Traditional and new composite endpoints in heart failure clinical trials: facilitating comprehensive efficacy assessments and improving trial efficiency

被引:72
作者
Anker, Stefan D. t [1 ]
Schroeder, Stefan [2 ]
Atar, Dan [3 ,4 ]
Bax, Jeroen J. [5 ]
Ceconi, Claudio [6 ]
Cowie, Martin R. [7 ]
AdamCrisp [8 ]
Dominjon, Fabienne [9 ]
Ford, Ian [10 ]
Ghofrani, Hossein-Ardeschir [11 ,12 ,13 ]
Gropper, Savion
Hindricks, Gerhard [14 ]
Hlatky, Mark A. [15 ]
Holcomb, Richard
Honarpour, Narimon [16 ]
Jukema, J. Wouter [5 ]
Kim, Albert M. [17 ]
Kunz, Michael [2 ]
Lefkowitz, Martin [18 ]
Le Floch, Chantal [9 ]
Landmesser, Ulf [19 ]
McDonagh, Theresa A. [20 ]
McMurray, John J. [21 ]
Merkely, Bela [22 ]
Packer, Milton [23 ]
Prasad, Krishna [24 ]
Revkin, James [17 ]
Rosano, Giuseppe M. C. [25 ,26 ]
Somaratne, Ransi
Stough, Wendy Gattis [27 ]
Voors, Adriaan A. [28 ]
Ruschitzka, Frank [29 ]
机构
[1] Univ Med Ctr Gottingen, Gottingen, Germany
[2] Bayer Healthcare, Berlin, Germany
[3] Oslo Univ Hosp Ulleval, Dept Cardiol B, Oslo, Norway
[4] Univ Oslo, N-0316 Oslo, Norway
[5] Leiden Univ, Med Ctr, Dept Cardiol, Leiden, Netherlands
[6] Hosp Desenzano Del Garda, Unit Cardiol, Desenzano Del Garda, Italy
[7] Imperial Coll London, Natl Heart & Lung Inst, London, England
[8] GlaxoSmithKline, Brentford, Middx, England
[9] Servier Int, Paris, France
[10] Univ Glasgow, Robertson Ctr Biostat, Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland
[11] Univ Giessen & Marburg Lung Ctr, Giessen, Germany
[12] Kerckhoff Klin Bad Nauheim, Bad Nauheim, Germany
[13] Imperial Coll London, London, England
[14] Univ Leipzig, Ctr Heart, Dept Electrophysiol, Leipzig, Germany
[15] Stanford Univ, Sch Med, Stanford, CA 94305 USA
[16] Amgen Inc, Thousand Oaks, CA 91320 USA
[17] Pfizer Inc, Cambridge, MA USA
[18] Novartis Pharmaceut, E Hanover, NJ USA
[19] Charite, Dept Cardiol, D-13353 Berlin, Germany
[20] Kings Coll Hosp London, London, England
[21] Univ Glasgow, BHF Cardiovasc Res Ctr, Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland
[22] Semmelweis Univ, Heart & Vasc Ctr, Budapest, Hungary
[23] Univ Texas Southwestern Med Ctr, Dept Clin Sci, Dallas, TX USA
[24] United Kingdom Med & Healthcare Prod Regulatory A, London, England
[25] IRCCS San Raffaele Hosp Roma, Rome, Italy
[26] St Georges Univ London, Cardiovasc & Cell Sci Inst, London, England
[27] Campbell Univ, Coll Pharm & Hlth Sci, Buies Creek, NC 27506 USA
[28] Univ Groningen, Univ Med Ctr Groningen, Groningen, Netherlands
[29] Univ Heart Ctr Zurich, Dept Cardiol Heart Failure Clin & Transplantat, Zurich, Switzerland
关键词
Heart failure; Clinical trial; Endpoint determination; Surrogate endpoints; CARDIAC RESYNCHRONIZATION; EUROPEAN-SOCIETY; OUTCOMES; OPPORTUNITIES; CHALLENGES; HOSPITALIZATIONS; HETEROGENEITY; PREFERENCES; IVABRADINE; THERAPY;
D O I
10.1002/ejhf.516
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Composite endpoints are commonly used as the primary measure of efficacy in heart failure clinical trials to assess the overall treatment effect and to increase the efficiency of trials. Clinical trials still must enrol large numbers of patients to accrue a sufficient number of outcome events and have adequate power to draw conclusions about the efficacy and safety of new treatments for heart failure. Additionally, the societal and health system perspectives on heart failure have raised interest in ascertaining the effects of therapy on outcomes such as repeat hospitalization and the patient's burden of disease. Thus, novel methods for using composite endpoints in clinical trials (e.g. clinical status composite endpoints, recurrent event analyses) are being applied in current and planned trials. Endpoints that measure functional status or reflect the patient experience are important but used cautiously because heart failure treatments may improve function yet have adverse effects on mortality. This paper discusses the use of traditional and new composite endpoints, identifies qualities of robust composites, and outlines opportunities for future research.
引用
收藏
页码:482 / 489
页数:8
相关论文
共 62 条
  • [1] Wireless pulmonary artery haemodynamic monitoring in chronic heart failure: a randomised controlled trial
    Abraham, William T.
    Adamson, Philip B.
    Bourge, Robert C.
    Aaron, Mark F.
    Costanzo, Maria Rosa
    Stevenson, Lynne W.
    Strickland, Warren
    Neelagaru, Suresh
    Raval, Nirav
    Krueger, Steven
    Weiner, Stanislav
    Shavelle, David
    Jeffries, Bradley
    Yadav, Jay S.
    [J]. LANCET, 2011, 377 (9766) : 658 - 666
  • [2] Effects of cardiac resynchronization on disease progression in patients with left ventricular systolic dysfunction, an indication for an implantable cardioverter-defibrillator, and mildly symptomatic chronic heart failure
    Abraham, WT
    Young, JB
    León, AR
    Adler, S
    Bank, AJ
    Hall, SA
    Lieberman, R
    Liem, LB
    O'Connell, JB
    Schroeder, JS
    Wheelan, KR
    [J]. CIRCULATION, 2004, 110 (18) : 2864 - 2868
  • [3] Modelling recurrent events: a tutorial for analysis in epidemiology
    Amorim, Leila D. A. F.
    Cai, Jianwen
    [J]. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2015, 44 (01) : 324 - 333
  • [4] The importance of patient-reported outcomes: a call for their comprehensive integration in cardiovascular clinical trials
    Anker, Stefan D.
    Agewall, Stefan
    Borggrefe, Martin
    Calvert, Melanie
    Caro, J. Jaime
    Cowie, Martin R.
    Ford, Ian
    Paty, Jean A.
    Riley, Jillian P.
    Swedberg, Karl
    Tavazzi, Luigi
    Wiklund, Ingela
    Kirchhof, Paulus
    [J]. EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL, 2014, 35 (30) : 2001 - +
  • [5] Time to move on from otime-to-first': should all events be included in the analysis of clinical trials?
    Anker, Stefan D.
    McMurray, John J. V.
    [J]. EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL, 2012, 33 (22) : 2764 - 2765
  • [6] Refining clinical trial composite outcomes: An application to the Assessment of the Safety and Efficacy of a New Thrombolytic-3 (ASSENT-3) trial
    Armstrong, Paul W.
    Westerhout, Cynthia M.
    Van de Werf, Frans
    Califf, Robert M.
    Welsh, Robert C.
    Wilcox, Robert G.
    Bakal, Jeffrey A.
    [J]. AMERICAN HEART JOURNAL, 2011, 161 (05) : 848 - 854
  • [7] Heart rate at baseline influences the effect of ivabradine on cardiovascular outcomes in chronic heart failure: analysis from the SHIFT study
    Boehm, Michael
    Borer, Jeffrey
    Ford, Ian
    Gonzalez-Juanatey, Jose R.
    Komajda, Michel
    Lopez-Sendon, Jose
    Reil, Jan-Christian
    Swedberg, Karl
    Tavazzi, Luigi
    [J]. CLINICAL RESEARCH IN CARDIOLOGY, 2013, 102 (01) : 11 - 22
  • [8] Effect of ivabradine on recurrent hospitalization for worsening heart failure in patients with chronic systolic heart failure: the SHIFT Study
    Borer, Jeffrey S.
    Boehm, Michael
    Ford, Ian
    Komajda, Michel
    Tavazzi, Luigi
    Lopez Sendon, Jose
    Alings, Marco
    Lopez-de-Sa, Esteban
    Swedberg, Karl
    [J]. EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL, 2012, 33 (22) : 2813 - 2820
  • [9] Bradley EH, 2014, JAMA-J AM MED ASSOC, V311, P1160, DOI 10.1001/jama.2014.678
  • [10] Generalized pairwise comparisons of prioritized outcomes in the two-sample problem
    Buyse, Marc
    [J]. STATISTICS IN MEDICINE, 2010, 29 (30) : 3245 - 3257