Review article: The mechanismic worldview: Thinking inside the box

被引:157
作者
Gerring, John [1 ]
机构
[1] Boston Univ, Dept Polit Sci, Boston, MA 02215 USA
关键词
D O I
10.1017/S0007123408000082
中图分类号
D0 [政治学、政治理论];
学科分类号
0302 ; 030201 ;
摘要
A widespread turn towards mechanism-centred explanations can be viewed across the social sciences in recent decades. This article clarifies what it might mean in practical terms to adopt a mechanismic view of causation. This simple task of definition turns out to be considerably more difficult than it might at first appear. The body of the article elucidates a series of tensions and conflicts within this ambient concept, looking closely at how influential authors have employed this ubiquitous term. It is discovered that 'mechanism' has at least nine distinct meanings as the term is used within contemporary social science: (1) the pathway or process by which an effect is produced; (2) an unobservable causal factor; (3) an easy-to-observe causal factor; (4) a context-dependent (bounded) explanation; (5) a universal (or at least highly general) explanation; (6) an explanation that presumes highly contingent phenomena; (7) an explanation built on phenomena that exhibit lawlike regularities; (8) a distinct technique of analysis (based on qualitative, case study, or process-tracing evidence); or (9) a micro-level explanation for a causal phenomenon. Some of these meanings may be combined into coherent definitions; others are obviously contradictory. It is argued, however, that only the first meaning is consistent with all contemporary usages and with contemporary practices within the social sciences; this is therefore proposed as a minimal (core) definition of the concept. The other meanings are regarded as arguments surrounding the core concept.
引用
收藏
页码:161 / 179
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Thinking outside the box ... inside the box
    Winkel, Brian
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MATHEMATICAL EDUCATION IN SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, 2012, 43 (05) : 663 - 668
  • [22] Thinking inside and outside the box
    Powell, WE
    FAMILIES IN SOCIETY-THE JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY SOCIAL SERVICES, 2006, 87 (02): : 155 - 156
  • [23] Thinking From Inside the Box
    Swaminathan, Madhav
    SEMINARS IN CARDIOTHORACIC AND VASCULAR ANESTHESIA, 2008, 12 (04) : 225 - 227
  • [24] Thinking inside and outside the box
    Andrew I. Share
    Amar H. Flood
    Nature Chemistry, 2010, 2 : 349 - 350
  • [25] Thinking inside the big box
    Karges-Faulconbridge
    Eng syst, 2006, 8 (51-54):
  • [26] TRAVELING, THINKING, INSIDE THE BOX
    Connor, Larry
    AMERICAN BEE JOURNAL, 2009, 149 (08): : 741 - 743
  • [27] Thinking inside and outside the box
    Jacoby, RO
    COMPARATIVE MEDICINE, 2001, 51 (06) : 498 - 498
  • [28] ToneWoodAmp Thinking Inside the Box
    Baumann, Keith
    DOWN BEAT, 2017, 84 (07): : 81 - 81
  • [29] The Herbrand Manifesto Thinking Inside the Box
    Genesereth, Michael
    Kao, Eric
    RULE TECHNOLOGIES: FOUNDATIONS, TOOLS, AND APPLICATIONS, 2015, 9202 : 3 - 12
  • [30] Thinking inside the box, part II
    Fees, S
    ATHLETIC THERAPY TODAY, 2001, 6 (02): : 38 - 39