Efficacy and safety of cryobiopsy versus forceps biopsy for interstitial lung diseases and lung tumours: A systematic review and meta-analysis

被引:87
作者
Ganganah, Oormila [1 ]
Guo, Shu Liang [1 ]
Chiniah, Manu [1 ]
Li, Yi Shi [1 ]
机构
[1] Chongqing Med Univ, Affiliated Hosp 1, Youyi 1 Rd, Chongqing 400016, Peoples R China
关键词
cryobiopsy; forceps biopsy; interstitial lung disease; lung tumours; meta-analysis; DIAGNOSTIC YIELD; FIBEROPTIC BRONCHOSCOPY; CRYOTHERAPY; INCREASES; CANCER;
D O I
10.1111/resp.12770
中图分类号
R56 [呼吸系及胸部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
Forceps biopsy (FB) is the most commonly used diagnostic tool for lung pathologies. FB is associated with a high diagnostic failure rate. Cryobiopsy (CB) is a novel technique providing a larger specimen size, few artefacts, more alveolar parts and superior diagnostic yield. CB, however, has drawbacks such as higher bleeding and pneumothorax rate. We conducted a meta-analysis to investigate the specimen area, diagnostic rate and bleeding severity in CB versus FB in interstitial lung diseases (ILDs) and lung tumours. A systematic literature search of PUBMED, BIOSIS PREVIEW and OVID databases was conducted using specific search terms. Eligible studies including RCTs and non-RCTs comparing cryobiopsy/cryotransbronchial biopsy (CB/CTBB) and forceps biopsy/forceps transbronchial biopsy (FB/FTBB) for specimen area, diagnostic rate and bleeding rate in ILDs and lung tumours were analysed. Two reviewers independently extracted data and evaluated the quality of the studies. Eight studies involving 916 patients were analysed. Specimen area (mm(2)) was significantly larger in CB/CTBB than FB/FTBB (standard mean difference= 1.21, 95% confidence interval (0.94, 1.48), P<0.00001). The diagnostic rate was significantly higher in CB/CTBB than FB/FTBB (Risk ratio 1.36, 95% confidence interval (1.16, 1.59), P=0.0002). Three studies compared the bleeding severity with only one showing significantly more bleeding in CB. Cryobiopsy/cryotransbronchial shows superiority to FB/FTBB for specimen area and diagnostic rate. CB/CTBB has better efficacy over FB/FTBB.
引用
收藏
页码:834 / 841
页数:8
相关论文
共 30 条
[1]   Endobronchial cryobiopsy or forceps biopsy for lung cancer diagnosis [J].
Aktas, Zafer ;
Gunay, Ersin ;
Hoca, Nevin Taci ;
Yilmaz, Aydin ;
Demirag, Funda ;
Gunay, Sibel ;
Sipit, Tugrul ;
Kurt, Emine Bahar .
ANNALS OF THORACIC MEDICINE, 2010, 5 (04) :242-246
[2]   Transbronchial Cryobiopsy: A New Tool for Lung Biopsies [J].
Babiak, Alexander ;
Hetzel, Juergen ;
Krishna, Ganesh ;
Fritz, Peter ;
Moeller, Peter ;
Balli, Tahsin ;
Hetzel, Martin .
RESPIRATION, 2009, 78 (02) :203-208
[3]   Transbronchial Lung Cryobiopsy in the Diagnosis of Fibrotic Interstitial Lung Diseases [J].
Casoni, Gian Luca ;
Tomassetti, Sara ;
Cavazza, Alberto ;
Colby, Thomas V. ;
Dubini, Alessandra ;
Ryu, Jay H. ;
Carretta, Elisa ;
Tantalocco, Paola ;
Piciucchi, Sara ;
Ravaglia, Claudia ;
Gurioli, Christian ;
Romagnoli, Micaela ;
Gurioli, Carlo ;
Chilosi, Marco ;
Poletti, Venerino .
PLOS ONE, 2014, 9 (02)
[4]   Role of Flexible Bronchoscopic Cryotechnology in Diagnosing Endobronchial Masses [J].
Chou, Chun-Liang ;
Wang, Chih-Wei ;
Lin, Shu-Min ;
Fang, Yueh-Fu ;
Yu, Chih-Teng ;
Chen, Hao-Cheng ;
Kuo, Chih-Hsi ;
Hsieh, Meng-Heng ;
Chung, Fu-Tsai .
ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 2013, 95 (03) :982-986
[5]   TRANSBRONCHIAL LUNG-BIOPSY - HISTOPATHOLOGIC AND MORPHOMETRIC ASSESSMENT OF DIAGNOSTIC UTILITY [J].
FRAIRE, AE ;
COOPER, SP ;
GREENBERG, SD ;
ROWLAND, LP ;
LANGSTON, C .
CHEST, 1992, 102 (03) :748-752
[6]   Histological diagnosis of interstitial lung diseases by cryo-transbronchial biopsy [J].
Fruchter, Oren ;
Fridel, Ludmila ;
El Raouf, Bayya Abed ;
Abdel-Rahman, Nader ;
Rosengarten, Dror ;
Kramer, Mordechai R. .
RESPIROLOGY, 2014, 19 (05) :683-688
[7]   Therapeutic effects of sequential therapy by electric coagulation, cryotherapy and balloon dilation with an electronic video bronchoscope [J].
Fu, En-Qing ;
Nan, Yan-Dong ;
Jin, Fa-Guang ;
Ma, Ai-Qun .
EXPERIMENTAL AND THERAPEUTIC MEDICINE, 2013, 5 (06) :1649-1656
[8]   FIBEROPTIC BRONCHOSCOPY - EFFECT OF MULTIPLE BRONCHIAL BIOPSIES ON DIAGNOSTIC YIELD IN BRONCHIAL-CARCINOMA [J].
GELLERT, AR ;
RUDD, RM ;
SINHA, G ;
GEDDES, DM .
THORAX, 1982, 37 (09) :684-687
[9]   Cost-effectiveness of collecting routine cytologic specimens during fiberoptic bronchoscopy for endoscopically visible lung tumor [J].
Govert, JA ;
Kopita, JM ;
Matchar, D ;
Kussin, PS ;
Samuelson, WM .
CHEST, 1996, 109 (02) :451-456
[10]   Morphometrical analysis of transbronchial cryobiopsies [J].
Griff, Sergej ;
Ammenwerth, Wim ;
Schoenfeld, Nicolas ;
Bauer, Torsten T. ;
Mairinger, Thomas ;
Blum, Torsten-Gerriet ;
Kollmeier, Jens ;
Gruening, Wolfram .
DIAGNOSTIC PATHOLOGY, 2011, 6