The role of performance measurement and evaluation in building organizational capabilities and performance

This study examines the processes through which the availability of broad-based strategically relevant performance information impacts on the performance outcomes of organizations We explore the role of evaluation mechanisms in influencing managers use of broad-based performance measurement information for feedback and feed-forward control We hypothesize that these resultant decision-making patterns impact the exploitation and identification of strategic capabilities within an organization and in turn organizational performance Using a structural equation model we find support for a model in which the degree of commonality between measures identified as decision facilitating and decision-Influencing is significantly associated with the use of decision-facilitating measures for both feedback and feed-forward control In turn the extent to which decision-facilitating measures are actually used by strategic business unit managers impacts on the strategic capabilities of the organization and subsequently its performance Overall the results suggest that to encourage managers to use the multiple financial and non-financial performance indicators increasingly Incorporated in contemporary performance measurement systems It is imperative that performance evaluation schemes are also designed to reflect these measures To the extent performance evaluation schemes do not reflect such decision facilitating measures it is less likely managers will use these indicators to effectively manage performance The resultant performance implications for the organization arise from the impact of these decision effects on the exploitation of existing capabilities and the search for and identification of new strategic opportunities (C) 2010 Elsevier Ltd All rights reserved