Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate versus Platelet Rich Plasma or Hyaluronic Acid for the Treatment of Knee Osteoarthritis

被引:61
作者
Dulic, Oliver [1 ,2 ,3 ,4 ,5 ]
Rasovic, Predrag [2 ,3 ]
Lalic, Ivica [2 ,3 ]
Kecojevic, Vaso [2 ]
Gavrilovic, Gordan [4 ]
Abazovic, Dzihan [6 ]
Maric, Dusan [3 ,5 ]
Miskulin, Mladen [7 ,8 ]
Bumbasirevic, Marko [1 ,9 ]
机构
[1] Univ Belgrade, Med Fac, Belgrade 11000, Serbia
[2] Clin Ctr Vojvodina, Dept Orthoped Surg & Traumatol, Hajduk Veljkova 1-9, Novi Sad 21000, Serbia
[3] Univ Novi Sad, Med Fac, Novi Sad 21000, Serbia
[4] Atlas Hosp, Belgrade 11000, Serbia
[5] MD Orto Hosp, Novi Sad 21000, Serbia
[6] Renova Hosp Belgrade, Belgrade 11000, Serbia
[7] Specijalna Boln Neurokirurgiju & Ortopediju Aksis, Zagreb 10000, Croatia
[8] Univ Split, Med Fac, Split 21000, Croatia
[9] Clin Ctr Serbia, Clin Orthoped Surg & Traumatol, Belgrade 11000, Serbia
来源
MEDICINA-LITHUANIA | 2021年 / 57卷 / 11期
关键词
bone marrow aspirate concentrate; platelet rich plasma; hyaluronic acid; knee osteoarthritis; regenerative medicine; stem cells; MESENCHYMAL STEM-CELLS; BASIC SCIENCE; INJECTION; EFFICACY; THERAPY; CARTILAGE;
D O I
10.3390/medicina57111193
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background: In the last decade, regenerative therapies have become one of the leading disease modifying options for treatment of knee osteoarthritis (OA). Still, there is a lack of trials with a direct comparison of different biological treatments. Our aim was to directly compare clinical outcomes of knee injections of Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate (BMAC), Platelet-rich Plasma (PRP), or Hyaluronic acid (HA) in the OA treatment. Methods: Patients with knee pain and osteoarthritis KL grade II to IV were randomized to receive a BMAC, PRP, and HA injection in the knee. VAS, WOMAC, KOOS, and IKDC scores were used to establish baseline values at 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. All side effects were reported. Results: A total of 175 patients with a knee osteoarthritis KL grade II-IV were randomized; 111 were treated with BMAC injection, 30 with HA injection, and 34 patients with PRP injection. There were no differences between these groups when considering KL grade, BMI, age, or gender. There were no serious side effects. The mean VAS scores after 3, 7, 14, and 21 days showed significant differences between groups with a drop of VAS in all groups but with a difference in the BMAC group in comparison to other groups (p < 0.001). There were high statistically significant differences between baseline scores and those after 12 months (p < 0.001) in WOMAC, KOOS, KOOS pain, and IKDC scores, and in addition, there were differences between these scores in the BMAC group in comparison with other groups, except for the PRP group in WOMAC and the partial IKDC score. There were no differences between the HA and PRP groups, although PRP showed a higher level of clinical improvement. Conclusions: Bone marrow aspirate concentrate, Leukocyte rich Platelet Rich Plasma, and Hyaluronic acid injections are safe therapeutic options for knee OA and provide positive clinical outcomes after 12 months in comparison with findings preceding the intervention. BMAC could be better in terms of clinical improvements in the treatment of knee OA than PRP and HA up to 12 months. PRP provides better outcomes than HA during the observation period, but these results are not statistically significant. More randomized controlled trials and high quality comparative studies are needed for direct correlative conclusions.
引用
收藏
页数:14
相关论文
共 40 条
[1]   The mechanism of action for hyaluronic acid treatment in the osteoarthritic knee: a systematic review [J].
Altman, R. D. ;
Manjoo, A. ;
Fierlinger, A. ;
Niazi, F. ;
Nicholls, M. .
BMC MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS, 2015, 16
[2]   Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate Is Equivalent to Platelet-Rich Plasma for the Treatment of Knee Osteoarthritis at 1 Year: A Prospective, Randomized Trial [J].
Anz, Adam W. ;
Hubbard, Ryan ;
Rendos, Nicole K. ;
Everts, Peter A. ;
Andrews, James R. ;
Hackel, Joshua G. .
ORTHOPAEDIC JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 2020, 8 (02)
[3]   The Basic Science of Platelet-rich Plasma (PRP): What Clinicians Need to Know [J].
Arnoczky, Steven P. ;
Shebani-Rad, Shahin .
SPORTS MEDICINE AND ARTHROSCOPY REVIEW, 2013, 21 (04) :180-185
[4]   Intraarticular injections (corticosteroid, hyaluronic acid, platelet rich plasma) for the knee osteoarthritis [J].
Ayhan, Egemen ;
Kesmezacar, Hayrettin ;
Akgun, Isik .
WORLD JOURNAL OF ORTHOPEDICS, 2014, 5 (03) :351-361
[5]   Does Intra-articular Platelet-Rich Plasma Injection Provide Clinically Superior Outcomes Compared With Other Therapies in the Treatment of Knee Osteoarthritis? A Systematic Review of Overlapping Meta-analyses [J].
Campbell, Kirk A. ;
Saltzman, Bryan M. ;
Mascarenhas, Randy ;
Khair, M. Michael ;
Verma, Nikhil N. ;
Bach, Bernard R., Jr. ;
Cole, Brian J. .
ARTHROSCOPY-THE JOURNAL OF ARTHROSCOPIC AND RELATED SURGERY, 2015, 31 (11) :2213-2221
[6]   Mesenchymal stem cells: Cell-based reconstructive therapy in orthopedics [J].
Caplan, AI .
TISSUE ENGINEERING, 2005, 11 (7-8) :1198-1211
[7]   A specific protocol of autologous bone marrow concentrate and platelet products versus exercise therapy for symptomatic knee osteoarthritis: a randomized controlled trial with 2year follow-up [J].
Centeno, Christopher ;
Sheinkop, Mitchell ;
Dodson, Ehren ;
Stemper, Ian ;
Williams, Christopher ;
Hyzy, Matthew ;
Ichim, Thomas ;
Freeman, Michael .
JOURNAL OF TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2018, 16
[8]   Efficacy of Autologous Bone Marrow Concentrate for Knee Osteoarthritis with and without Adipose Graft [J].
Centeno, Christopher ;
Pitts, John ;
Al-Sayegh, Hasan ;
Freeman, Michael .
BIOMED RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL, 2014, 2014
[9]   A multi-center analysis of adverse events among two thousand, three hundred and seventy two adult patients undergoing adult autologous stem cell therapy for orthopaedic conditions [J].
Centeno, Christopher J. ;
Al-Sayegh, Hasan ;
Freeman, Michael D. ;
Smith, Jay ;
Murrell, William D. ;
Bubnov, Rostyslav .
INTERNATIONAL ORTHOPAEDICS, 2016, 40 (08) :1755-1765
[10]   Concentrated Bone Marrow Aspirate for the Treatment of Chondral Injuries and Osteoarthritis of the Knee: A Systematic Review of Outcomes [J].
Chahla, Jorge ;
Dean, Chase S. ;
Moatshe, Gilbert ;
Pascual-Garrido, Cecilia ;
Cruz, Raphael Serra ;
LaPrade, Robert F. .
ORTHOPAEDIC JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 2016, 4 (01)