Hosp, Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland
[5] Univ Regensburg, Inst Epidemiol & Prevent Med, Med Sociol, Regensburg, Germany
[6] Amper Kliniken Dachau, Dept Pain Therapy, Dachau, Germany
[7] Pelv Pain Support Network, Poole, Dorset, England
[8] Swedish Assoc Physiotherapists, Stockholm, Sweden
[9] Univ Med Hosp Hamburg Eppendorf UKE, Ctr Anesthesiol & Intens Care Med, Dept Anesthesiol Pain Med & Pain Psychol, Hamburg, Germany
[10] UCL, Res Dept Clin Educ & Hlth Psychol, London, England
[11] German Federat Physiotherapy, Cologne, Germany
[12] Lubeck Univ, Med Sch, Dept Anesthesiol, Lubeck, Germany
[13] Univ Appl Sci Utrecht, Fac Hlth Care, Res Grp Lifestyle & Hlth, Utrecht, Netherlands
[14] German Pain League, Frankfurt, Germany
[15] Sapienza Univ Rome, Reg Referral Headache Ctr, St Andrea Hosp, Dept Clin & Mol Med, Rome, Italy
[16] Kings Coll London, Hlth Psychol Sect, Dept Psychol, London, England
[17] Maastricht UMC, Univ Pain Ctr Maastricht, Res & Qual Assessment, Anesthesiol & Pain Med, Maastricht, Netherlands
[18] DRK Pain Ctr Mainz, Day Care Unit, Mainz, Germany
[19] Vrije Univ Brussel, Fac Phys Educ & Physiotherapy, Dept Physiotherapy Human Physiol & Anat, Brussels, Belgium
[20] Patient Federat SchmerzLOS eV, Lubeck, Germany
[21] Univ Alabama Birmingham, Sch Publ Hlth, Div Epidemiol, Birmingham, AL 35294 USA
[22] Vrije Univ Amsterdam, Med Ctr, Amsterdam Publ Hlth Res Inst, Dept Epidemiol & Biostat, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[23] Fac Med, Dept Epidemiol & Community Med, Ottawa, ON, Canada
[24] Univ Leuven, Res Grp Hlth Psychol, Leuven, Belgium
[25] Neuruppin & Witten Herdecke Univ, Brandenburg Med Sch, Neuruppin, Germany
关键词
Chronic pain; Interdisciplinary multimodal pain therapy; Core outcome set; Consensus process; Outcome domains; CLINICAL-TRIALS; FRAMEWORKS; ROADMAP; PEOPLE; NEED;
D O I
10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001129
中图分类号
R614 [麻醉学];
学科分类号
100217 ;
摘要
Interdisciplinarymultimodal pain therapy (IMPT) is a biopsychosocial treatment approach for patientswith chronic pain that comprises at least psychological and physiotherapeutic interventions. Core outcome sets (COSs) are currently developed in different medical fields to standardize and improve the selection of outcome domains, and measurement instruments in clinical trials, to make trial results meaningful, to pool trial results, and to allow indirect comparison between interventions. The objective of this study was to develop aCOSof patient-relevant outcome domains for chronic pain in IMPT clinical trials. An international, multiprofessional panel (patient representatives [n=5], physicians specialized in pain medicine [n = 5], physiotherapists [n = 5], clinical psychologists [n = 5], and methodological researchers [n = 5]) was recruited for a 3-stage consensus study, which consisted of a mixed-method approach comprising an exploratory systematic review, a preparing online survey to identify important outcome domains, a face-to-face consensus meeting to agree on COS domains, and a second online survey (Delphi) establishing agreement on definitions for the domains included. The panel agreed on the following 8 domains to be included into the COS for IMPT: pain intensity, pain frequency, physical activity, emotional wellbeing, satisfaction with social roles and activities, productivity (paid and unpaid, at home and at work, inclusive presentism and absenteeism), health-related quality of life, and patient's perception of treatment goal achievement. The complexity of chronic pain in a biopsychosocial context is reflected in the current recommendation and includes physical, mental, and social outcomes. In a subsequent step, measurement instruments will be identified via systematic reviews.
引用
收藏
页码:673 / 683
页数:11
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] A protocol for developing a core outcome set for ectopic pregnancy
    Chong, Krystle Y.
    Solangon, Sarah
    Kemper, James
    Barnhart, Kurt
    Andrieu, Pamela Causa
    Capmas, Perrine
    Chacon, Carolina
    Condous, George
    de Waard, Liesl
    Duffy, James M. N.
    Horne, Andrew
    Memtsa, Maria
    Mol, Femke
    Oza, Munira
    Strandell, Annika
    van Wely, Madelon
    Van't Hooft, Janneke
    Vuong, Lan N.
    Zhang, Jian
    Jurkovic, Davor
    Mol, Ben W.
    TRIALS, 2021, 22 (01)
  • [22] A protocol for developing a core outcome set for ectopic pregnancy
    Krystle Y. Chong
    Sarah Solangon
    James Kemper
    Kurt Barnhart
    Pamela Causa Andrieu
    Perrine Capmas
    Carolina Chacon
    George Condous
    Liesl de Waard
    James M. N. Duffy
    Andrew Horne
    Maria Memtsa
    Femke Mol
    Munira Oza
    Annika Strandell
    Madelon van Wely
    Janneke van’t Hooft
    Lan N. Vuong
    Jian Zhang
    Davor Jurkovic
    Ben W. Mol
    Trials, 22
  • [23] Relevant domains, core outcome sets and measurements for implant dentistry clinical trials: The Implant Dentistry Core Outcome Set and Measurement (ID-COSM) international consensus report
    Tonetti, Maurizio S.
    Sanz, Mariano
    Avila-Ortiz, Gustavo
    Berglundh, Tord
    Cairo, Francesco
    Derks, Jan
    Figuero, Elena
    Graziani, Filippo
    Guerra, Fernando
    Heitz-Mayfield, Lisa
    Jung, Ronald E.
    Lai, Hongchang
    Needleman, Ian
    Papapanou, Panos N.
    Sailer, Irena
    Sanz-Sanchez, Ignacio
    Schwarz, Frank
    Shi, Junyu
    Thoma, Daniel
    CLINICAL ORAL IMPLANTS RESEARCH, 2023, 34 : 4 - 21
  • [24] Core outcome domains for chronic pain clinical trials: IMMPACT recommendations
    Turk, DC
    Dworkin, RH
    Allen, RR
    Bellamy, N
    Brandenburg, N
    Carr, DB
    Cleeland, C
    Dionne, R
    Farrar, JT
    Galer, BS
    Hewitt, DJ
    Jadad, AR
    Katz, NP
    Kramer, LD
    Manning, DC
    McCormick, CG
    McDermott, MP
    McGrath, P
    Quessy, S
    Rappaport, BA
    Robinson, JP
    Royal, MA
    Simon, L
    Stauffer, JW
    Stein, W
    Tollett, J
    Witter, J
    PAIN, 2003, 106 (03) : 337 - 345
  • [25] Core Set of Domains for Outcome Measures in Behcet's Syndrome
    Hatemi, Gulen
    Meara, Alexa
    Ozguler, Yesim
    Direskeneli, Haner
    Mahr, Alfred
    Shea, Beverly
    Cam, Esen
    Gul, Ahmet
    Yazici, Yusuf
    Tugwell, Peter
    Yazici, Hasan
    Merkel, Peter A.
    ARTHRITIS CARE & RESEARCH, 2022, 74 (04) : 691 - 699
  • [26] Developing a core outcome set for hand fractures and joint injuries in adults
    Deshmukh, S. R.
    Kirkham, J. J.
    Karantana, A.
    SOHANDI Study Grp
    BONE & JOINT OPEN, 2023, 4 (02): : 87 - 95
  • [27] Delphi procedure in core outcome set development: rating scale and consensus criteria determined outcome selection
    De Meyer, Dorien
    Kottner, Jan
    Beele, Hilde
    Schmitt, Jochen
    Lange, Toni
    Van Hecke, Ann
    Verhaeghe, Sofie
    Beeckman, Dimitri
    JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2019, 111 : 23 - 31
  • [28] Core outcome set developers should consider and specify the level of granularity of outcome domains
    Kottner, Jan
    Beaton, Dorcas
    Clarke, Mike
    Dodd, Susanna
    Kirkham, Jamie
    Lange, Toni
    Nieuwlaat, Robby
    Schmitt, Jochen
    Tugwell, Peter
    Williamson, Paula
    JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2024, 169
  • [29] Developing an Outcome Measures in Rheumatology (OMERACT) Core set of Outcome Measures for FOot and ankle disorders in RheumaTic and musculoskeletal diseases (COMFORT): core domain set study protocol
    Lara S. Chapman
    Anthony C. Redmond
    Caroline A. Flurey
    Pamela Richards
    Toby O. Smith
    John B. Arnold
    Dorcas Beaton
    Philip G. Conaghan
    Yvonne M. Golightly
    Marian T. Hannan
    Catherine Hofstetter
    Lara J. Maxwell
    Hylton B. Menz
    Beverley Shea
    Peter Tugwell
    Philip Helliwell
    Heidi J. Siddle
    Trials, 24
  • [30] Core outcome set for pediatric chronic pain clinical trials: results from a Delphi poll and consensus meeting
    Palermo, Tonya M.
    Walco, Gary A.
    Paladhi, Unmesha Roy
    Birnie, Kathryn A.
    Crombez, Geert
    de la Vega, Rocio
    Eccleston, Christopher
    Kashikar-Zuck, Susmita
    Stone, Amanda L.
    PAIN, 2021, 162 (10) : 2539 - 2547