An alternate calculation of the distance to M87 using the Whitmore et al luminosity function for its globular clusters: H-0 therefrom

被引:13
作者
Sandage, A [1 ]
Tammann, GA [1 ]
机构
[1] UNIV BASEL,INST ASTRON,CH-4102 BINNINGEN,SWITZERLAND
关键词
distance scale; galaxies; distances and redshifts; individual; (M87); star clusters;
D O I
10.1086/310083
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
An alternate calculation to that made by Whitmore et al. (WSLMB) is set out for the distance to M87 using their globular cluster luminosity function (GCLF) for M87 in the Virgo Cluster. They have concluded from these data that H-0 = 78 +/- 11 km s(-1) Mpc(-1). Our purpose is to show how a different set of precepts leads to a substantially smaller value of H-0 that is in statistical agreement with other analyses that favor the long distance scale. Adopting the WSLMB observed turnover apparent magnitude for the GCLF of V = 23.79 +/- 0.2 (external), together with A(V) = 0.00 mag for the foreground Galactic absorption, and [M(V)](0) = -7.62 +/- 0.2 (external) as the calibration of the turnover luminosity gives (m - M)(0) = 31.41 +/- 0.28 for the distance modulus of M87. Using the cosmic velocity of the E galaxy Virgo core as v(cosmic) = 1179 +/- 17 km s(-1) gives Ho = 62 +/- 9 km s(-1) Mpc(-1). The procedure of WSLMB and others in stepping a Virgo distance to the Coma Cluster and then using a Coma velocity that still contains a random component to determine H-0 is argued. The cosmic velocity for Virgo, calculated by reading a Hubble diagram of relative distances of 17 ''remote'' clusters versus cosmic microwave background velocities at zero modulus difference to Virgo (Jerjen & Tammann), overcomes this error by circumventing the problem of accounting for any random and/or streaming motions of the Virgo Cluster and/or of the Coma Cluster about the ideal Hubble flow. This procedure cuts to the core of the distance scale problem, eliminating the major uncertainty concerning local random motions. Four sources of possible systematic errors in the Virgo Cluster modulus using the GCLF method, as applied to M87, are also set out, suggesting that the value of H-0 = 62 is an upper limit.
引用
收藏
页码:L51 / L54
页数:4
相关论文
共 56 条
  • [1] Hubble space telescope observations of globular clusters in M31 .1. Color-magnitude diagrams, horizontal branch metallicity dependence, and the distance to M31
    Ajhar, EA
    Grillmair, CJ
    Lauer, TR
    Baum, WA
    Faber, SM
    Holtzman, JA
    Lynds, CR
    ONeil, EJ
    [J]. ASTRONOMICAL JOURNAL, 1996, 111 (03) : 1110 - &
  • [2] GLOBULAR-CLUSTER SYSTEMS AS DISTANCE INDICATORS - METALLICITY EFFECTS ON THE LUMINOSITY FUNCTION
    ASHMAN, KM
    CONTI, A
    ZEPF, SE
    [J]. ASTRONOMICAL JOURNAL, 1995, 110 (03) : 1164 - 1170
  • [3] Globular clusters in coma galaxy NGC 4881
    Baum, WA
    Hammergren, M
    Groth, EJ
    Ajhar, EA
    Lauer, TR
    ONeil, EJ
    Lynds, CR
    Faber, SM
    Grillmair, CJ
    Holtzman, JA
    Light, RM
    [J]. ASTRONOMICAL JOURNAL, 1995, 110 (06) : 2537 - &
  • [4] BOTTINELLI L, 1986, ASTRON ASTROPHYS, V156, P157
  • [5] BOTTINELLI L, 1987, ASTRON ASTROPHYS, V181, P1
  • [6] REDDENING ESTIMATES FOR GALAXIES IN THE 2ND REFERENCE CATALOG AND THE UPPSALA GENERAL CATALOG
    BURSTEIN, D
    HEILES, C
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL SUPPLEMENT SERIES, 1984, 54 (01) : 33 - 79
  • [7] COX DP, 1987, ANNU REV ASTRON ASTR, V25, P303
  • [8] POST-MAIN-SEQUENCE AND POST RED GIANT BRANCH VARIABLES WITH PULSATION PERIODS LESS-THAN ONE-DAY
    EGGEN, OJ
    [J]. ASTRONOMICAL JOURNAL, 1994, 107 (06) : 2131 - 2147
  • [9] The globular clusters in M87: A bimodal, colour distribution
    Elson, RAW
    Santiago, BX
    [J]. MONTHLY NOTICES OF THE ROYAL ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY, 1996, 278 (02) : 617 - 624
  • [10] BIAS PROPERTIES OF EXTRAGALACTIC DISTANCE INDICATORS .3. ANALYSIS OF TULLY-FISHER DISTANCES FOR THE MATHEWSON-FORD-BUCHHORN SAMPLE OF 1355 GALAXIES
    FEDERSPIEL, M
    SANDAGE, A
    TAMMANN, GA
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1994, 430 (01) : 29 - 52