Comparison of Antigen Tests and qPCR in Rapid Diagnostics of Infections Caused by SARS-CoV-2 Virus

被引:9
作者
Klajmon, Adrianna [1 ]
Olechowska-Jarzab, Aldona [2 ]
Salamon, Dominika [3 ]
Sroka-Oleksiak, Agnieszka [3 ]
Brzychczy-Wloch, Monika [3 ]
Gosiewski, Tomasz [3 ]
机构
[1] John Paul 2 Hosp, Dept Mol Biol, Ul Pradnicka 80, PL-31202 Krakow, Poland
[2] John Paul 2 Hosp, Dept Microbiol, Ul Pradnicka 80, PL-31202 Krakow, Poland
[3] Jagiellonian Univ, Coll Med, Fac Med, Dept Mol Med Microbiol,Chair Microbiol, Ul Czysta 18, PL-31121 Krakow, Poland
来源
VIRUSES-BASEL | 2022年 / 14卷 / 01期
关键词
SARS-CoV-2; COVID-19; laboratory diagnostics; antigen test; NAAT; qPCR; CORONAVIRUS;
D O I
10.3390/v14010017
中图分类号
Q93 [微生物学];
学科分类号
071005 ; 100705 ;
摘要
Diagnostics of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) using molecular techniques from the collected respiratory swab specimens requires well-equipped laboratory and qualified personnel, also it needs several hours of waiting for results and is expensive. Antigen tests appear to be faster and cheaper but their sensitivity and specificity are debatable. The aim of this study was to compare a selected antigen test with quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) tests results. Nasopharyngeal swabs were collected from 192 patients with COVID-19 symptoms. All samples were tested using Vitassay qPCR SARS-CoV-2 kit and the Humasis COVID-19 Ag Test (MedSun) antigen immunochromatographic test simultaneously. Ultimately, 189 samples were tested; 3 samples were excluded due to errors in taking swabs. The qPCR and antigen test results were as follows: 47 positive and 142 negative, and 45 positive and 144 negative, respectively. Calculated sensitivity of 91.5% and specificity of 98.6% for the antigen test shows differences which are not statistically significant in comparison to qPCR. Our study showed that effectiveness of the antigen tests in rapid laboratory diagnostics is high enough to be an alternative and support for nucleic acid amplification tests (NAAT) in the virus replication phase in the course of COVID-19.
引用
收藏
页数:9
相关论文
共 50 条
[21]   Clinical performance evaluation of SARS-CoV-2 rapid antigen testing in point of care usage in comparison to RT-qPCR [J].
Wagenhauser, Isabell ;
Knies, Kerstin ;
Rauschenberger, Vera ;
Eisenmann, Michael ;
McDonogh, Miriam ;
Petri, Nils ;
Andres, Oliver ;
Flemming, Sven ;
Gawlik, Micha ;
Papsdorf, Michael ;
Taurines, Regina ;
Boehn, Hartmut ;
Forster, Johannes ;
Weismann, Dirk ;
Weissbrich, Benedikt ;
Doelken, Lars ;
Liese, Johannes ;
Kurzai, Oliver ;
Vogel, Ulrich ;
Krone, Manuel .
EBIOMEDICINE, 2021, 69
[22]   Head-to-Head Comparison of Rapid and Automated Antigen Detection Tests for the Diagnosis of SARS-CoV-2 Infection [J].
Favresse, Julien ;
Gillot, Constant ;
Oliveira, Maxime ;
Cadrobbi, Julie ;
Elsen, Marc ;
Eucher, Christine ;
Laffineur, Kim ;
Rosseels, Catherine ;
Van Eeckhoudt, Sandrine ;
Nicolas, Jean-Baptiste ;
Morimont, Laure ;
Dogne, Jean-Michel ;
Douxfils, Jonathan .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE, 2021, 10 (02) :1-10
[23]   Efficacy comparison of three rapid antigen tests for SARS-CoV-2 and how viral load impact their performance [J].
Blairon, Laurent ;
Cupaiolo, Roberto ;
Thomas, Isabelle ;
Piteus, Sebastien ;
Wilmet, Alain ;
Beukinga, Ingrid ;
Tre-Hardy, Marie .
JOURNAL OF MEDICAL VIROLOGY, 2021, 93 (10) :5783-5788
[24]   Rapid, point-of-care antigen tests for diagnosis of SARS-CoV-2 infection [J].
Dinnes, Jacqueline ;
Sharma, Pawana ;
Berhane, Sarah ;
van Wyk, Susanna S. ;
Nyaaba, Nicholas ;
Domen, Julie ;
Taylor, Melissa ;
Cunningham, Jane ;
Davenport, Clare ;
Dittrich, Sabine ;
Emperador, Devy ;
Hooft, Lotty ;
Leeflang, Mariska M. G. ;
McInnes, Matthew D. F. ;
Spijker, Rene ;
Verbakel, Jan Y. ;
Takwoingi, Yemisi ;
Taylor-Phillips, Sian ;
Van den Bruel, Ann ;
Deeks, Jonathan J. .
COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS, 2022, (07)
[25]   Evaluation of SARS-CoV-2 Rapid Antigen Tests in Use on the Isle of Youth, Cuba [J].
Gonzalez-Fiallo, Sayli ;
Mena-Rodriguez, Idorka ;
Castro-Batista, Percy ;
Doeste-Hernandez, Victor M. ;
Louit-Laborit, Viviana .
MEDICC REVIEW, 2022, 24 (02) :15-19
[26]   Evaluation of two rapid antigen tests to detect SARS-CoV-2 in a hospital setting [J].
Osterman, Andreas ;
Baldauf, Hanna-Mari ;
Eletreby, Marwa ;
Wettengel, Jochen M. ;
Afridi, Suliman Q. ;
Fuchs, Thimo ;
Holzmann, Elena ;
Maier, Anton ;
Doring, Johanna ;
Grzimek-Koschewa, Natascha ;
Muenchhoff, Maximilian ;
Protzer, Ulrike ;
Kaderali, Lars ;
Keppler, Oliver T. .
MEDICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND IMMUNOLOGY, 2021, 210 (01) :65-72
[27]   Making sense of rapid antigen testing in severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) diagnostics [J].
Mattiuzzi, Camilla ;
Henry, Brandon M. ;
Lippi, Giuseppe .
DIAGNOSIS, 2021, 8 (01) :27-31
[28]   Considerations for the selection of tests for SARS-CoV-2 molecular diagnostics [J].
Huriye Erbak Yılmaz ;
Evin Iscan ;
Ozden Oz ;
Tuğçe Batur ;
Aybike Erdoğan ;
Seval Kılıç ;
Zeynep Mutlu ;
Murat Yılmaz ;
Kevin J. Spring .
Molecular Biology Reports, 2022, 49 :9725-9735
[29]   Considerations for the selection of tests for SARS-CoV-2 molecular diagnostics [J].
Erbak Yilmaz, Huriye ;
Iscan, Evin ;
Oz, Ozden ;
Batur, Tugce ;
Erdogan, Aybike ;
Kilic, Seval ;
Mutlu, Zeynep ;
Yilmaz, Murat ;
Spring, Kevin J. .
MOLECULAR BIOLOGY REPORTS, 2022, 49 (10) :9725-9735
[30]   Field evaluations of four SARS-CoV-2 rapid antigen tests during SARS-CoV-2 Delta variant wave in South Africa [J].
Samsunder, Natasha ;
Lustig, Gila ;
Ngubane, Slindile ;
Maseko, Thando Glory ;
Rambaran, Santhuri ;
Ngcapu, Sinaye ;
Magini, Stanley Nzuzo ;
Lewis, Lara ;
Cawood, Cherie ;
Kharsany, Ayesha B. M. ;
Karim, Quarraisha Abdool ;
Karim, Salim Abdool ;
Naidoo, Kogieleum ;
Sivro, Aida .
DIAGNOSTIC AND PROGNOSTIC RESEARCH, 2023, 7 (01)