Leonardo Sciascia and The Disappearance of Majorana

被引:1
作者
Francese, Joseph [1 ]
机构
[1] Michigan State Univ, E Lansing, MI 48824 USA
关键词
Leonardo Sciascia; Ettore Majorana; atomic bomb; ethics of science; historical fictions vs; historiography; Italy's 'Racial Campaign'; ethics of conviction vs; ethics of responsibility; socially engaged; committed intellectual;
D O I
10.1080/1354571X.2010.523541
中图分类号
K [历史、地理];
学科分类号
06 ;
摘要
In The Disappearance of Majorana, the Italian novelist Leonardo Sciascia contends that a brilliant young physicist did not commit suicide in 1937, as is widely believed, but instead, sequestered himself into a convent rather than contribute to the development of an atomic bomb. Thus, Sciascia equates Ettore Majorana's 'refusal of science' with 'responsible science', whose scope, Sciascia suggests, must at times be restricted. By contrast, the author argues that Sciascia's Majorana is a fictional character, not the historical persona who was hardly the conscientious objector Sciascia portrays, but instead a supporter of Fascism. The author also argues, more importantly, that Sciascia's narrative, while plausible, falsifies the historical record in order to spark debate on issues in the ethics of science. However, such debate, if it were to stay within the parameters set forth by Sciascia, would fail to consider the responsibility of non-scientists to monitor how new scientific discoveries and technologies are applied by economic and political power and would absolve intellectuals from responsibility for the consequences of their choices.
引用
收藏
页码:715 / 733
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   Quirino Majorana's experiments on the speed of light and gravitational absorption [J].
Dragoni, Giorgio ;
Maltese, Giulio ;
Atti, Luisa .
PHYSICS IN PERSPECTIVE, 2007, 9 (03) :281-304
[42]   Ettore Majorana’s Course on Theoretical Physics: A Recent Discovery [J].
Antonino Drago ;
Salvatore Esposito .
Physics in Perspective, 2007, 9 :329-345
[43]   Quirino Majorana’s Experiments on the Speed of Light and Gravitational Absorption [J].
Giorgio Dragoni ;
Giulio Maltese ;
Luisa Atti .
Physics in Perspective, 2007, 9 :281-304
[44]   Ettore Majorana's forgotten publication on the Thomas-Fermi model [J].
Guerra, Francesco ;
Robotti, Nadia .
PHYSICS IN PERSPECTIVE, 2008, 10 (01) :56-76
[45]   Ettore Majorana’s Forgotten Publication on the Thomas-Fermi Model [J].
Francesco Guerra ;
Nadia Robotti .
Physics in Perspective, 2008, 10 :56-76
[46]   Hole Theory and Quantum Electrodynamics in an Unknown Manuscript in French by Ettore Majorana [J].
Salvatore Esposito .
Foundations of Physics, 2007, 37 :956-976
[47]   Hole theory and quantum electrodynamics in an unknown manuscript in French by Ettore!Majorana [J].
Esposito, S. .
FOUNDATIONS OF PHYSICS, 2007, 37 (07) :1049-1068
[48]   Hole theory and quantum electrodynamics in an unknown manuscript in French by Ettore!Majorana [J].
Esposito, Salvatore .
FOUNDATIONS OF PHYSICS, 2007, 37 (06) :956-976
[49]   Stories of emperors, sultans, and cities: comparing protagonists in the histories of Doukas and Leonardo Bruni [J].
Kinloch, Matthew .
BYZANTINE AND MODERN GREEK STUDIES, 2022, 46 (02) :196-213
[50]   DISAPPEARANCE OF MARGERY KEMPE, OR HOW THE AUTHOR HAS TURNED INTO A CHARACTER [J].
Soupriyanovich, A. G. .
DIALOG SO VREMENEM-DIALOGUE WITH TIME, 2010, (31) :251-+