APOSTEL 2.0 Recommendations for Reporting Quantitative Optical Coherence Tomography Studies

被引：137

作者：

Aytulun, Aykut ^{[1
,60
]}

Cruz-Herranz, Andres ^{[2
,60
]}

Aktas, Orhan ^{[1
,60
]}

Balcer, Laura J. ^{[3
,4
,5
,60
]}

Balk, Lisanne ^{[6
,60
]}

Barboni, Piero ^{[7
]}

Blanco, Augusto Azuara ^{[8
]}

Calabresi, Peter A. ^{[9
,60
]}

Costello, Fiona ^{[10
,11
,60
]}

Sanchez-Dalmau, Bernardo ^{[12
]}

DeBuc, Delia Cabrera ^{[13
]}

Feltgen, Nicolas ^{[14
]}

Finger, Robert P. ^{[15
]}

Frederiksen, Jette Lautrup ^{[16
,17
,60
]}

Frohman, Elliot ^{[18
,60
]}

Frohman, Teresa ^{[18
,60
]}

Garway-Heath, David ^{[19
,20
]}

Gabilondo, Inigo ^{[21
,60
]}

Graves, Jennifer S. ^{[22
,60
]}

Green, Ari J. ^{[2
,60
]}

Hartung, Hans-Peter ^{[1
,23
,24
,60
]}

Havla, Joachim ^{[25
,60
]}

Holz, Frank G. ^{[15
]}

Imitola, Jaime ^{[26
,60
]}

Kenney, Rachel ^{[3
,4
,5
,60
]}

Klistorner, Alexander ^{[27
,60
]}

Knier, Benjamin ^{[28
,60
]}

Korn, Thomas ^{[28
,60
]}

Kolbe, Scott ^{[29
]}

Kraemer, Julia ^{[30
,60
]}

Lagreze, Wolf A. ^{[31
]}

Leocani, Letizia ^{[32
,60
]}

Maier, Oliver ^{[1
]}

Martinez-Lapiscina, Elena H. ^{[12
,60
]}

Meuth, Sven ^{[1
,60
]}

Outteryck, Olivier ^{[33
,60
]}

Paul, Friedemann ^{[34
,35
,36
,37
,38
,60
]}

Petzold, Axel ^{[39
,40
,60
]}

Pihl-Jensen, Gorm ^{[16
,17
,60
]}

Preiningerova, Jana Lizrova ^{[41
,42
,60
]}

Rebolleda, Gema ^{[43
]}

Ringelstein, Marius ^{[1
,44
,60
]}

Saidha, Shiv ^{[9
,60
]}

Schippling, Sven ^{[45
,60
]}

Schuman, Joel S. ^{[46
,47
,48
,49
,50
,51
]}

Sergott, Robert C. ^{[52
,60
]}

Toosy, Ahmed ^{[53
]}

Villoslada, Pablo ^{[12
,60
]}

Wolf, Sebastian ^{[54
,55
]}

Yeh, E. Ann ^{[56
,60
]}

机构：

[1] Heinrich Heine Univ Dusseldorf, Med Fac, Dept Neurol, Dusseldorf, Germany

[2] Univ Calif San Francisco, Dept Neurol, San Francisco, CA 94143 USA

[3] NYU, Grossman Sch Med, Dept Neurol, New York, NY USA

[4] NYU, Grossman Sch Med, Dept Populat Hlth, New York, NY USA

[5] NYU, Grossman Sch Med, Dept Ophthalmol, New York, NY USA

[6] Ctr Res Sports Soc, Mulier Inst, Utrecht, Netherlands

[7] Sci Inst San Raffaele, Milan, Italy

[8] Queens Univ Belfast, Ctr Publ Hlth, Belfast, Antrim, North Ireland

[9] Johns Hopkins Univ, Div Neuroimmunol, Baltimore, MD USA

[10] Univ Calgary, Dept Clin Neurosci, Calgary, AB, Canada

[11] Univ Calgary, Dept Surg, Calgary, AB, Canada

[12] Univ Barcelona, Hosp Clin, Barcelona, Spain

[13] Univ Miami, Miller Sch Med, Bascom Palmer Eye Inst, Coral Gables, FL 33124 USA

[14] Univ Med Ctr, Dept Ophthalmol, Gottingen, Germany

[15] Univ Bonn, Dept Ophthalmol, Bonn, Germany

[16] Rigshosp Glostrup, Dept Neurol, Copenhagen, Denmark

[17] Univ Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark

[18] Stanford Univ, Sch Med, Lab Neuroimmunol, Stanford, CA 94305 USA

[19] Moorfields Eye Hosp NHS Fdn Trust, Biomed Res Ctr, Natl Inst Hlth Res NIHR, Inst Ophthalmol, London, England

[20] UCL Inst Ophthalmol, London, England

[21] Biocruces Bizkaia Hlth Res Inst, Baracaldo, Spain

[22] Univ Calif San Diego, Dept Neurosci, San Diego, CA USA

[23] Univ Sydney, Brain & Mind Ctr, Sydney, NSW, Australia

[24] Med Univ Vienna, Dept Neurol, Vienna, Austria

[25] Ludwig Maximilians Univ Munchen, LMU Hosp, Inst Clin Neuroimmunol, Munich, Germany

[26] Univ Connecticut, Sch Med, Dept Neurol, UConn Hlth Comprehens MS Ctr,Div Multiple Scleros, Farmington, CT USA

[27] Macquarie Univ, Fac Med & Hlth Sci, Sydney, NSW, Australia

[28] Tech Univ Munich, Sch Med, Klinikum Rechts Isar, Dept Neurol, Munich, Germany

[29] Univ Melbourne, Dept Med & Radiol, Melbourne, Vic, Australia

[30] Univ Munster, Inst Translat Neurol, Dept Neurol, Munster, Germany

[31] Univ Freiburg, Fac Med, Med Ctr, Eye Ctr, Freiburg, Germany

[32] Univ Vita Salute San Raffaele, Inst Expt Neurol INSPE, IRCCS San Raffaele, Expt Neurophiol Unit, Milan, Italy

[33] Univ Lille, INSERM, Lille Neurosci & Cognit, CHU Lille,U1172 LiINCogOPARC, Lille, France

[34] Max Delbruck Ctr Mol Med, Expt & Clin Res Ctr, Berlin, Germany

[35] Charite Univ Med Berlin, Berlin, Germany

[36] Free Univ Berlin, Berlin, Germany

[37] Humboldt Univ, Berlin, Germany

[38] Berlin Inst Hlth, Berlin, Germany

[39] UCL Inst Neurol, Natl Hosp Neurol & Neurosurg, Moorfields Eye Hosp, Queen Sq, London, England

[40] Amsterdam UMC, Neuroophthalmol Expert Ctr, Amsterdam, Netherlands

[41] Charles Univ Prague, Fac Med 1, Dept Neurol, Prague, Czech Republic

[42] Gen Univ Hosp Prague, Prague, Czech Republic

[43] Med Univ Alcala, Ramon y Cajal Hosp, Dept Ophthalmol, Madrid, Spain

[44] Heinrich Heine Univ Dusseldorf, LVR Klinikum, Ctr Neurol & Neuropsychiat, Dept Neurol, Dusseldorf, Germany

[45] Univ Hosp Zurich, Dept Neurol, Zurich, Switzerland

[46] NYU Grossman Sch Med, NYU Langone Hlth, Dept Ophthalmol, New York, NY USA

[47] NYU Langone Hlth, NYU Grossman Sch Med, Dept Neurosci, New York, NY USA

[48] NYU Langone Hlth, NYU Grossman Sch Med, Dept Physiol, New York, NY USA

[49] NYU Tandon Sch Engn, Dept Biomed Engn, Brooklyn, NY USA

[50] NYU Tandon Sch Engn, Dept Elect Engn, Brooklyn, NY USA

来源：

NEUROLOGY | 2021年 / 97卷 / 02期

关键词：

D O I：

10.1212/WNL.0000000000012125

中图分类号：

R74 [神经病学与精神病学];

学科分类号：

摘要：

Objective To update the consensus recommendations for reporting of quantitative optical coherence tomography (OCT) study results, thus revising the previously published Advised Protocol for OCT Study Terminology and Elements (APOSTEL) recommendations. Methods To identify studies reporting quantitative OCT results, we performed a PubMed search for the terms "quantitative" and "optical coherence tomography" from 2015 to 2017. Corresponding authors of the identified publications were invited to provide feedback on the initial APOSTEL recommendations via online surveys following the principle of a modified Delphi method. The results were evaluated and discussed by a panel of experts and changes to the initial recommendations were proposed. A final survey was recirculated among the corresponding authors to obtain a majority vote on the proposed changes. Results A total of 116 authors participated in the surveys, resulting in 15 suggestions, of which 12 were finally accepted and incorporated into an updated 9-point checklist. We harmonized the nomenclature of the outer retinal layers, added the exact area of measurement to the description of volume scans, and suggested reporting device-specific features. We advised to address potential bias in manual segmentation or manual correction of segmentation errors. References to specific reporting guidelines and room light conditions were removed. The participants' consensus with the recommendations increased from 80% for the previous APOSTEL version to greater than 90%. Conclusions The modified Delphi method resulted in an expert-led guideline (evidence Class III; Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluations [GRADE] criteria) concerning study protocol, acquisition device, acquisition settings, scanning protocol, funduscopic imaging, postacquisition data selection, postacquisition analysis, nomenclature and abbreviations, and statistical approach. It will be essential to update these recommendations to new research and practices regularly.

引用

页码：68 / 79

页数：12

共 10 条

[1] The International Multiple Sclerosis Visual System Consortium: Advancing Visual System Research in Multiple Sclerosis
Balcer, Laura J.
Balk, Lisanne J.
Brandt, Alexander U.
Calabresi, Peter A.
Martinez-Lapiscina, Elena H.
Nolan, Rachel C.
Paul, Friedemann
Petzold, Axel
Saidha, Shiv
[J]. JOURNAL OF NEURO-OPHTHALMOLOGY, 2018, 38 (04) : 494 - 501
[2] A Simple Sign for Recognizing Off-Axis OCT Measurement Beam Placement in the Context of Multicentre Studies
Balk, Lisanne J.
de Vries-Knoppert, Willemien A. E. J.
Petzold, Axel
[J]. PLOS ONE, 2012, 7 (11):
[3] THE APOSTEL RECOMMENDATIONS FOR REPORTING QUANTITATIVE OPTICAL COHERENCE TOMOGRAPHY STUDIES Response
Albrecht, Philipp
Cruz-Herranz, Andres
Petzold, Axel
Lagreze, Wolf A.
Brandt, Alexander U.
[J]. NEUROLOGY, 2016, 87 (18) : 1960 - 1960
[4] The APOSTEL recommendations for reporting quantitative optical coherence tomography studies
Cruz-Herranz, Andres
Balk, Lisanne J.
Oberwahrenbrock, Timm
Saidha, Shiv
Martinez-Lapiscina, Elena H.
Lagreze, Wolf A.
Schuman, Joel S.
Villoslada, Pablo
Calabresi, Peter
Balcer, Laura
Petzold, Axel
Green, Ari J.
Paul, Friedemann
Brandt, Alexander U.
Albrecht, Philipp
[J]. NEUROLOGY, 2016, 86 (24) : 2303 - 2309
[5] Exploring physician specialist response rates to web-based surveys
Cunningham, Ceara Tess
Quan, Hude
Hemmelgarn, Brenda
Noseworthy, Tom
Beck, Cynthia A.
Dixon, Elijah
Samuel, Susan
Ghali, William A.
Sykes, Lindsay L.
Jette, Nathalie
[J]. BMC MEDICAL RESEARCH METHODOLOGY, 2015, 15
[6] The Delphi technique in health sciences education research
De Villiers, MR
De Villiers, PJT
Kent, AP
[J]. MEDICAL TEACHER, 2005, 27 (07) : 639 - 643
[7] GRADE guidelines: A new series of articles in the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
Guyatt, Gordon H.
Oxman, Andrew D.
Schuenemann, Holger J.
Tugwell, Peter
Knottnerus, Andre
[J]. JOURNAL OF CLINICAL EPIDEMIOLOGY, 2011, 64 (04) : 380 - 382
[8] Reliability of Intra-Retinal Layer Thickness Estimates
Oberwahrenbrock, Timm
Weinhold, Maria
Mikolajczak, Janine
Zimmermann, Hanna
Paul, Friedemann
Beckers, Ingeborg
Brandt, Alexander U.
[J]. PLOS ONE, 2015, 10 (09):
[9] Petzold A., Ann Clin Translational Neurol
[10] Proposed Lexicon for Anatomic Landmarks in Normal Posterior Segment Spectral-Domain Optical Coherence Tomography
Staurenghi, Giovanni
Sadda, Srinivas
Chakravarthy, Usha
Spaide, Richard F.
[J]. OPHTHALMOLOGY, 2014, 121 (08) : 1572 - 1578

← 1 →