Improved postoperative analgesia with isoflurane than with propofol anaesthesia

被引:14
作者
Boccara, G
Mann, C
Pouzeratte, Y
Bellavoir, A
Rouvier, A
Colson, P
机构
[1] Hop St Eloi, Dept Anaesthesiol & Intens Care Med, DARB, Montpellier, France
[2] Hop Instruct Armees Begin, Dept Plast Surg, St Mande, France
[3] Hop Instruct Armees Begin, Dept Anaesthesiol, St Mande, France
来源
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA-JOURNAL CANADIEN D ANESTHESIE | 1998年 / 45卷 / 09期
关键词
D O I
10.1007/BF03012216
中图分类号
R614 [麻醉学];
学科分类号
100217 ;
摘要
Purpose: The impact of hypnotic drugs on postoperative analgesia has not been evaluated, We compared the influence of the maintenance of anaesthesia with either propofol or isoflurane on postoperative pain. Methods: Forty ASA 1-2 women. undergoing cosmetic abdominoplasty were randomized to receive either 6-12 mg.kg(-1).hr(-1) propofol iv (P, n = 20) or MAC 1-1.5 isoflurane inhalation (Iso, n = 20). The lungs were ventilated with N2O 60% and O-2 40%, and 1 mu g.kg(-1) fentanyl iv provided intraoperative analgesia. Before surgical closure. 2 g propacetamol iv were administered. Postoperative analgesia was provided after hourly assessment of pain (VAS 0-100 mm), with 10 mg nalbuphine iv if VAS greater than or equal to 50 mm, during the eight hours after surgery. Sedation score (awake 0 to unrousable 4) was also recorded, Analgesia satisfaction score (nil 0 to excellent 4) obtained from the patient on discharge. Results: Sedation scores were similar in both groups except in the first postoperative hour, when it was higher in the Iso group. The VAS at rest (15.4 +/- 18.6 vs 29.7 +/- 19.8 mm, P = 0.0001) and nalbuphine requirements (0.13 +/- 0.35 vs 0.70 +/- 0.80 doses, P = 0.004) were lower in the iso group during the first six hours, although emesis was more frequent than in P (60 vs 25%; P = 0.03), The incidence of analgesia satisfaction score (greater than or equal to 3) was similar between the two groups (P: 95; Iso: 75%). Conclusion: These results suggested that isoflurane anaesthesia provides better analgesia than propofol anaesthesia in the first six hours after abdominoplasty.
引用
收藏
页码:839 / 842
页数:4
相关论文
共 13 条
[1]   MORPHINE, BUT NOT INHALATION ANESTHESIA, BLOCKS POSTINJURY FACILITATION - THE ROLE OF PREEMPTIVE SUPPRESSION OF AFFERENT TRANSMISSION [J].
ABRAM, SE ;
YAKSH, TL .
ANESTHESIOLOGY, 1993, 78 (04) :713-721
[2]   SUBHYPNOTIC DOSES OF THIOPENTONE AND PROPOFOL CAUSE ANALGESIA TO EXPERIMENTALLY INDUCED ACUTE PAIN [J].
ANKERMOLLER, E ;
SPANGSBERG, N ;
ARENDTNIELSEN, L ;
SCHULTZ, P ;
KRISTENSEN, MS ;
BJERRING, P .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA, 1991, 66 (02) :185-188
[3]   PROPOFOL NITROUS OXIDE VERSUS THIOPENTAL-ISOFLURANE NITROUS OXIDE FOR GENERAL-ANESTHESIA [J].
DOZE, VA ;
SHAFER, A ;
WHITE, PF .
ANESTHESIOLOGY, 1988, 69 (01) :63-71
[4]   Volatile anaesthetics antagonize nitrous oxide and morphine-induced analgesia in the rat [J].
Goto, T ;
Marota, JJA ;
Crosby, G .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA, 1996, 76 (05) :702-706
[5]   PROPOFOL AND BARBITURATE DEPRESSION OF SPINAL NOCICEPTIVE NEUROTRANSMISSION [J].
JEWETT, BA ;
GIBBS, LM ;
TARASIUK, A ;
KENDIG, JJ .
ANESTHESIOLOGY, 1992, 77 (06) :1148-1154
[6]   RANDOMIZED COMPARISON OF RECOVERY AFTER PROPOFOL-NITROUS OXIDE VERSUS THIOPENTONE-ISOFLURANE-NITROUS OXIDE ANESTHESIA IN PATIENTS UNDERGOING AMBULATORY SURGERY [J].
KORTTILA, K ;
OSTMAN, P ;
FAURE, E ;
APFELBAUM, JL ;
PRUNSKIS, J ;
EKDAWI, M ;
ROIZEN, MF .
ACTA ANAESTHESIOLOGICA SCANDINAVICA, 1990, 34 (05) :400-403
[7]   EFFECTS OF HALOTHANE ON SPINAL NEURONAL RESPONSES TO GRADED NOXIOUS HEAT STIMULATION IN THE CAT [J].
NAMIKI, A ;
COLLINS, JG ;
KITAHATA, LM ;
KIKUCHI, H ;
HOMMA, E ;
THALHAMMER, JG .
ANESTHESIOLOGY, 1980, 53 (06) :475-480
[8]   INHIBITION OF NOCICEPTION-INDUCED SPINAL SENSITIZATION BY ANESTHETIC AGENTS [J].
OCONNOR, TC ;
ABRAM, SE .
ANESTHESIOLOGY, 1995, 82 (01) :259-266
[9]   Psychophysical and electrophysiological responses to experimental pain may be influenced by sedation: Comparison of the effects of a hypnotic (propofol) and an analgesic (alfentanil) [J].
PetersenFelix, S ;
ArendtNielsen, L ;
Bak, P ;
Fischer, M ;
Zbinden, AM .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA, 1996, 77 (02) :165-171
[10]   ANALGESIC EFFECT IN HUMANS OF SUBANAESTHETIC ISOFLURANE CONCENTRATIONS EVALUATED BY EXPERIMENTALLY-INDUCED PAIN [J].
PETERSENFELIX, S ;
ARENDTNIELSEN, L ;
BAK, P ;
ROTH, D ;
FISCHER, M ;
BJERRING, P ;
ZBINDEN, AM .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIA, 1995, 75 (01) :55-60