Does mild hypothermia protect against reperfusion injury? The debate continues

Mild hypothermia (32-35A degrees C) salvages ischemic myocardium and reduces infarct size in hearts undergoing ischemia/reperfusion. It is clear that a cardioprotective effect is evident when the heart is cooled during ischemia, and the protection is greater as the duration of normothermic ischemia is increasingly limited. The effect of cooling just before and at reperfusion is more controversial. Multiple experimental studies have revealed no effect of mild hypothermia on myocardial infarction when cooling was initiated in the waning minutes of ischemia. But Gotberg et al. have demonstrated a small effect in pigs cooled with cold intravenous saline and a venous thermode, although the effect of cooling during ischemia continued to be more prominent. Clinical studies have been disappointing, and possible explanations are offered. Gotberg's new data are encouraging, but it is questioned whether this is the correct time to conduct a new large-scale clinical trial.