AGSPosition Statement: Resource Allocation Strategies andAge-RelatedConsiderations in theCOVID-19 Era and Beyond

被引:93
作者
Farrell, Timothy W. [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Ferrante, Lauren E. [4 ]
Brown, Teneille [5 ,6 ]
Francis, Leslie [7 ,8 ]
Widera, Eric [9 ,10 ]
Rhodes, Ramona [11 ,12 ]
Rosen, Tony [13 ]
Hwang, Ula [14 ,15 ,16 ]
Witt, Leah J. [9 ,17 ]
Thothala, Niranjan [18 ,19 ]
Liu, Shan W. [20 ]
Vitale, Caroline A. [21 ,22 ]
Braun, Ursula K. [23 ,24 ]
Stephens, Caroline [25 ]
Saliba, Debra [26 ,27 ,28 ]
机构
[1] Univ Utah, Sch Med, Dept Internal Med, Div Geriatr, Salt Lake City, UT USA
[2] VA SLC Geriatr Res Educ & Clin Ctr, Salt Lake City, UT USA
[3] Univ Utah Hlth Interprofess Educ Program, Salt Lake City, UT USA
[4] Yale Sch Med, Dept Internal Med, Sect Pulm Crit Care & Sleep Med, New Haven, CT USA
[5] Univ Utah, SJ Quinney Coll Law, Ctr Law & Biomed Sci, Salt Lake City, UT USA
[6] Univ Utah, Sch Med, Dept Internal Med, Program Med Eth & Humanities, Salt Lake City, UT USA
[7] Univ Utah, SJ Quinney Coll Law, Salt Lake City, UT USA
[8] Univ Utah, Dept Philosophy, Salt Lake City, UT USA
[9] Univ Calif San Francisco, Dept Med, Div Geriatr, San Francisco, CA 94143 USA
[10] San Francisco Vet Affairs Hlth Care Syst, San Francisco, CA USA
[11] Univ Texas Southwestern Med Ctr Dallas, Dept Internal Med, Div Geriatr Med, Dallas, TX USA
[12] Cent Arkansas Vet Healthcare Syst, Geriatr Res Educ & Clin Ctr, Little Rock, AR USA
[13] New York Presbyterian Hosp, Weill Cornell Med, Div Geriatr Emergency Med, Dept Emergency Med, New York, NY USA
[14] Icahn Sch Med Mt Sinai, Dept Emergency Med, New York, NY 10029 USA
[15] Icahn Sch Med Mt Sinai, Brookdale Dept Geriatr & Palliat Med, New York, NY 10029 USA
[16] James J Peters VAMC, Geriatr Res Educ & Clin Ctr, Bronx, NY USA
[17] Univ Calif San Francisco, Div UCSF Pulm Crit Care Allergy & Sleep Med, San Francisco, CA 94143 USA
[18] Good Samaritan Hosp, Dept Med, Hospitalist Div, Vincennes, IN USA
[19] Union Hosp, Dept Med, Hospitalist Div, Terre Haute, IN USA
[20] Harvard Med Sch, Massachusetts Gen Hosp, Div Geriatr Emergency Med, Dept Emergency Med, Boston, MA 02115 USA
[21] Univ Michigan, Sch Med, Dept Internal Med, Div Geriatr & Palliat Med, Ann Arbor, MI USA
[22] VA Ann Arbor Geriatr Res Educ & Clin Ctr GRECC, Ann Arbor, MI USA
[23] Baylor Coll Med, Dept Med, Sect Geriatr & Palliat Med, Houston, TX 77030 USA
[24] Michael E DeBakey VA Med Ctr, Rehabil & Extended Care Line, Houston, TX USA
[25] Univ Utah, Coll Nursing, Salt Lake City, UT 84112 USA
[26] UCLA Borun Ctr Gerontol Res, Los Angeles, CA USA
[27] VA Los Angeles Geriatr Res Educ & Clin Ctr, Los Angeles, CA USA
[28] RAND Corp, Santa Monica, CA USA
关键词
COVID-19; bioethics; rationing; pandemic; aging; DISABILITY; MORTALITY; FRAILTY; AGE;
D O I
10.1111/jgs.16537
中图分类号
R592 [老年病学]; C [社会科学总论];
学科分类号
03 ; 0303 ; 100203 ;
摘要
Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) continues to impact older adults disproportionately, from severe illness and hospitalization to increased mortality risk. Concurrently, concerns about potential shortages of healthcare professionals and health supplies to address these needs have focused attention on how resources are ultimately allocated and used. Some strategies misguidedly use age as an arbitrary criterion, inappropriately disfavoring older adults. This statement represents the official policy position of the American Geriatrics Society (AGS). It is intended to inform stakeholders including hospitals, health systems, and policymakers about ethical considerations to consider when developing strategies for allocating scarce resources during an emergency involving older adults. Members of the AGS Ethics Committee collaborated with interprofessional experts in ethics, law, nursing, and medicine (including geriatrics, palliative care, emergency medicine, and pulmonology/critical care) to conduct a structured literature review and examine relevant reports. The resulting recommendations defend a particular view of distributive justice that maximizes relevant clinical factors and deemphasizes or eliminates factors placing arbitrary, disproportionate weight on advanced age. The AGS positions include (1) avoiding age per se as a means for excluding anyone from care; (2) assessing comorbidities and considering the disparate impact of social determinants of health; (3) encouraging decision makers to focus primarily on potential short-term (not long-term) outcomes; (4) avoiding ancillary criteria such as "life-years saved" and "long-term predicted life expectancy" that might disadvantage older people; (5) forming and staffing triage committees tasked with allocating scarce resources; (6) developing institutional resource allocation strategies that are transparent and applied uniformly; and (7) facilitating appropriate advance care planning. The statement includes recommendations that should be immediately implemented to address resource allocation strategies during COVID-19, aligning with AGS positions. The statement also includes recommendations for post-pandemic review. Such review would support revised strategies to ensure that governments and institutions have equitable emergency resource allocation strategies, avoid future discriminatory language and practice, and have appropriate guidance to develop national frameworks for emergent resource allocation decisions. J Am Geriatr Soc 68:1136-1142, 2020.
引用
收藏
页码:1136 / 1142
页数:7
相关论文
共 24 条
  • [1] [Anonymous], CLIN ETH REC ALL INT
  • [2] [Anonymous], 2018, UT CRIS STAND CAR GU
  • [3] Frailty and Subsequent Disability and Mortality among Patients with Critical Illness
    Brummel, Nathan E.
    Bell, Susan P.
    Girard, Timothy D.
    Pandharipande, Pratik P.
    Jackson, James C.
    Morandi, Alessandro
    Thompson, Jennifer L.
    Chandrasekhar, Rameela
    Bernard, Gordon R.
    Dittus, Robert S.
    Gill, Thomas M.
    Ely, E. Wesley
    [J]. AMERICAN JOURNAL OF RESPIRATORY AND CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE, 2017, 196 (01) : 64 - 72
  • [4] cdc, Advance care planning: Ensuring your wishes are known and honored if you are unable to speak for yourself CDC Healthy Aging Program.
  • [5] Triage Care of the Critically Ill and Injured During Pandemics and Disasters: CHEST Consensus Statement
    Christian, Michael D.
    Sprung, Charles L.
    King, Mary A.
    Dichter, Jeffrey R.
    Kissoon, Niranjan
    Devereaux, Asha V.
    Gomersall, Charles D.
    [J]. CHEST, 2014, 146 (04) : E61S - E74S
  • [6] The Importance of Addressing Advance Care Planning and Decisions About Do-Not-Resuscitate Orders During Novel Coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19)
    Curtis, J. Randall
    Kross, Erin K.
    Stapleton, Renee D.
    [J]. JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2020, 323 (18): : 1771 - 1772
  • [7] Coronavirus Disease 2019 in Geriatrics and Long-Term Care: The ABCDs of COVID-19
    D'Adamo, Heather
    Yoshikawa, Thomas
    Ouslander, Joseph G.
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN GERIATRICS SOCIETY, 2020, 68 (05) : 912 - 917
  • [8] Multiple Chronic Conditions and Life Expectancy A Life Table Analysis
    DuGoff, Eva H.
    Canudas-Romo, Vladimir
    Buttorff, Christine
    Leff, Bruce
    Anderson, Gerard F.
    [J]. MEDICAL CARE, 2014, 52 (08) : 688 - 694
  • [9] Fair Allocation of Scarce Medical Resources in the Time of Covid-19
    Emanuel, Ezekiel J.
    Persad, Govind
    Upshur, Ross
    Thome, Beatriz
    Parker, Michael
    Glickman, Aaron
    Zhang, Cathy
    Boyle, Connor
    Smith, Maxwell
    Phillips, James P.
    [J]. NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2020, 382 (21) : 2049 - 2055
  • [10] Rationing Limited Healthcare Resources in the COVID-19 Era and Beyond: Ethical Considerations Regarding Older Adults
    Farrell, Timothy W.
    Francis, Leslie
    Brown, Teneille
    Ferrante, Lauren E.
    Widera, Eric
    Rhodes, Ramona
    Rosen, Tony
    Hwang, Ula
    Witt, Leah J.
    Thothala, Niranjan
    Liu, Shan W.
    Vitale, Caroline A.
    Braun, Ursula K.
    Stephens, Caroline
    Saliba, Debra
    [J]. JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN GERIATRICS SOCIETY, 2020, 68 (06) : 1143 - 1149