Training and Surgical Simulation in Skull Base Surgery: a Systematic Review

被引:2
作者
Lavigne, Philippe [1 ]
Yang, Nathan [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Montreal, Dept Otolaryngol Head & Neck Surg, Montreal, PQ, Canada
关键词
Cranial base surgery; Simulation; Training; Medical education; Virtual reality; ENDONASAL TRANSSPHENOIDAL SURGERY; ENDOSCOPIC SINUS SURGERY; CAROTID-ARTERY INJURY; VIRTUAL-REALITY; TASK TRAINER; LOW-COST; MODEL; VALIDATION; MANAGEMENT;
D O I
10.1007/s40136-020-00280-z
中图分类号
R76 [耳鼻咽喉科学];
学科分类号
100213 ;
摘要
Purpose of ReviewSimulation devices and training protocols are being developed across all surgical fields to teach trainees and optimize learning to improve performance when operating on live patients. This article presents a review of the available literature specific to training and simulation in endoscopic endonasal skull base surgery.Recent FindingsA systematic review of the literature was performed on simulation and training in endoscopic endonasal skull base surgery. The level of evidence, simulation fidelity, and the level of learning effectiveness (Kirkpatrick scale) were assessed for each available study. Thirty studies were included in the review. One study describes a validated training program for training in skull base surgery. The other included studies of present simulation training using cadaveric models, 3D-printed models, virtual reality trainers, or a combination of these modalities. The overall level of learning effectiveness and level of evidence from these studies are low.SummaryThe level of evidence and fidelity of simulators in endoscopic skull base surgery has improved over the years, but high-quality studies are needed to demonstrate the effectiveness of these learning methods on surgical training.
引用
收藏
页码:154 / 159
页数:6
相关论文
共 40 条
  • [31] Blinded Evaluation of Endoscopic Skill and Instructability After Implementation of an Endoscopic Simulation Experience
    Stephenson, Elizabeth D.
    Farquhar, Douglas R.
    Masood, Maheer M.
    Capra, Gregory
    Kimple, Adam
    Ebert, Charles S., Jr.
    Thorp, Brian D.
    Zanation, Adam M.
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF RHINOLOGY & ALLERGY, 2019, 33 (06) : 681 - 690
  • [32] A physical simulator for endoscopic endonasal drilling techniques: technical note
    Tai, Bruce L.
    Wang, Anthony C.
    Joseph, Jacob R.
    Wang, Page I.
    Sullivan, Stephen E.
    McKean, Erin L.
    Shih, Albert J.
    Rooney, Deborah M.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF NEUROSURGERY, 2016, 124 (03) : 811 - 816
  • [33] Resident simulation training in endoscopic endonasal surgery utilizing haptic feedback technology
    Thawani, Jayesh P.
    Ramayya, Ashwin G.
    Abdullah, Kalil G.
    Hudgins, Eric
    Vaughan, Kerry
    Piazza, Matthew
    Madsen, Peter J.
    Buch, Vivek
    Grady, M. Sean
    [J]. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NEUROSCIENCE, 2016, 34 : 112 - 116
  • [34] Virtual Reality: A New Paranasal Sinus Surgery Simulator
    Tolsdorff, Boris
    Pommert, Andreas
    Hoehne, Karl Heinz
    Petersik, Andreas
    Pflesser, Bernhard
    Tiede, Ulf
    Leuwer, Rudolf
    [J]. LARYNGOSCOPE, 2010, 120 (02) : 420 - 426
  • [35] Simulation Training for Vascular Emergencies in Endoscopic Sinus and Skull Base Surgery
    Valentine, Rowan
    Padhye, Vikram
    Wormald, Peter-John
    [J]. OTOLARYNGOLOGIC CLINICS OF NORTH AMERICA, 2016, 49 (03) : 877 - +
  • [36] Development of the McGill simulator for endoscopic sinus surgery: A new high-fidelity virtual reality simulator for endoscopic sinus surgery
    Varshney, Rickul
    Frenkiel, Saul
    Nguyen, Lily H. P.
    Young, Meredith
    Del Maestro, Rolando
    Zeitouni, Anthony
    Tewfik, Marc A.
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF RHINOLOGY & ALLERGY, 2014, 28 (04) : 330 - 334
  • [37] ICAR: endoscopic skull-base surgery
    Wang, Eric W.
    Zanation, Adam M.
    Gardner, Paul A.
    Schwartz, Theodore H.
    Eloy, Jean Anderson
    Adappa, Nithin D.
    Bettag, Martin
    Bleier, Benjamin S.
    Cappabianca, Paolo
    Carrau, Ricardo L.
    Casiano, Roy R.
    Cavallo, Luigi M.
    Ebert, Charles S., Jr.
    El-Sayed, Ivan H.
    Evans, James J.
    Fernandez-Miranda, Juan C.
    Folbe, Adam J.
    Froelich, Sebastien
    Gentili, Fred
    Harvey, Richard J.
    Hwang, Peter H.
    Jane, John A., Jr.
    Kelly, Daniel F.
    Kennedy, David
    Knosp, Engelbert
    Lal, Devyani
    Lee, John Y. K.
    Liu, James K.
    Lund, Valerie J.
    Palmer, James N.
    Prevedello, Daniel M.
    Schlosser, Rodney J.
    Sindwani, Raj
    Solares, C. Arturo
    Tabaee, Abtin
    Teo, Charles
    Thirumala, Parthasarathy D.
    Thorp, Brian D.
    Silva Vellutini, Eduardo de Arnaldo
    Witterick, Ian
    Woodworth, Bradford A.
    Wormald, Peter-John
    Yang, Andrew, I
    Snyderman, Carl H.
    Banks, Catherine
    de Oliveira, Matheus Fernandes
    Di Somma, Alberto
    Elsawy, Ahmad
    Ferguson, Mark S.
    Garcia, Hermes G.
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL FORUM OF ALLERGY & RHINOLOGY, 2019, 9 : S145 - S365
  • [38] A practical 3D printed simulator for endoscopic endonasal transsphenoidal surgery to improve basic operational skills
    Wen, Guodao
    Cong, ZiXiang
    Liu, KaiDong
    Tang, Chao
    Zhong, Chunyu
    Li, Liwen
    Dai, XuJie
    Ma, Chiyuan
    [J]. CHILDS NERVOUS SYSTEM, 2016, 32 (06) : 1109 - 1116
  • [39] A novel three-dimensional-printed paranasal sinus-skull base anatomical model
    Zhang, Xiao-Dong
    Li, Zhong-Hua
    Wu, Zhi-Sheng
    Lin, Wen
    Lin, Wen-Ji
    Lin, Jin-Chao
    Zhuang, Li-Ming
    [J]. EUROPEAN ARCHIVES OF OTO-RHINO-LARYNGOLOGY, 2018, 275 (08) : 2045 - 2049
  • [40] Three-Dimensional Printed Skull Base Simulation for Transnasal Endoscopic Surgical Training
    Zheng, Jia-Ping
    Li, Chu-Zhong
    Chen, Guo-Qiang
    Song, Gui-Dong
    Zhang, Ya-Zhuo
    [J]. WORLD NEUROSURGERY, 2018, 111 : E773 - E782