SiC MOSFET versus Si Super Junction MOSFET - Switching Loss Comparison in Different Switching Cell Configurations

Although SiC MOSFETs show superior switching performance compared to Si IGBTs, it is unknown whether SiC MOSFETs have the same advantage over Si super junction (SJ) MOSFETs such as CoolMOS. This paper analyzes the switching performance in different switching cell configurations and summarizes the impact factors that influence switching loss. A double pulse test is conducted for a SiC MOSFET and a CoolMOS with the same voltage and current rating. In the FET/ diode cell structure, a SiC Schottky diode is used as the upper device to eliminate the reverse recovery, and the testing results show that the SiC MOSFET has 2.4 times higher switching loss than the Si CoolMOS. This can be explained by the smaller transconductance and the higher Miller voltage of the SiC MOSFET. On the other hand, the Si CooMOS has 10 times higher switching loss than the SiC MOSFET in the FET/FET cell structure because of the significant turn-on loss caused by the poor reverse recovery of its body diode.