An assessment of the acid-extraction approach to compositional characterization of archaeological ceramics

被引：22

作者：

Neff, H ^{[1
]}

Glascock, MD ^{[1
]}

Bishop, RL ^{[1
]}

Blackman, MJ ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] SMITHSONIAN INST,CONSERVAT ANALYT LAB,WASHINGTON,DC 20560

来源：

AMERICAN ANTIQUITY | 1996年 / 61卷 / 02期

关键词：

D O I：

10.2307/282433

中图分类号：

Q98 [人类学];

学科分类号：

030303 ;

摘要：

We criticize the acid-extraction approach to chemical characterization of ceramics previously advocated in this journal by Burton and Simon (1993). The instrumental technique used by Burton and Simon (inductively coupled plasma emission spectroscopy [ICP]) is a highly precise chemical characterization technique, but noise introduced by characterizing acid extracts from sherds nullifies the usefulness of the resulting elemental concentration data for archeological sourcing.

引用

页码：389 / 404

页数：16

共 22 条

[1] COMPOSITIONAL ANALYSIS AND SOURCES OF POTTERY - AN ETHNOARCHEOLOGICAL APPROACH [J].

ARNOLD, DE ;

NEFF, H ;

BISHOP, RL .

AMERICAN ANTHROPOLOGIST, 1991, 93 (01) :70-90

[2]

Baxter M.J., 1992, COMPUTER APPL QUANTI, P141

[3]

BAXTER MJ, 1991, ARCHAEOMETRY 90, P355

[4]

BIEBER AM, 1977, THESIS U CONNECTICUT

[5]

BISHOP RL, 1989, ARCHAEOL CHEM, V4, P576

[6]

BISHOP RL, 1982, MEMOIRS PEABODY MUSE, V15, P272

[7]

Bishop RonaldL., 1982, ADV ARCHAEOL METH TH, V5, P275, DOI [10.1016/B978-0-12-003105-4.50012-1, DOI 10.1016/B978-0-12-003105-4.50012-1]

[8] THE STANDARDIZATION HYPOTHESIS AND CERAMIC MASS-PRODUCTION - TECHNOLOGICAL, COMPOSITIONAL, AND METRIC INDEXES OF CRAFT SPECIALIZATION AT TELL LEILAN, SYRIA [J].

BLACKMAN, MJ ;

STEIN, GJ ;

VANDIVER, PB .

AMERICAN ANTIQUITY, 1993, 58 (01) :60-80

[9] ACID-EXTRACTION AS A SIMPLE AND INEXPENSIVE METHOD FOR COMPOSITIONAL CHARACTERIZATION OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL CERAMICS [J].

BURTON, JH ;

SIMON, AW .

AMERICAN ANTIQUITY, 1993, 58 (01) :45-59

[10] The effect of firing temperature on the elemental characterization of pottery [J].

Cogswell, JW ;

Neff, H ;

Glascock, MD .

JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 1996, 23 (02) :283-287

← 1 2 3 →