Is esophageal manometry essential for the diagnosis of achalasia? Identifying patients with achalasia by the esophageal clearance method

Background and aim Achalasia is a disease characterized by inadequate relaxation of the lower esophageal sphincter (LES) and impaired peristalsis, for which esophageal motor function testing is essential in making a definitive diagnosis. However, the diffusion rate of esophageal pressure testing in Japan is low. We, therefore, examined whether achalasia could be identified by esophageal clearance testing with low-density barium (Timed Barium Esophagogram: TBE). Materials and methods 126 cases (62 males, median age of 46 years), excluding those who had not undergone TBE during their initial laparoscopic Heller-Dor surgery, were chosen as the subjects from among those who were diagnosed with achalasia from November 2012 when HRM was introduced. The type of dilation, maximum esophageal transverse diameter, and esophageal clearance measurements by TBE were retrospectively examined. With respect to TBE, 200 mL of 45 weight% low-density barium was ingested as quickly as possible, after which the barium column heights (H0,H1,H2, andH5) were measured 1 min, 2 min, and 5 min following ingestion. Results The types of dilation indicated included: straight type (105 cases, 83%); sigmoid type (20 cases, 16%); and advanced sigmoid type (1 case, 1%). The maximum transverse diameter of the esophagus was 45 (34-54) mm, with Grade I (d < 30 mm) in 33 cases, Grade II (35 mm < d < 60 mm) in 75 cases, and Grade III (d < 60 mm) in 18 cases. The values for H0, H1, H2, and H5 were 162 (117-201) mm, 142 (98-199) mm, 130 (94-183) mm, and 119 (77-178) mm, respectively. 114 cases (90.5%) were not cleared after 5 min, while 12 cases (9.5%) were cleared by 5 min later (H1 = 0 + H2 = 0 + H5 = 0) and 7 cases (5.6%) by 2 min later (H1 = 0 + H2 = 0), with only 6 cases (4.8%) having complete clearance within 1 min (H1 = 0). Moreover, the degree of dilatation in patients with complete clearance within 1 min was three patients (2.4%) each for Grade I and Grade II, respectively. Conclusions Approximately 2.4% of achalasia cases had mostly normal esophageal clearance and no esophageal dilation. Based on the state of esophageal clearance by TBE and the maximum transverse diameter of the esophagus, it seems by and large possible to identify achalasia cases.