Criticality of O(N) symmetric models in the presence of discrete gauge symmetries

We investigate the critical properties of the three-dimensional antiferromagnetic RPN-1 model, which is characterized by a global O(N) symmetry and a discrete Z(2) gauge symmetry. We perform a field-theoretical analysis using the Landau-Ginzburg-Wilson (LGW) approach and a numerical Monte Carlo study. The LGW field-theoretical results are obtained by high-order perturbative analyses of the renormalization-group flow of the most general Phi(4) theory with the same global symmetry as the model, assuming a gauge-invariant order-parameter field. For N = 4 no stable fixed point is found, implying that any transition must necessarily be of first order. This is contradicted by the numerical results that provide strong evidence for a continuous transition. This suggests that gauge modes are not always irrelevant, as assumed by the LGW approach, but they may play an important role to determine the actual critical dynamics at the phase transition of O(N) symmetric models with a discrete Z(2) gauge symmetry.