Barriers and facilitators to implementing evidence-based interventions among third sector organisations: a systematic review

被引:128
作者
Bach-Mortensen, Anders Malthe [1 ]
Lange, Brittany C. L. [1 ]
Montgomery, Paul [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Oxford, Dept Social Policy & Intervent, Barnett House,32 Wellington Sq, Oxford OX1 2ER, England
[2] Univ Birmingham, Dept Social Policy Sociol & Criminol, Birmingham B15 2TT, W Midlands, England
来源
IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE | 2018年 / 13卷
关键词
Evidence-based intervention; EBI; evidence-based practice; EBP; third-sector organisation; TSO; Implementation; Barriers; Facilitators; Enablers; Obstructers; Charities; Non-profits; CBO; NGO; COMMUNITY-BASED ORGANIZATIONS; HIV-PREVENTION INTERVENTIONS; ADDICTION TREATMENT; PROVIDER PERSPECTIVES; STAFF PERCEPTIONS; BUSINESS-LIKE; PROGRAMS; HEALTH; LESSONS; PARTNERSHIP;
D O I
10.1186/s13012-018-0789-7
中图分类号
R19 [保健组织与事业(卫生事业管理)];
学科分类号
摘要
Background: The third sector is becoming a growing provider of public, social, and health services. However, there is little evidence on the effectiveness of third sector organisations (TSOs), and their capacity to implement evidence-based interventions (EBIs). Understanding implementation aspects of service delivery remains an important issue in clinical practice, but is poorly understood in the context of TSOs. This is problematic, since implementation issues are known to be critical for effective intervention outcomes. Objectives: To identify and synthesise existing research on what barriers and facilitators influence the implementation process of TSOs delivering EBIs. Methods: This review is reported according to PRISMA guidelines and was pre-registered in PROSPERO. Key databases were searched using relevant terms, experts in the field were contacted, and websites were reviewed. All identified studies were double-screened, and data were extracted independently by two authors. Included studies were synthesised using thematic analysis and were quality appraised. Results: Thirty-one studies were included, most of which were conducted in North America. The thematic synthesis identified resource limitations, in particular staff and finance, to be the most reported barrier to TSOs implementing EBIs. Organisational culture, including factors such as alignment between the mission of the TSO and EBI, and support/ prioritisation of the implementation process were the most reported facilitators. These findings generalise across the included studies and are robust to study quality assessment. Conclusions: While it is often assumed that good outcomes follow when implementing interventions that have been developed and tested according to best practice, little attention has been paid to how EBIs are best transported, contextualised, and implemented by third sector providers. This systematic review found that TSOs faced considerable challenges in implementing EBIs, which were primarily a lack of support and expertise, and unclear/insufficient guidelines on how to adapt EBIs to different populations. To address these challenges, it is important to engage with central stakeholders, such as funders, researchers, policymakers, and practitioners, to discuss how these needs can be met.
引用
收藏
页数:19
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Implementing Prehospital Evidence-Based Guidelines: A Systematic Literature Review
    Fishe, Jennifer N.
    Crowe, Remle P.
    Cash, Rebecca E.
    Nudell, Nikiah G.
    Martin-Gill, Christian
    Richards, Christopher T.
    PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE, 2018, 22 (04) : 511 - 519
  • [32] Barriers and facilitators of evidence-based practice among lecturers at Makerere University College of Health Sciences, Uganda: a qualitative study
    Nalweyiso, Dorothy Irene
    Mbabazi, Johnson
    Kabanda, Joseph
    Breckon, Jeff
    Nnyanzi, Lawrence Achilles
    Kawooya, Michael Grace
    Mubuuke, Aloysius Gonzaga
    Saltikov, Josette Bettany
    Sanderson, Katherine
    COGENT EDUCATION, 2024, 11 (01):
  • [33] Provider Perspectives on Evidence-Based HIV Prevention Interventions: Barriers and Facilitators to Implementation
    Owczarzak, Jill
    Dickson-Gomez, Julia
    AIDS PATIENT CARE AND STDS, 2011, 25 (03) : 171 - 179
  • [34] What are the barriers and facilitators to implementing Collaborative Care for depression? A systematic review
    Wood, Emily
    Ohlsen, Sally
    Ricketts, Thomas
    JOURNAL OF AFFECTIVE DISORDERS, 2017, 214 : 26 - 43
  • [35] Organizational Facilitators and Barriers to Implementing Effective Clinical Audit: Systematic Review
    Vahidi, Reza Gholi
    Tabrizi, Jafar Sadegh
    Iezadi, Shabnam
    Gholipour, Kamal
    Mojahed, Farokh
    Rasi, Vahid
    JOURNAL OF PIONEERING MEDICAL SCIENCES, 2013, 3 (01): : 38 - 45
  • [36] Effectiveness of Educational Interventions to Increase Knowledge of Evidence-Based Practice Among Nurses and Physiotherapists in Primary Health Care: Protocol for a Systematic Review
    Verloo, Henk
    Melly, Pauline
    Hilfiker, Roger
    Pereira, Filipa
    JMIR RESEARCH PROTOCOLS, 2020, 9 (11):
  • [37] Health professionals' views on the barriers and enablers to evidence-based practice for acute stroke care: a systematic review
    Baatiema, Leonard
    Otim, Michael E.
    Mnatzaganian, George
    Aikins, Ama de-Graft
    Coombes, Judith
    Somerset, Shawn
    IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE, 2017, 12
  • [38] A mapping of facilitators and barriers to evidence-based management in health systems: a scoping review study
    Tahereh Shafaghat
    Mohammad Hasan Imani Nasab
    Mohammad Amin Bahrami
    Zahra Kavosi
    Mahsa Roozrokh Arshadi Montazer
    Mohammad Kazem Rahimi Zarchi
    Peivand Bastani
    Systematic Reviews, 10
  • [39] A mapping of facilitators and barriers to evidence-based management in health systems: a scoping review study
    Shafaghat, Tahereh
    Imani Nasab, Mohammad Hasan
    Bahrami, Mohammad Amin
    Kavosi, Zahra
    Roozrokh Arshadi Montazer, Mahsa
    Rahimi Zarchi, Mohammad Kazem
    Bastani, Peivand
    SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS, 2021, 10 (01)
  • [40] Determinants of Implementing Evidence-Based Trauma-Focused Interventions for Children and Youth: A Systematic Review
    Byron J. Powell
    Sheila V. Patel
    Amber D. Haley
    Emily R. Haines
    Kathleen E. Knocke
    Shira Chandler
    Colleen Cary Katz
    Heather Pane Seifert
    George Ake
    Lisa Amaya-Jackson
    Gregory A. Aarons
    Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 2020, 47 : 705 - 719