Conceptual bases for environmental compensation under the ecological approach

被引:4
|
作者
Bonilla, Fabian [1 ]
Monros, Juan S. [3 ]
Sasa, Mahmood [1 ,2 ,4 ]
机构
[1] Univ Costa Rica, Inst Clodomiro Picado, San Jose, Costa Rica
[2] Univ Costa Rica, Ctr Invest Biodiversidad & Ecol Trop, Museo Zool, San Jose, Costa Rica
[3] Univ Valencia, Inst Cavanilles Biodiversidad & Biol Evolut, Valencia, Spain
[4] Org Estudios Trop, San Jose, Costa Rica
关键词
environment; biodiversity; ecological equivalence; economic equivalence; environmental evaluation; NO NET LOSS; BIODIVERSITY OFFSETS; EQUIVALENCY ANALYSIS; MITIGATION BANKING; INDICATORS; VEGETATION; CHOICE;
D O I
10.15517/rev.biol.trop.2022.52281
中图分类号
Q [生物科学];
学科分类号
07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;
摘要
Introduction: Infrastructure projects or development activities often generate a loss of biodiversity and reduce the quality of the environment's services to human societies. Fortunately, many of these impacts can be reduced, controlled, or compensated through mitigation, rehabilitation, and compensation measures, which usually rely on the environmental legal framework of the countries or states where they are implemented. This review provides a theoretical vision of using environmental compensation as a legal/technical instrument integrated into natural environment management.Methodology: We reviewed the global literature on the subject using the GoogleScholar and SciELO reference search engines using various indicators in English and Spanish.Results: We found 244 references on environmental compensation, showing a clear increasing pattern in the last decade. Environmental compensation constitutes a legal/technical instrument that allows offsets for environmen-tal losses and often is part of the Environmental Impact Studies regulated by the state. Several methodological strategies are used to establish compensatory actions, each of them based on one of four possible approaches: economic, ecological, political, and cultural. The ecological equivalence between the impacted environmental elements and compensation is sought within the ecological approach, ensuring no net loss. Thus, this approach allows the incorporation of multiple criteria for the evaluation of damage and compensation actions: it can be applied in different situations. Nevertheless, compensatory measures are not exempt from criticism. There are situations in which the singularity of the impacted elements makes an adequate compensation for losses impossible.Conclusions: Compensation is highly relevant in environmental management and must favor the universal right to a healthy environment. However, its practical application requires clear procedures and close vigilance to prevent losses or even a net environmental gain.
引用
收藏
页数:21
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] A conceptual framework for the evolution of ecological specialisation
    Poisot, Timothee
    Bever, James D.
    Nemri, Adnane
    Thrall, Peter H.
    Hochberg, Michael E.
    ECOLOGY LETTERS, 2011, 14 (09) : 841 - 851
  • [22] Offsetting environmental impacts beyond climate change: the Circular Ecosystem Compensation approach
    Moore, Daniel
    Bach, Vanessa
    Finkbeiner, Matthias
    Honkomp, Theresa
    Ahn, Heinz
    Sprenger, Madlen
    Froese, Linda
    Gratzel, Dirk
    JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, 2023, 329
  • [23] The SDGs Provide Limited Evidence That Environmental Policies Are Delivering Multiple Ecological and Social Benefits
    Fairbrass, A. J.
    O'Sullivan, A.
    Campbell, J.
    Ekins, P.
    EARTHS FUTURE, 2024, 12 (05)
  • [24] Ecological compensation areas promote farmlandbirds
    Birrer, Simon
    Jenny, Markus
    Korner-Nievergelt, Fraenzi
    Meichtry-Stier, Kim
    Pfiffner, Lukas
    Zellweger-Fischer, Judith
    Zollinger, Jean-Luc
    TAGUNGSBAND: FACHGESPRACH AGRARVOGEL - OKOLOGISCHE BEWERTUNGSGRUNDLAGE FUR BIODIVERSITATSZIELE IN ACKERBAUGEBIETEN, 2013, 442 : 138 - +
  • [25] Ecological restoration as precaution and not as restitutional compensation
    Wiegleb, Gerhard
    Broering, Udo
    Choi, Gyewoon
    Dahms, Hans-Uwe
    Kanongdate, Kamalaporn
    Byeon, Chan-Woo
    Ler, Lian Guey
    BIODIVERSITY AND CONSERVATION, 2013, 22 (09) : 1931 - 1948
  • [26] Safeguards for enhancing ecological compensation in Sweden
    Koh, Niak Sian
    Hahn, Thomas
    Ituarte-Lima, Claudia
    LAND USE POLICY, 2017, 64 : 186 - 199
  • [27] Ecological restoration as precaution and not as restitutional compensation
    Gerhard Wiegleb
    Udo Bröring
    Gyewoon Choi
    Hans-Uwe Dahms
    Kamalaporn Kanongdate
    Chan-Woo Byeon
    Lian Guey Ler
    Biodiversity and Conservation, 2013, 22 : 1931 - 1948
  • [28] Metrics for environmental compensation: A comparative analysis of Swedish municipalities
    Soderqvist, Tore
    Cole, Scott
    Franzen, Frida
    Hasselstrom, Linus
    Beery, Thomas H.
    Bengtsson, Fredrik
    Bjorn, Helena
    Kjeller, Elsie
    Lindblom, Erik
    Mellin, Anna
    Wiberg, Johanna
    Jonsson, K. Ingemar
    JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, 2021, 299
  • [29] Synergies and Trade-Offs between Biodiversity and Carbon in Ecological Compensation
    Yirdaw, Eshetu
    Kanninen, Markku
    Monge, Adrian
    SUSTAINABILITY, 2023, 15 (15)
  • [30] Motivations for the implementation of ecological compensation areas
    Jahrl, Ingrid
    Rudmann, Christine
    Pfiffner, Lukas
    Balmer, Oliver
    AGRARFORSCHUNG SCHWEIZ, 2012, 3 (04): : 208 - 215