The educational value of using cumulative sum charts

被引:5
作者
Smith, S. E. [1 ]
Tallentire, V. R.
Spiller, J. [2 ]
Wood, S. M. [3 ]
Cameron, H. S. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Edinburgh, Ctr Med Educ, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland
[2] Univ Edinburgh, Learning Technol Sect, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland
[3] Queen Margaret Hosp, Dunfermline, Fife, Scotland
关键词
LEARNING-CURVE; CUSUM; SKILLS;
D O I
10.1111/j.1365-2044.2012.07100.x
中图分类号
R614 [麻醉学];
学科分类号
100217 ;
摘要
Various workplace-based assessment tools are available, but none have been shown to improve performance in procedural skills. This study aimed to assess the impact of using one such tool, cumulative sum charts, on procedural skill ability. A single-blind randomised controlled trial was conducted on 82 final year medical students. Control group students received the usual teaching; in addition to this, intervention group students were provided with cumulative sum charts to log their cannulation attempts over a 7-month period. At the end of the year, students from both groups undertook a validated test of automaticity of cannulation skill. Students in the intervention group obtained median (IQR [range]) scores of 68.2 (60.574.3 [42.781.1]) vs 62.2 (52.268.8 [40.780.5]) for the control group (p = 0.013). The effect size was moderate (Cohens d = 0.608). This study therefore provides support for the hypothesis that use of cumulative sum charts improves performance when learning procedural skills.
引用
收藏
页码:734 / 740
页数:7
相关论文
共 50 条
[21]   Cumulative sum analysis of the learning curve for the preclosure technique using Proglide [J].
Gao, Haoyu ;
Luo, Mingyao ;
Fang, Kun ;
Fan, Bowen ;
Zhao, Jiawei ;
Xue, Yunfei ;
Shu, Chang .
INTERACTIVE CARDIOVASCULAR AND THORACIC SURGERY, 2020, 30 (02) :280-286
[22]   Assessment of progress and competence in tonsillectomy surgery using cumulative sum analysis [J].
Abou-Foul, A. K. ;
Taghi, A. ;
Tolley, N. S. ;
Awad, Z. .
JOURNAL OF LARYNGOLOGY AND OTOLOGY, 2018, 132 (08) :734-738
[23]   Learning curve of vessel cannulation in rats using cumulative sum analysis [J].
Christakis, Ioannis ;
Georgiou, Panagiotis ;
Minnion, James ;
Constantinides, Vasilis ;
Cuenco, Joyceline ;
Scott, Rebecca ;
Tan, Tricia ;
Palazzo, Fausto ;
Murphy, Kevin ;
Bloom, Stephen .
JOURNAL OF SURGICAL RESEARCH, 2015, 193 (01) :69-76
[24]   Analysis of the Surgical Learning Curve Using the Cumulative Sum (CUSUM) Method [J].
Maguire, Turlough ;
Mayne, Christopher J. ;
Terry, Tim ;
Tincello, Douglas G. .
NEUROUROLOGY AND URODYNAMICS, 2013, 32 (07) :964-967
[25]   Adaptive simulation training using cumulative sum: a randomized prospective trial [J].
Hu, Yinin ;
Brooks, Kendall D. ;
Kim, Helen ;
Mahmutovic, Adela ;
Choi, Joanna ;
Le, Ivy A. ;
Kane, Bartholomew J. ;
McGahren, Eugene D. ;
Rasmussen, Sara K. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2016, 211 (02) :377-383
[26]   Optimal design of one-sided exponential cumulative sum charts with known and estimated parameters based on the median run length [J].
Qiao, YuLong ;
Hu, XueLong ;
Sun, JinSheng ;
Xu, Qin .
QUALITY AND RELIABILITY ENGINEERING INTERNATIONAL, 2021, 37 (01) :123-144
[27]   Residual-based cumulative sum charts to monitor time series of counts via copula-based Markov models [J].
Alqawba, Mohammed ;
Kim, Jong-Min ;
Radwan, Taha .
APPLIED STOCHASTIC MODELS IN BUSINESS AND INDUSTRY, 2022, 38 (06) :1039-1048
[28]   Distribution-free mixed cumulative sum-exponentially weighted moving average control charts for detecting mean shifts [J].
Malela-Majika, Jean-Claude ;
Rapoo, Eeva .
QUALITY AND RELIABILITY ENGINEERING INTERNATIONAL, 2017, 33 (08) :1983-2002
[29]   Objective evaluation of technical dexterity in robotic hepaticojejunostomy: Assessment of hepatopancreatobiliary fellows using cumulative sum analytics [J].
Robinson, Jordan ;
Watson, Michael ;
Baimas-George, Maria ;
Iannitti, David ;
Martinie, John ;
Vrochides, Dionisios .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MEDICAL ROBOTICS AND COMPUTER ASSISTED SURGERY, 2021, 17 (05)
[30]   Learning Curve and Complications of Unilateral Biportal Endoscopy : Cumulative Sum and Risk-Adjusted Cumulative Sum Analysis [J].
Xu, Jinchao ;
Wang, Dong ;
Liu, Jidan ;
Zhu, Chengyue ;
Bao, Jianhang ;
Gao, Wenshuo ;
Zhang, Wei ;
Pan, Hao .
NEUROSPINE, 2022, 19 (03) :792-804